Phosphorus limitation in low nitrogen lakes in New Zealand

ABSTRACT Lakes on volcanic soils of the North Island of New Zealand, compared to north temperate lakes, have low total nitrogen:total phosphorus (TN:TP) ratios, low dissolved inorganic nitrogen concentrations during summer stratification, and have positive chlorophyll a responses to N additions more frequently than to P in nutrient enrichment bioassays. This response has resulted, in some cases, to the imposition of N loading caps on some lake catchments, in contrast to nutrient management in north temperate lakes focused more on P management. To explore this possible difference in limiting nutrients, a suite of nutrient status indicators based on measurement of ambient seston stoichiometry and metabolic activity, which have been widely used in north temperate lakes, were applied to 8 lakes on volcanic terrain with previously reported N limitation. These nutrient status measurements were previously calibrated to inform whether in situ phytoplankton are growth-rate limited and, if so, which nutrient is limiting growth rate. In austral summer 2015, all 8 lakes showed indications of P limitation, and P limitation was more extreme, pervasive, and persistent (among samplings) than N limitation. Indications of N limitation were not observed without contemporaneous evidence of P limitation, but P limitation was frequently observed without evidence of N limitation. One lake, Rotorua, was not strongly nutrient limited, and phytoplankton were likely growing at or near optimum growth rates. In this study the commonly used TN:TP ratio was a poor predictor of which nutrient was potentially limiting in situ phytoplankton.