Evolution of sexual dimorphism in an endemic toad of the Qinghai–Tibet plateau fails to obey Rensch’s rule

According to Rensch's rule, sexual size dimorphism (SSD) decreases with increasing body size in species where females are larger than males, whereas SSD increases with body size when males are larger than females. In this study, we examined body size from 15 populations of Bufo minshanicus in the Qinghai–Tibet plateau in China. We estimated the age of the individuals from eight populations to evaluate Rensch's rule and possible causes of variation in SSD. After or before correcting male and female body size for age differences, the patterns of SSD failed to obey Rensch's rule or its inverse, even though fecundity selection in toads tends to favor larger female body size. We also found that the degree of SSD was positively correlated with the operational sex ratio in the field across B. minshanicus populations. Thus, sexual and fecundity selection play an equal role driving the evolution of SSD within toads. In addition, sex-specific growth rate and age structure explain part of the variation observed in SSD across populations.