书评

IF 0.5 4区 地球科学 Q4 GEOLOGY
C. Braithwaite
{"title":"书评","authors":"C. Braithwaite","doi":"10.1144/sjg2019-021","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"Sedimentary structures were one of the features that drew this reviewer to the study of Sedimentology. They are, perhaps, the most eloquent among the many details observed in rocks, speaking to us about their conditions of deposition and the environment in which this occurred. If that seems a touch anthropomorphic, well, they talk to me! This is an impressive volume, well presented on good quality paper, and a credit to the publishers. It resembled a ‘Coffee-Table book’, but this is not a criticism, the use of this term is fully justified by countless high quality colour images and prolific line illustrations of the features discussed. Pick it up, these catch the eye, and encourage further investigation. The photographs leave no doubt about the identity of the structures and the diagrams explain, with some help from the text, how and why they form. Good illustrations are not a trivial issue, so often students asked to illustrate features appear to see something quite different! There is a brief introduction to each chapter, and each includes sections on study techniques, recommended field and laboratory experience, and references. There are two novel features. The authors commonly describe simple experiments that would allow the reader to observe the effects discussed for themselves. Unusually, the references that follow chapters are limited to the names and dates of the work, but each has a brief critique of what the article cited offers to the topic addressed. Traditional bibliographic references for all chapters appear at the end of the volume. There are ten chapters, varying in length according to the material they contain. An Introduction to the study of sedimentary structures (5 pp) discusses the origins, principles, and aims of the science of sedimentology and reading is recommended. The discussion follows the various philosophical views, and principles, that have shaped sedimentology in particular, Actualism, the Uniformitarianism promoted by Lyell, and the Catastrophism espoused by Cuvier, and we see how these shaped the ways in which we look at sedimentary rocks. From the outset, the authors adopt a personal approach, addressing the reader directly and encouraging methodical observation and analysis. The core of the book is represented by six chapters, on Bedding (14 pp), the Basic properties of fluids, flows and sediment (24 pp), Erosional structures (relating principally to turbidite deposits, 21 pp), Depositional structures in muds, mudstones and shales (6 pp), Depositional structures of sands and sandstones (71pp), and Depositional structures in gravels, conglomerates and breccias (26 pp). These describe the characteristics of flow, and how sediments move, and generate structures ranging from ripples to large scale cross bedding. These stretch across a range of environments, from subaerial fluvial and aeolian deposits, to shallow storm deposits, bars, channels and deltas, and deep-water turbidite fans. Although the account includes the mathematical expressions for Reynolds and Froude numbers, wave velocity, and Stokes Law, that underlie behaviour, the reader is able to gain a good understanding of the processes involved without these details. The descriptions are clear and the illustrations and diagrams excellent. The book is worth buying for this section alone. The chapter on Depositional structures of chemical and biological origin (20pp) is disappointing. The account of evaporites is good, again with good illustrations, but sections relating to carbonate rocks are poor, containing errors and omissions and lack the structure of the rest of the book. There is no detailed description of stylolites. The following chapter reverts to the more typical high standards of the work with a description of structures due to deformation and disturbance (67 pp). These relate principally to sands and finer-grained sediments, reflecting physical, chemical and biological processes. Features range from structures resulting from liquefaction to large-scale slumps, diapirs and gravity collapse. There is a relatively brief section on nodules but a comprehensive description of biogenic sedimentary structures. The final chapter considers Assemblages of structures and their environmental interpretation (21 pp). It explains how structures may be used to establish the nature of processes and their spatial and temporal relationships, using palaeoflows and wave movements to characterize palaeoenvironments. Six Appendices provide advice on how to collect, display, analyse and interpret directional data, and sample and preserve unconsolidated sediments; together with methods for the study of present-day environments; techniques for the study of trace fossils; and techniques for sedimentary logging, with illustrations of graphic keys to common lithologies and structures. There is an extensive bibliography (12.5 pp) and a helpful Index (19 pp). So, for whom is the book intended? In the author’s view, it is primarily for Earth scientists, but non-specialists from other subject areas are expected to benefit also, where an understanding of sedimentary structures and environments is of value. It provides awell-organized account of how features form and what they mean at scales ranging from sand grains to sedimentary basins. Although written in an understandable manner, the level of detail goes beyond that which might be expected in a book aimed at undergraduates, or even early postgraduates. However, in my view, this should not deter readers from other backgrounds. It guides even the novice to a deeper understanding of the significance of the features described and, given the costs of many books today, it","PeriodicalId":49556,"journal":{"name":"Scottish Journal of Geology","volume":"55 1","pages":"179 - 180"},"PeriodicalIF":0.5000,"publicationDate":"2019-09-20","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":"{\"title\":\"Book Review\",\"authors\":\"C. Braithwaite\",\"doi\":\"10.1144/sjg2019-021\",\"DOIUrl\":null,\"url\":null,\"abstract\":\"Sedimentary structures were one of the features that drew this reviewer to the study of Sedimentology. They are, perhaps, the most eloquent among the many details observed in rocks, speaking to us about their conditions of deposition and the environment in which this occurred. If that seems a touch anthropomorphic, well, they talk to me! This is an impressive volume, well presented on good quality paper, and a credit to the publishers. It resembled a ‘Coffee-Table book’, but this is not a criticism, the use of this term is fully justified by countless high quality colour images and prolific line illustrations of the features discussed. Pick it up, these catch the eye, and encourage further investigation. The photographs leave no doubt about the identity of the structures and the diagrams explain, with some help from the text, how and why they form. Good illustrations are not a trivial issue, so often students asked to illustrate features appear to see something quite different! There is a brief introduction to each chapter, and each includes sections on study techniques, recommended field and laboratory experience, and references. There are two novel features. The authors commonly describe simple experiments that would allow the reader to observe the effects discussed for themselves. Unusually, the references that follow chapters are limited to the names and dates of the work, but each has a brief critique of what the article cited offers to the topic addressed. Traditional bibliographic references for all chapters appear at the end of the volume. There are ten chapters, varying in length according to the material they contain. An Introduction to the study of sedimentary structures (5 pp) discusses the origins, principles, and aims of the science of sedimentology and reading is recommended. The discussion follows the various philosophical views, and principles, that have shaped sedimentology in particular, Actualism, the Uniformitarianism promoted by Lyell, and the Catastrophism espoused by Cuvier, and we see how these shaped the ways in which we look at sedimentary rocks. From the outset, the authors adopt a personal approach, addressing the reader directly and encouraging methodical observation and analysis. The core of the book is represented by six chapters, on Bedding (14 pp), the Basic properties of fluids, flows and sediment (24 pp), Erosional structures (relating principally to turbidite deposits, 21 pp), Depositional structures in muds, mudstones and shales (6 pp), Depositional structures of sands and sandstones (71pp), and Depositional structures in gravels, conglomerates and breccias (26 pp). These describe the characteristics of flow, and how sediments move, and generate structures ranging from ripples to large scale cross bedding. These stretch across a range of environments, from subaerial fluvial and aeolian deposits, to shallow storm deposits, bars, channels and deltas, and deep-water turbidite fans. Although the account includes the mathematical expressions for Reynolds and Froude numbers, wave velocity, and Stokes Law, that underlie behaviour, the reader is able to gain a good understanding of the processes involved without these details. The descriptions are clear and the illustrations and diagrams excellent. The book is worth buying for this section alone. The chapter on Depositional structures of chemical and biological origin (20pp) is disappointing. The account of evaporites is good, again with good illustrations, but sections relating to carbonate rocks are poor, containing errors and omissions and lack the structure of the rest of the book. There is no detailed description of stylolites. The following chapter reverts to the more typical high standards of the work with a description of structures due to deformation and disturbance (67 pp). These relate principally to sands and finer-grained sediments, reflecting physical, chemical and biological processes. Features range from structures resulting from liquefaction to large-scale slumps, diapirs and gravity collapse. There is a relatively brief section on nodules but a comprehensive description of biogenic sedimentary structures. The final chapter considers Assemblages of structures and their environmental interpretation (21 pp). It explains how structures may be used to establish the nature of processes and their spatial and temporal relationships, using palaeoflows and wave movements to characterize palaeoenvironments. Six Appendices provide advice on how to collect, display, analyse and interpret directional data, and sample and preserve unconsolidated sediments; together with methods for the study of present-day environments; techniques for the study of trace fossils; and techniques for sedimentary logging, with illustrations of graphic keys to common lithologies and structures. There is an extensive bibliography (12.5 pp) and a helpful Index (19 pp). So, for whom is the book intended? In the author’s view, it is primarily for Earth scientists, but non-specialists from other subject areas are expected to benefit also, where an understanding of sedimentary structures and environments is of value. It provides awell-organized account of how features form and what they mean at scales ranging from sand grains to sedimentary basins. Although written in an understandable manner, the level of detail goes beyond that which might be expected in a book aimed at undergraduates, or even early postgraduates. However, in my view, this should not deter readers from other backgrounds. It guides even the novice to a deeper understanding of the significance of the features described and, given the costs of many books today, it\",\"PeriodicalId\":49556,\"journal\":{\"name\":\"Scottish Journal of Geology\",\"volume\":\"55 1\",\"pages\":\"179 - 180\"},\"PeriodicalIF\":0.5000,\"publicationDate\":\"2019-09-20\",\"publicationTypes\":\"Journal Article\",\"fieldsOfStudy\":null,\"isOpenAccess\":false,\"openAccessPdf\":\"\",\"citationCount\":\"0\",\"resultStr\":null,\"platform\":\"Semanticscholar\",\"paperid\":null,\"PeriodicalName\":\"Scottish Journal of Geology\",\"FirstCategoryId\":\"89\",\"ListUrlMain\":\"https://doi.org/10.1144/sjg2019-021\",\"RegionNum\":4,\"RegionCategory\":\"地球科学\",\"ArticlePicture\":[],\"TitleCN\":null,\"AbstractTextCN\":null,\"PMCID\":null,\"EPubDate\":\"\",\"PubModel\":\"\",\"JCR\":\"Q4\",\"JCRName\":\"GEOLOGY\",\"Score\":null,\"Total\":0}","platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Scottish Journal of Geology","FirstCategoryId":"89","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.1144/sjg2019-021","RegionNum":4,"RegionCategory":"地球科学","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"Q4","JCRName":"GEOLOGY","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0

摘要

沉积结构是吸引这位评论家进行沉积学研究的特征之一。在岩石中观察到的许多细节中,它们可能是最雄辩的,向我们讲述了它们的沉积条件和发生沉积的环境。如果这看起来有点拟人化,那么,他们会和我说话!这是一本令人印象深刻的书,在高质量的纸上呈现得很好,值得出版商称赞。它类似于一本“咖啡桌书”,但这并不是一种批评,无数高质量的彩色图像和所讨论特征的大量线条插图充分证明了这个术语的使用是合理的。拿起它,这些吸引眼球,并鼓励进一步的调查。照片让人对结构的身份毫无疑问,图表在文本的帮助下解释了它们是如何形成的以及为什么形成的。好的插图不是一个微不足道的问题,所以经常被要求说明特征的学生似乎看到了完全不同的东西!每章都有一个简短的介绍,每章都包括关于研究技术、推荐的领域和实验室经验以及参考文献的章节。有两个新颖的特点。作者通常描述一些简单的实验,让读者自己观察所讨论的效果。不同寻常的是,章节后面的参考文献仅限于作品的名称和日期,但每一章都对文章引用的内容进行了简短的评论。所有章节的传统参考书目都出现在本卷末尾。共有十章,根据所含材料的不同,篇幅各不相同。沉积构造研究导论(5页)讨论了沉积学的起源、原理和目的,并推荐阅读。讨论遵循了各种哲学观点和原则,这些观点和原则塑造了沉积学,特别是现实主义、莱尔倡导的统一主义和居维叶支持的灾难主义,我们看到了这些观点和原理是如何塑造我们看待沉积岩的方式的。从一开始,作者就采用了个人的方法,直接向读者讲话,并鼓励有条理的观察和分析。该书的核心由六章组成,分别是层理(14页)、流体、流动和沉积物的基本性质(24页)、侵蚀结构(主要与浊积岩矿床有关,21页)、泥岩、泥岩和页岩中的沉积结构(6页)、砂和砂岩的沉积结构,砾岩和角砾岩(26页)。这些描述了水流的特征,以及沉积物如何移动,并产生从波纹到大规模交错层理的结构。这些分布在一系列环境中,从陆上河流和风成沉积,到浅层风暴沉积、坝、河道和三角洲,以及深水浊积扇。尽管该描述包括雷诺数和弗劳德数、波速和斯托克斯定律的数学表达式,这些都是行为的基础,但读者能够在没有这些细节的情况下很好地理解所涉及的过程。描述清晰,插图和图表非常好。仅就这一部分而言,这本书就值得购买。关于化学和生物成因沉积结构的章节(第20页)令人失望。蒸发岩的描述很好,同样有很好的插图,但与碳酸盐岩有关的章节很差,包含错误和遗漏,缺乏本书其余部分的结构。没有关于缝合岩的详细描述。下一章通过对变形和扰动引起的结构的描述,回到了更典型的高标准工作(第67页)。这些主要与沙子和细粒沉积物有关,反映了物理、化学和生物过程。特征包括液化产生的结构、大规模滑塌、底辟和重力坍塌。关于结核有一个相对简短的部分,但对生物成因沉积结构有一个全面的描述。最后一章考虑了结构的组合及其环境解释(第21页)。它解释了如何利用结构来确定过程的性质及其空间和时间关系,利用古水流和波浪运动来表征古环境。六个附录就如何收集、显示、分析和解释定向数据、采样和保存未固结沉积物提供了建议;以及研究当今环境的方法;痕迹化石研究技术;以及沉积测井技术,并附有常见岩性和结构的图解键。有一个广泛的参考书目(12.5页)和一个有用的索引(19页)。 那么,这本书是为谁写的呢?在作者看来,这主要是为了地球科学家,但来自其他学科领域的非专家也有望受益,因为在这些领域,对沉积结构和环境的了解是有价值的。它对从沙粒到沉积盆地的各种尺度上的特征是如何形成的以及它们的含义进行了有组织的描述。尽管以一种可以理解的方式写作,但其细节程度超出了一本针对本科生甚至早期研究生的书的预期。然而,在我看来,这不应该阻止其他背景的读者。它甚至引导新手更深入地理解所描述的功能的重要性,考虑到当今许多书籍的成本,它
本文章由计算机程序翻译,如有差异,请以英文原文为准。
Book Review
Sedimentary structures were one of the features that drew this reviewer to the study of Sedimentology. They are, perhaps, the most eloquent among the many details observed in rocks, speaking to us about their conditions of deposition and the environment in which this occurred. If that seems a touch anthropomorphic, well, they talk to me! This is an impressive volume, well presented on good quality paper, and a credit to the publishers. It resembled a ‘Coffee-Table book’, but this is not a criticism, the use of this term is fully justified by countless high quality colour images and prolific line illustrations of the features discussed. Pick it up, these catch the eye, and encourage further investigation. The photographs leave no doubt about the identity of the structures and the diagrams explain, with some help from the text, how and why they form. Good illustrations are not a trivial issue, so often students asked to illustrate features appear to see something quite different! There is a brief introduction to each chapter, and each includes sections on study techniques, recommended field and laboratory experience, and references. There are two novel features. The authors commonly describe simple experiments that would allow the reader to observe the effects discussed for themselves. Unusually, the references that follow chapters are limited to the names and dates of the work, but each has a brief critique of what the article cited offers to the topic addressed. Traditional bibliographic references for all chapters appear at the end of the volume. There are ten chapters, varying in length according to the material they contain. An Introduction to the study of sedimentary structures (5 pp) discusses the origins, principles, and aims of the science of sedimentology and reading is recommended. The discussion follows the various philosophical views, and principles, that have shaped sedimentology in particular, Actualism, the Uniformitarianism promoted by Lyell, and the Catastrophism espoused by Cuvier, and we see how these shaped the ways in which we look at sedimentary rocks. From the outset, the authors adopt a personal approach, addressing the reader directly and encouraging methodical observation and analysis. The core of the book is represented by six chapters, on Bedding (14 pp), the Basic properties of fluids, flows and sediment (24 pp), Erosional structures (relating principally to turbidite deposits, 21 pp), Depositional structures in muds, mudstones and shales (6 pp), Depositional structures of sands and sandstones (71pp), and Depositional structures in gravels, conglomerates and breccias (26 pp). These describe the characteristics of flow, and how sediments move, and generate structures ranging from ripples to large scale cross bedding. These stretch across a range of environments, from subaerial fluvial and aeolian deposits, to shallow storm deposits, bars, channels and deltas, and deep-water turbidite fans. Although the account includes the mathematical expressions for Reynolds and Froude numbers, wave velocity, and Stokes Law, that underlie behaviour, the reader is able to gain a good understanding of the processes involved without these details. The descriptions are clear and the illustrations and diagrams excellent. The book is worth buying for this section alone. The chapter on Depositional structures of chemical and biological origin (20pp) is disappointing. The account of evaporites is good, again with good illustrations, but sections relating to carbonate rocks are poor, containing errors and omissions and lack the structure of the rest of the book. There is no detailed description of stylolites. The following chapter reverts to the more typical high standards of the work with a description of structures due to deformation and disturbance (67 pp). These relate principally to sands and finer-grained sediments, reflecting physical, chemical and biological processes. Features range from structures resulting from liquefaction to large-scale slumps, diapirs and gravity collapse. There is a relatively brief section on nodules but a comprehensive description of biogenic sedimentary structures. The final chapter considers Assemblages of structures and their environmental interpretation (21 pp). It explains how structures may be used to establish the nature of processes and their spatial and temporal relationships, using palaeoflows and wave movements to characterize palaeoenvironments. Six Appendices provide advice on how to collect, display, analyse and interpret directional data, and sample and preserve unconsolidated sediments; together with methods for the study of present-day environments; techniques for the study of trace fossils; and techniques for sedimentary logging, with illustrations of graphic keys to common lithologies and structures. There is an extensive bibliography (12.5 pp) and a helpful Index (19 pp). So, for whom is the book intended? In the author’s view, it is primarily for Earth scientists, but non-specialists from other subject areas are expected to benefit also, where an understanding of sedimentary structures and environments is of value. It provides awell-organized account of how features form and what they mean at scales ranging from sand grains to sedimentary basins. Although written in an understandable manner, the level of detail goes beyond that which might be expected in a book aimed at undergraduates, or even early postgraduates. However, in my view, this should not deter readers from other backgrounds. It guides even the novice to a deeper understanding of the significance of the features described and, given the costs of many books today, it
求助全文
通过发布文献求助,成功后即可免费获取论文全文。 去求助
来源期刊
Scottish Journal of Geology
Scottish Journal of Geology 地学-地质学
CiteScore
1.70
自引率
0.00%
发文量
10
审稿时长
>12 weeks
期刊介绍: Although published only since 1965, the Scottish Journal of Geology has a long pedigree. It is the joint publication of the Geological Society of Glasgow and the Edinburgh Geological Society, which prior to 1965 published separate Transactions: from 1860 in the case of Glasgow and 1863 for Edinburgh. Traditionally, the Journal has acted as the focus for papers on all aspects of Scottish geology and its contiguous areas, including the surrounding seas. The publication policy has always been outward looking, with the Editors encouraging review papers and papers on broader aspects of the Earth sciences that cannot be discussed solely in terms of Scottish geology. The diverse geology of Scotland continues to provide an important natural laboratory for the study of earth sciences; many seminal studies in geology have been carried out on Scottish rocks, and over the years the results of much of this work had been published in the Journal and its predecessors. The Journal fully deserves its high reputation worldwide and intends to maintain its status in the front rank of publications in the Earth sciences.
×
引用
GB/T 7714-2015
复制
MLA
复制
APA
复制
导出至
BibTeX EndNote RefMan NoteFirst NoteExpress
×
提示
您的信息不完整,为了账户安全,请先补充。
现在去补充
×
提示
您因"违规操作"
具体请查看互助需知
我知道了
×
提示
确定
请完成安全验证×
copy
已复制链接
快去分享给好友吧!
我知道了
右上角分享
点击右上角分享
0
联系我们:info@booksci.cn Book学术提供免费学术资源搜索服务,方便国内外学者检索中英文文献。致力于提供最便捷和优质的服务体验。 Copyright © 2023 布克学术 All rights reserved.
京ICP备2023020795号-1
ghs 京公网安备 11010802042870号
Book学术文献互助
Book学术文献互助群
群 号:481959085
Book学术官方微信