Clara Mendoza-Lera, Sadhbh Juarez-Bourke, Núria Catalán, Anna Lupon
{"title":"学术界的性别角色谈判:大胆探索","authors":"Clara Mendoza-Lera, Sadhbh Juarez-Bourke, Núria Catalán, Anna Lupon","doi":"10.1002/lob.10563","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"Although the situation of female limnologists has improved in several aspects since the 20th century, gender-specific barriers and biases persist (Catal an et al. 2022). Unless these barriers are spotted and remedied, female scientists will remain as prominent casualties. In an effort to learn and raise awareness of the barriers and biases faced by women across the limnological community, the Gender and Science group (genderlimno.org) of the Iberian Society of Limnology (AIL) organized three activities during the 36th Congress of the International Society of Limnology (https://www.sil2022.org/) in Berlin, Germany (07–10 August 2022): (1) the workshop “Negotiating gender roles in academia—A courageous exploration”; (2) the exhibition “Women in Limnology”; and (3) the special session “Past, present and future of the herstory of limnology”. Here, we summarize the highlights and insights gained in that meeting and share what we see as the way forward. The workshop “Negotiating gender roles in academia—A courageous exploration” was facilitated by Sadhbh Ju arez-Bourke (connectingacademia.com; s.juarez.bourke@gmail.com), an intercultural facilitator, cultural coach, and sustainability scientist . The workshop was an invitation to explore gender roles, not from our usual intellectual perspective, but from the knowledge of the body (Fig. 1). Our body is the vehicle to our emotional experience, through which we experience the world and interpret objective reality (Jung et al. 2017). The purpose was to create a space to witness each other’s reality when it comes to gender roles with empathy, compassion, and humor, regardless of gender, political inclinations, or personal convictions. Through playful exercises we gently transitioned from the head-space we usually inhabit to being present in our body. From here, we explored our gender identity and roles within academia, allowing each participant their individual, private realizations. When coming back to share with the group, we found ourselves in a space of dialogue grounded in our authentic needs, rather than discussion framed by ideology. One of the workshop participants, Jun. Prof. E. Berger, kindly shared with us: “I have talked, read and thought so many times about gender inequality in society and academia in specific, growing tired of the debate. It was a great experience not to talk and exchange clever arguments with others, but to simply concentrate on how things feel and share those feelings. It was refreshing to let the body talk instead of the mind. The workshop weaved a subtle net of understanding and compassion between its participants that remained present during the duration of the conference.” The exhibition “Women in Limnology” consisted of a series of eight panels that were displayed during the conference (https://www. genderlimno.org/exhibition.html). The exhibition was developed in 2018 by more than 20 volunteers of the AIL Gender and Science group and has been displayed all over Europe in universities and research centers and can be requested via the website. The exhibition invites the reader to travel over the history, current situation, and future for female scientists in limnology. It aims to celebrate and increase visibility of women limnologists, recognize the efforts of the pioneers, provide a gender perspective to the historical development of our field, and show current inequalities as well as advances in reducing gender bias. The special session on “Past, present and future of the herstory of limnology” welcomed contributions that discussed key vulnerabilities that challenge women’s careers in limnology, and that identified activities, strategies, and solutionbased approaches promoting visibility and participation of women at all career stages. The session hosted three talks about actions to promote an inclusive “fair” science (Mendoza-Lera and Knäbel 2023), inclusivity in conferences (Lupon et al. 2021), and prospects of women in limnology (Catal an et al. 2022; Fig. 2). Because the topics were interrelated, they were presented","PeriodicalId":40008,"journal":{"name":"Limnology and Oceanography Bulletin","volume":null,"pages":null},"PeriodicalIF":0.0000,"publicationDate":"2023-03-31","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":"{\"title\":\"Negotiating Gender Roles in Academia: A Courageous Exploration\",\"authors\":\"Clara Mendoza-Lera, Sadhbh Juarez-Bourke, Núria Catalán, Anna Lupon\",\"doi\":\"10.1002/lob.10563\",\"DOIUrl\":null,\"url\":null,\"abstract\":\"Although the situation of female limnologists has improved in several aspects since the 20th century, gender-specific barriers and biases persist (Catal an et al. 2022). Unless these barriers are spotted and remedied, female scientists will remain as prominent casualties. In an effort to learn and raise awareness of the barriers and biases faced by women across the limnological community, the Gender and Science group (genderlimno.org) of the Iberian Society of Limnology (AIL) organized three activities during the 36th Congress of the International Society of Limnology (https://www.sil2022.org/) in Berlin, Germany (07–10 August 2022): (1) the workshop “Negotiating gender roles in academia—A courageous exploration”; (2) the exhibition “Women in Limnology”; and (3) the special session “Past, present and future of the herstory of limnology”. Here, we summarize the highlights and insights gained in that meeting and share what we see as the way forward. The workshop “Negotiating gender roles in academia—A courageous exploration” was facilitated by Sadhbh Ju arez-Bourke (connectingacademia.com; s.juarez.bourke@gmail.com), an intercultural facilitator, cultural coach, and sustainability scientist . The workshop was an invitation to explore gender roles, not from our usual intellectual perspective, but from the knowledge of the body (Fig. 1). Our body is the vehicle to our emotional experience, through which we experience the world and interpret objective reality (Jung et al. 2017). The purpose was to create a space to witness each other’s reality when it comes to gender roles with empathy, compassion, and humor, regardless of gender, political inclinations, or personal convictions. Through playful exercises we gently transitioned from the head-space we usually inhabit to being present in our body. From here, we explored our gender identity and roles within academia, allowing each participant their individual, private realizations. When coming back to share with the group, we found ourselves in a space of dialogue grounded in our authentic needs, rather than discussion framed by ideology. One of the workshop participants, Jun. Prof. E. Berger, kindly shared with us: “I have talked, read and thought so many times about gender inequality in society and academia in specific, growing tired of the debate. It was a great experience not to talk and exchange clever arguments with others, but to simply concentrate on how things feel and share those feelings. It was refreshing to let the body talk instead of the mind. The workshop weaved a subtle net of understanding and compassion between its participants that remained present during the duration of the conference.” The exhibition “Women in Limnology” consisted of a series of eight panels that were displayed during the conference (https://www. genderlimno.org/exhibition.html). The exhibition was developed in 2018 by more than 20 volunteers of the AIL Gender and Science group and has been displayed all over Europe in universities and research centers and can be requested via the website. The exhibition invites the reader to travel over the history, current situation, and future for female scientists in limnology. It aims to celebrate and increase visibility of women limnologists, recognize the efforts of the pioneers, provide a gender perspective to the historical development of our field, and show current inequalities as well as advances in reducing gender bias. The special session on “Past, present and future of the herstory of limnology” welcomed contributions that discussed key vulnerabilities that challenge women’s careers in limnology, and that identified activities, strategies, and solutionbased approaches promoting visibility and participation of women at all career stages. The session hosted three talks about actions to promote an inclusive “fair” science (Mendoza-Lera and Knäbel 2023), inclusivity in conferences (Lupon et al. 2021), and prospects of women in limnology (Catal an et al. 2022; Fig. 2). Because the topics were interrelated, they were presented\",\"PeriodicalId\":40008,\"journal\":{\"name\":\"Limnology and Oceanography Bulletin\",\"volume\":null,\"pages\":null},\"PeriodicalIF\":0.0000,\"publicationDate\":\"2023-03-31\",\"publicationTypes\":\"Journal Article\",\"fieldsOfStudy\":null,\"isOpenAccess\":false,\"openAccessPdf\":\"\",\"citationCount\":\"0\",\"resultStr\":null,\"platform\":\"Semanticscholar\",\"paperid\":null,\"PeriodicalName\":\"Limnology and Oceanography Bulletin\",\"FirstCategoryId\":\"1085\",\"ListUrlMain\":\"https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/lob.10563\",\"RegionNum\":0,\"RegionCategory\":null,\"ArticlePicture\":[],\"TitleCN\":null,\"AbstractTextCN\":null,\"PMCID\":null,\"EPubDate\":\"\",\"PubModel\":\"\",\"JCR\":\"\",\"JCRName\":\"\",\"Score\":null,\"Total\":0}","platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Limnology and Oceanography Bulletin","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/lob.10563","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"","JCRName":"","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
摘要
尽管自20世纪以来,女性湖泊学家的状况在几个方面有所改善,但针对性别的障碍和偏见依然存在(Catal an等人,2022)。除非发现并弥补这些障碍,否则女性科学家仍将是主要的受害者。为了了解和提高对整个湖沼学界妇女面临的障碍和偏见的认识,伊比利亚湖沼学学会的性别与科学小组(genderlinno.org)在国际湖沼学协会第36届大会期间组织了三项活动(https://www.sil2022.org/)在德国柏林(2022年8月7日至10日):(1)“协商学术界的性别角色——一次勇敢的探索”研讨会;(2) “湖沼学中的女性”展览;以及(3)“湖泊学史的过去、现在和未来”特别会议。在这里,我们总结了这次会议的亮点和见解,并分享了我们认为的前进道路。Sadhbh Ju arez Bourke(connectingacademia.com;s.juarez.bourke@gmail.com),跨文化促进者、文化教练和可持续发展科学家。研讨会邀请我们探讨性别角色,不是从我们通常的智力角度,而是从身体的知识角度(图1)。我们的身体是我们情感体验的载体,通过它我们体验世界并解释客观现实(Jung等人,2017)。其目的是创造一个空间,在涉及性别角色时,无论性别、政治倾向或个人信念如何,都能以同理心、同情心和幽默见证彼此的现实。通过有趣的锻炼,我们从通常居住的头部空间慢慢过渡到了身体中。从这里开始,我们探索了我们在学术界的性别认同和角色,让每个参与者都有自己的私人认识。当我们回来与团队分享时,我们发现自己处于一个基于真实需求的对话空间,而不是意识形态框架下的讨论。研讨会参与者之一E.Berger教授,亲切地与我们分享:“我多次谈论、阅读和思考社会和学术界的性别不平等问题,对这场辩论感到厌倦。不与他人交谈和交换巧妙的论点,而是专注于事情的感受并分享这些感受,这是一次很棒的经历。让身体而不是头脑说话让人耳目一新g以及在会议期间仍然在场的与会者之间的同情。”“湖沼学中的女性”展览由会议期间展出的八个小组组成(https://www.该展览由AIL性别与科学小组的20多名志愿者于2018年开发,已在欧洲各地的大学和研究中心展出,可通过网站申请。展览邀请读者游历湖沼学女性科学家的历史、现状和未来。它旨在庆祝和提高女性湖沼学家的知名度,表彰先驱们的努力,为我们领域的历史发展提供性别视角,并展示当前的不平等现象以及在减少性别偏见方面取得的进展。关于“湖泊学历史的过去、现在和未来”的特别会议欢迎与会者讨论了挑战妇女湖泊学职业生涯的关键脆弱性,并确定了促进妇女在所有职业阶段的知名度和参与的活动、战略和基于解决方案的方法。会议举办了三场关于促进包容性“公平”科学的行动(Mendoza Lera和Knäbel 2023)、会议包容性(Lupon等人,2021)和妇女在湖沼学领域的前景(Catal an等人,2022;图2)。由于这些主题是相互关联的,所以介绍了它们
Negotiating Gender Roles in Academia: A Courageous Exploration
Although the situation of female limnologists has improved in several aspects since the 20th century, gender-specific barriers and biases persist (Catal an et al. 2022). Unless these barriers are spotted and remedied, female scientists will remain as prominent casualties. In an effort to learn and raise awareness of the barriers and biases faced by women across the limnological community, the Gender and Science group (genderlimno.org) of the Iberian Society of Limnology (AIL) organized three activities during the 36th Congress of the International Society of Limnology (https://www.sil2022.org/) in Berlin, Germany (07–10 August 2022): (1) the workshop “Negotiating gender roles in academia—A courageous exploration”; (2) the exhibition “Women in Limnology”; and (3) the special session “Past, present and future of the herstory of limnology”. Here, we summarize the highlights and insights gained in that meeting and share what we see as the way forward. The workshop “Negotiating gender roles in academia—A courageous exploration” was facilitated by Sadhbh Ju arez-Bourke (connectingacademia.com; s.juarez.bourke@gmail.com), an intercultural facilitator, cultural coach, and sustainability scientist . The workshop was an invitation to explore gender roles, not from our usual intellectual perspective, but from the knowledge of the body (Fig. 1). Our body is the vehicle to our emotional experience, through which we experience the world and interpret objective reality (Jung et al. 2017). The purpose was to create a space to witness each other’s reality when it comes to gender roles with empathy, compassion, and humor, regardless of gender, political inclinations, or personal convictions. Through playful exercises we gently transitioned from the head-space we usually inhabit to being present in our body. From here, we explored our gender identity and roles within academia, allowing each participant their individual, private realizations. When coming back to share with the group, we found ourselves in a space of dialogue grounded in our authentic needs, rather than discussion framed by ideology. One of the workshop participants, Jun. Prof. E. Berger, kindly shared with us: “I have talked, read and thought so many times about gender inequality in society and academia in specific, growing tired of the debate. It was a great experience not to talk and exchange clever arguments with others, but to simply concentrate on how things feel and share those feelings. It was refreshing to let the body talk instead of the mind. The workshop weaved a subtle net of understanding and compassion between its participants that remained present during the duration of the conference.” The exhibition “Women in Limnology” consisted of a series of eight panels that were displayed during the conference (https://www. genderlimno.org/exhibition.html). The exhibition was developed in 2018 by more than 20 volunteers of the AIL Gender and Science group and has been displayed all over Europe in universities and research centers and can be requested via the website. The exhibition invites the reader to travel over the history, current situation, and future for female scientists in limnology. It aims to celebrate and increase visibility of women limnologists, recognize the efforts of the pioneers, provide a gender perspective to the historical development of our field, and show current inequalities as well as advances in reducing gender bias. The special session on “Past, present and future of the herstory of limnology” welcomed contributions that discussed key vulnerabilities that challenge women’s careers in limnology, and that identified activities, strategies, and solutionbased approaches promoting visibility and participation of women at all career stages. The session hosted three talks about actions to promote an inclusive “fair” science (Mendoza-Lera and Knäbel 2023), inclusivity in conferences (Lupon et al. 2021), and prospects of women in limnology (Catal an et al. 2022; Fig. 2). Because the topics were interrelated, they were presented
期刊介绍:
All past issues of the Limnology and Oceanography Bulletin are available online, including its predecessors Communications to Members and the ASLO Bulletin. Access to the current and previous volume is restricted to members and institutions with a subscription to the ASLO journals. All other issues are freely accessible without a subscription. As part of ASLO’s mission to disseminate and communicate knowledge in the aquatic sciences.