Comprehensive Optimization of LC-MS Metabolomics Methods Using Design of Experiments (COLMeD).

Introduction: Both reverse-phase and HILIC chemistries are deployed for liquid-chromatography mass spectrometry (LC-MS) metabolomics analyses, however HILIC methods lag behind reverse-phase methods in reproducibility and versatility. Comprehensive metabolomics analysis is additionally complicated by the physiochemical diversity of metabolites and array of tunable analytical parameters.

Objective: Our aim was to rationally and efficiently design complementary HILIC-based polar metabolomics methods on multiple instruments using Design of Experiments (DoE).

Methods: We iteratively tuned LC and MS conditions on ion-switching triple quadrupole (QqQ) and quadrupole-time-of-flight (qTOF) mass spectrometers through multiple rounds of a workflow we term COLMeD (Comprehensive optimization of LC-MS metabolomics methods using design of experiments). Multivariate statistical analysis guided our decision process in the method optimizations.

Results: LC-MS/MS tuning for the QqQ method on serum metabolites yielded a median response increase of 161.5% (p<0.0001) over initial conditions with a 13.3% increase in metabolite coverage. The COLMeD output was benchmarked against two widely used polar metabolomics methods, demonstrating total ion current increases of 105.8% and 57.3%, with median metabolite response increases of 106.1% and 10.3% (p<0.0001 and p<0.05 respectively). For our optimized qTOF method, 22 solvent systems were compared on a standard mix of physiochemically diverse metabolites, followed by COLMeD optimization, yielding a median 29.8% response increase (p<0.0001) over initial conditions.

Conclusions: The COLMeD process elucidated response tradeoffs, facilitating improved chromatography and MS response without compromising separation of isobars. COLMeD is efficient, requiring no more than 20 injections in a given DoE round, and flexible, capable of class-specific optimization as demonstrated through acylcarnitine optimization within the QqQ method.