护士在灾难、战争和冲突中不可或缺的作用:最具挑战性环境中的临床卓越

IF 3.7 3区 医学 Q1 NURSING
John Unsworth
{"title":"护士在灾难、战争和冲突中不可或缺的作用:最具挑战性环境中的临床卓越","authors":"John Unsworth","doi":"10.1111/inr.70114","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"<p>Nurses are an integral element of the global response to healthcare emergencies, whether they are caused by natural disasters, terrorism, armed conflicts or humanitarian crises. In all of these circumstances, the fragility of many countries healthcare system is laid bare and staff are left to cope as front-line providers (Al Thobaity <span>2024</span>). Nurses are major contributors at times of war and disaster as they work not only in the immediate emergency response, but they cope with the psychological and long-term aspects of recovery. When <i>International Nursing Review</i> put out the call for papers for this virtual special issue in 2024, the world had faced unprecedented global disaster challenges. Hurricane Helene and Typhoon Yagi had caused widespread damage, and flooding had also claimed a number of lives in Africa, Spain, Brazil, Bangladesh and India. Other countries were impacted by extreme heat with thousands of people dying in Saudi Arabia, North America and Pakistan. Overall, natural disasters killed more than 16,753 people in 2024, with extreme weather events accounting for the majority of these fatalities (Centre for Research on the Epidemiology of Disasters <span>2024</span>). This figure is staggering as disasters had only claimed 65,566 lives in the previous 20-year period (Centre for Research on the Epidemiology of Disasters <span>2024</span>). It was clear to me and my fellow editors that we needed to think differently about the role of nurses in disasters as many countries were now experiencing significant mass casualty events when disaster competencies were not really embedded in nursing education.</p><p>During disasters, nurses act as first responders, managing triage, stabilizing patients and delivering emergency care. At the same time, colleagues from other non-emergency care areas, such as public health, are ensuring that displaced people with no access to medication are appropriately managed. Wherever care is provided, nurses need ingenuity and resourcefulness in emergency situations in order to deliver care in unusual environments with resource limitations (Veenema <span>2009</span>).</p><p>Nurses have a significant role beyond physical health and immediate emergency care. They address the longer-term impact of disasters on individuals and communities. In the aftermath, nurses deliver psychological first aid and trauma-informed interventions to people impacted by disasters and conflict. The mental health toll of such events on the population is profound, as is the impact on nurses and other healthcare workers. The COVID-19 pandemic has brought into the spotlight the impact of moral insult and injury that having to work in extreme circumstances and having to make challenging ethical decisions has on individuals (Scott et al. <span>2023</span>). Working during disasters and conflict also brings such challenges and we need to ensure the workforce is both resilient and supported to deliver such care (Xue et al. <span>2020</span>). The nursing role also extends in developing community resilience in the period after a disaster as people try to return to some sense of normality. This role requires a different set of skills and knowledge as it involves wider public health interventions, including monitoring for disease and working with communities to rebuild social structures and strengthening community networks (Committee on Post-Disaster Recovery, Institute of Public Health <span>2015</span>).</p><p>It is clear that disasters, either natural or manmade, and other challenges such as emerging infections, bioterrorism and mass casualty events are an ever present threat for many countries around the world. As highlighted earlier, climate change is also causing more extreme weather events, which make natural disasters more frequent and more intense (Vernick <span>2025</span>). It is now common to see ‘once-in-a-lifetime’ events occurring two to three times in a decade. Extreme weather events, excessive heat and drought now affect a number of continents. Weather events such as storms, torrential rain and hurricanes are now more intense than they were previously, fuelled by a rise in global temperatures (Earth Justice <span>2024</span>). At the International Council of Nurses (ICN) Congress in Helsinki, in June 2025, Howard Catton, CEO of the ICN, called on nurses from all countries to pay attention to global crises like climate change and conflict no matter how far removed they seem to be from their own country. This reaffirms that countries need to think differently about disaster competencies for nurses and other health professionals. While such competencies have been embedded for many years in countries that face geological and other threats, every country on earth now faces the threat of disaster because of extreme weather.</p><p>While all disasters bring ethical challenges and psychological trauma for the public and healthcare staff, conflict and war bring extended periods of challenging or intolerable conditions. During conflict, nurses carry a triple burden of caregiving, personal risk and concern about their own families. Despite this, civilian nurses provide care without discrimination, treating the wounded from either side alongside injured civilians. Increasingly, we are seeing attacks on health facilities and healthcare workers during conflict, breaching international humanitarian law. This protection is afforded by the Geneva Convention and associated protocols, and while hospitals can lose such protection if they are used by the enemy for military operations. Despite this position, the International Committee of the Red Cross is clear that the fact that hospitals can lose protection is not a free licence to attack them (ICRC <span>2023</span>). The lack of clarity around how and why facilities can lose their protections is a concern. Increasingly, health facilities are used as a shield, placing healthcare workers and patients at increased risk of attack. My view is that this notion of a hospital ‘carrying out an act harmful to the enemy’ requires urgent clarification, as it is not the facility or the staff who are carrying out the act but the military or terrorist forces who are occupying the facilities. The thought of patients and staff being caught in the crossfire through no fault of their own makes an attack on a facility even more abhorrent. The ICN has called numerous times for the protection of nurses, healthcare workers and facilities, and this was reinforced by a motion of the recent Council of National Nursing Association Representatives at their meeting in June 2025. Despite this, attacks continue in numerous conflict zones, with the notion of military operations taking place in the facilities used as a justification.</p><p>The United Nations outlines how conflict is becoming more entrenched, although the absolute number of deaths as a result of war and conflict has declined year by year since 1946. Yet there is more conflict between groups within countries, as well as notable wars in Europe and the Middle East. Global conflict is now at the highest level since the Second World War (Bowman <span>2025</span>). More nurses than ever before are working in areas affected by conflict or delivering care under repressive regimes. Of course, we should not forget our military colleagues working at the front lines, providing care to injured soldiers. Many of these individuals also work in civilian healthcare services and are no more immune to the challenges that war and conflict bring than their colleagues.</p><p>Recognizing that disasters, war and conflict are becoming increasingly common, what needs to be done to ensure healthcare services are resilient and nurses are well prepared. The International Council of Nurses launched the second version of their disaster nursing core competencies in 2019 (ICN <span>2019</span>). The core competencies cover eight domains from preparation and planning, communication, incident management, safety and security, assessment, intervention, recover and law and ethics. The framework considers three levels of nurses from Level 1, all registered nurses, through to Level 2, a nurse designated in their own organization to supervise and lead the response, and finally Level 3 for a nurse who is part of a deployable team. The core competencies are a useful framework to develop education programmes, and many countries have gone on to integrate Level 1 competencies into pre-registration nursing programmes (Ranse et al. <span>2022</span>; Erkin and Kiyan <span>2025</span>).</p><p>Level 1 preparation is not universal across the world, and the United Nations warned in 2022 that half the world was not prepared for disasters (United Nations Office for Disaster Risk Reduction <span>2022</span>). Many of these countries in the Asia-Pacific region and Africa are prone to extreme weather events and other forms of natural disaster, which often lead to drought, crop failure and famine. Other countries are experiencing increasing events with wildfires and extreme heat, and report feeling less well prepared than they should be, including Portugal, Greece, Spain and Italy (Yanatma <span>2025</span>). It is clear that with the increased risk of disaster and rising conflict, we need to ensure all countries are embedding disaster nursing competencies in initial nurse education as well as preparing practitioners in hospitals and public health to deal with emergencies. Without such preparation, countries will not be able to cope with emergencies arising from extreme weather, natural disasters or conflict.</p><p>This Special Issue brings together a wide collection of published papers around disaster preparedness, exploring system preparation for natural and climate-related disasters. The mass migration of people is a common feature, either within a country or to other countries during war and conflict, and two papers explore displaced populations from Ukraine and Syria. The Special Issue also includes wide-ranging experiences of war and conflict, including an enlightening paper on <i>Voice from Hiding</i>, exploring the work of nurses in Myanmar during the military coup.</p><p>Three papers explore the emerging threats from bioterrorism, mass casualty events caused by extreme heat and nuclear and radiological disasters. Several papers examine the immediate and long-term recovery of the devastating Türkiye–Syria earthquakes.</p><p>The Special Issue also explores disasters through the eyes of various vulnerable populations, including children, newborn infants and mothers, and those with chronic conditions.</p><p>It is abundantly clear that as we enter an era of marked climate emergencies, increasing armed conflict and displaced populations, the role of the nurse must be redefined as central to disaster and crisis response. Countries that have viewed disasters elsewhere need to prepare for climate-related catastrophes within their own borders. At the same time, clarity is needed that it is never acceptable to target health facilities and health workers. Disaster preparedness must be embedded into all nursing programmes, and staff must be adequately prepared and supported throughout their careers. Unless we prepare, we will be doomed to fail, and the people we serve simply deserve better.</p><p>None of the authors have a conflict of interest to disclose.</p>","PeriodicalId":54931,"journal":{"name":"International Nursing Review","volume":"72 4","pages":""},"PeriodicalIF":3.7000,"publicationDate":"2025-10-10","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1111/inr.70114","citationCount":"0","resultStr":"{\"title\":\"The Indispensable Role of Nurses in Disasters, War and Conflict: Clinical Excellence in the Most Challenging Environments\",\"authors\":\"John Unsworth\",\"doi\":\"10.1111/inr.70114\",\"DOIUrl\":null,\"url\":null,\"abstract\":\"<p>Nurses are an integral element of the global response to healthcare emergencies, whether they are caused by natural disasters, terrorism, armed conflicts or humanitarian crises. In all of these circumstances, the fragility of many countries healthcare system is laid bare and staff are left to cope as front-line providers (Al Thobaity <span>2024</span>). Nurses are major contributors at times of war and disaster as they work not only in the immediate emergency response, but they cope with the psychological and long-term aspects of recovery. When <i>International Nursing Review</i> put out the call for papers for this virtual special issue in 2024, the world had faced unprecedented global disaster challenges. Hurricane Helene and Typhoon Yagi had caused widespread damage, and flooding had also claimed a number of lives in Africa, Spain, Brazil, Bangladesh and India. Other countries were impacted by extreme heat with thousands of people dying in Saudi Arabia, North America and Pakistan. Overall, natural disasters killed more than 16,753 people in 2024, with extreme weather events accounting for the majority of these fatalities (Centre for Research on the Epidemiology of Disasters <span>2024</span>). This figure is staggering as disasters had only claimed 65,566 lives in the previous 20-year period (Centre for Research on the Epidemiology of Disasters <span>2024</span>). It was clear to me and my fellow editors that we needed to think differently about the role of nurses in disasters as many countries were now experiencing significant mass casualty events when disaster competencies were not really embedded in nursing education.</p><p>During disasters, nurses act as first responders, managing triage, stabilizing patients and delivering emergency care. At the same time, colleagues from other non-emergency care areas, such as public health, are ensuring that displaced people with no access to medication are appropriately managed. Wherever care is provided, nurses need ingenuity and resourcefulness in emergency situations in order to deliver care in unusual environments with resource limitations (Veenema <span>2009</span>).</p><p>Nurses have a significant role beyond physical health and immediate emergency care. They address the longer-term impact of disasters on individuals and communities. In the aftermath, nurses deliver psychological first aid and trauma-informed interventions to people impacted by disasters and conflict. The mental health toll of such events on the population is profound, as is the impact on nurses and other healthcare workers. The COVID-19 pandemic has brought into the spotlight the impact of moral insult and injury that having to work in extreme circumstances and having to make challenging ethical decisions has on individuals (Scott et al. <span>2023</span>). Working during disasters and conflict also brings such challenges and we need to ensure the workforce is both resilient and supported to deliver such care (Xue et al. <span>2020</span>). The nursing role also extends in developing community resilience in the period after a disaster as people try to return to some sense of normality. This role requires a different set of skills and knowledge as it involves wider public health interventions, including monitoring for disease and working with communities to rebuild social structures and strengthening community networks (Committee on Post-Disaster Recovery, Institute of Public Health <span>2015</span>).</p><p>It is clear that disasters, either natural or manmade, and other challenges such as emerging infections, bioterrorism and mass casualty events are an ever present threat for many countries around the world. As highlighted earlier, climate change is also causing more extreme weather events, which make natural disasters more frequent and more intense (Vernick <span>2025</span>). It is now common to see ‘once-in-a-lifetime’ events occurring two to three times in a decade. Extreme weather events, excessive heat and drought now affect a number of continents. Weather events such as storms, torrential rain and hurricanes are now more intense than they were previously, fuelled by a rise in global temperatures (Earth Justice <span>2024</span>). At the International Council of Nurses (ICN) Congress in Helsinki, in June 2025, Howard Catton, CEO of the ICN, called on nurses from all countries to pay attention to global crises like climate change and conflict no matter how far removed they seem to be from their own country. This reaffirms that countries need to think differently about disaster competencies for nurses and other health professionals. While such competencies have been embedded for many years in countries that face geological and other threats, every country on earth now faces the threat of disaster because of extreme weather.</p><p>While all disasters bring ethical challenges and psychological trauma for the public and healthcare staff, conflict and war bring extended periods of challenging or intolerable conditions. During conflict, nurses carry a triple burden of caregiving, personal risk and concern about their own families. Despite this, civilian nurses provide care without discrimination, treating the wounded from either side alongside injured civilians. Increasingly, we are seeing attacks on health facilities and healthcare workers during conflict, breaching international humanitarian law. This protection is afforded by the Geneva Convention and associated protocols, and while hospitals can lose such protection if they are used by the enemy for military operations. Despite this position, the International Committee of the Red Cross is clear that the fact that hospitals can lose protection is not a free licence to attack them (ICRC <span>2023</span>). The lack of clarity around how and why facilities can lose their protections is a concern. Increasingly, health facilities are used as a shield, placing healthcare workers and patients at increased risk of attack. My view is that this notion of a hospital ‘carrying out an act harmful to the enemy’ requires urgent clarification, as it is not the facility or the staff who are carrying out the act but the military or terrorist forces who are occupying the facilities. The thought of patients and staff being caught in the crossfire through no fault of their own makes an attack on a facility even more abhorrent. The ICN has called numerous times for the protection of nurses, healthcare workers and facilities, and this was reinforced by a motion of the recent Council of National Nursing Association Representatives at their meeting in June 2025. Despite this, attacks continue in numerous conflict zones, with the notion of military operations taking place in the facilities used as a justification.</p><p>The United Nations outlines how conflict is becoming more entrenched, although the absolute number of deaths as a result of war and conflict has declined year by year since 1946. Yet there is more conflict between groups within countries, as well as notable wars in Europe and the Middle East. Global conflict is now at the highest level since the Second World War (Bowman <span>2025</span>). More nurses than ever before are working in areas affected by conflict or delivering care under repressive regimes. Of course, we should not forget our military colleagues working at the front lines, providing care to injured soldiers. Many of these individuals also work in civilian healthcare services and are no more immune to the challenges that war and conflict bring than their colleagues.</p><p>Recognizing that disasters, war and conflict are becoming increasingly common, what needs to be done to ensure healthcare services are resilient and nurses are well prepared. The International Council of Nurses launched the second version of their disaster nursing core competencies in 2019 (ICN <span>2019</span>). The core competencies cover eight domains from preparation and planning, communication, incident management, safety and security, assessment, intervention, recover and law and ethics. The framework considers three levels of nurses from Level 1, all registered nurses, through to Level 2, a nurse designated in their own organization to supervise and lead the response, and finally Level 3 for a nurse who is part of a deployable team. The core competencies are a useful framework to develop education programmes, and many countries have gone on to integrate Level 1 competencies into pre-registration nursing programmes (Ranse et al. <span>2022</span>; Erkin and Kiyan <span>2025</span>).</p><p>Level 1 preparation is not universal across the world, and the United Nations warned in 2022 that half the world was not prepared for disasters (United Nations Office for Disaster Risk Reduction <span>2022</span>). Many of these countries in the Asia-Pacific region and Africa are prone to extreme weather events and other forms of natural disaster, which often lead to drought, crop failure and famine. Other countries are experiencing increasing events with wildfires and extreme heat, and report feeling less well prepared than they should be, including Portugal, Greece, Spain and Italy (Yanatma <span>2025</span>). It is clear that with the increased risk of disaster and rising conflict, we need to ensure all countries are embedding disaster nursing competencies in initial nurse education as well as preparing practitioners in hospitals and public health to deal with emergencies. Without such preparation, countries will not be able to cope with emergencies arising from extreme weather, natural disasters or conflict.</p><p>This Special Issue brings together a wide collection of published papers around disaster preparedness, exploring system preparation for natural and climate-related disasters. The mass migration of people is a common feature, either within a country or to other countries during war and conflict, and two papers explore displaced populations from Ukraine and Syria. The Special Issue also includes wide-ranging experiences of war and conflict, including an enlightening paper on <i>Voice from Hiding</i>, exploring the work of nurses in Myanmar during the military coup.</p><p>Three papers explore the emerging threats from bioterrorism, mass casualty events caused by extreme heat and nuclear and radiological disasters. Several papers examine the immediate and long-term recovery of the devastating Türkiye–Syria earthquakes.</p><p>The Special Issue also explores disasters through the eyes of various vulnerable populations, including children, newborn infants and mothers, and those with chronic conditions.</p><p>It is abundantly clear that as we enter an era of marked climate emergencies, increasing armed conflict and displaced populations, the role of the nurse must be redefined as central to disaster and crisis response. Countries that have viewed disasters elsewhere need to prepare for climate-related catastrophes within their own borders. At the same time, clarity is needed that it is never acceptable to target health facilities and health workers. Disaster preparedness must be embedded into all nursing programmes, and staff must be adequately prepared and supported throughout their careers. Unless we prepare, we will be doomed to fail, and the people we serve simply deserve better.</p><p>None of the authors have a conflict of interest to disclose.</p>\",\"PeriodicalId\":54931,\"journal\":{\"name\":\"International Nursing Review\",\"volume\":\"72 4\",\"pages\":\"\"},\"PeriodicalIF\":3.7000,\"publicationDate\":\"2025-10-10\",\"publicationTypes\":\"Journal Article\",\"fieldsOfStudy\":null,\"isOpenAccess\":false,\"openAccessPdf\":\"https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1111/inr.70114\",\"citationCount\":\"0\",\"resultStr\":null,\"platform\":\"Semanticscholar\",\"paperid\":null,\"PeriodicalName\":\"International Nursing Review\",\"FirstCategoryId\":\"3\",\"ListUrlMain\":\"https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/inr.70114\",\"RegionNum\":3,\"RegionCategory\":\"医学\",\"ArticlePicture\":[],\"TitleCN\":null,\"AbstractTextCN\":null,\"PMCID\":null,\"EPubDate\":\"\",\"PubModel\":\"\",\"JCR\":\"Q1\",\"JCRName\":\"NURSING\",\"Score\":null,\"Total\":0}","platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"International Nursing Review","FirstCategoryId":"3","ListUrlMain":"https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/inr.70114","RegionNum":3,"RegionCategory":"医学","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"Q1","JCRName":"NURSING","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0

摘要

无论是由自然灾害、恐怖主义、武装冲突还是人道主义危机引起的突发卫生事件,护士都是全球应对突发卫生事件不可或缺的组成部分。在所有这些情况下,许多国家卫生保健系统的脆弱性暴露无遗,工作人员只能作为一线提供者应对(Al Thobaity 2024)。在战争和灾难时期,护士是主要的贡献者,因为她们不仅在立即的紧急反应中工作,而且还处理心理和长期恢复方面的问题。当《国际护理评论》在2024年为这期虚拟特刊征集论文时,世界面临着前所未有的全球灾难挑战。飓风“海伦”和台风“八木”造成了广泛的破坏,洪水在非洲、西班牙、巴西、孟加拉国和印度也夺去了许多人的生命。其他国家也受到了极端高温的影响,沙特阿拉伯、北美和巴基斯坦有数千人死亡。总体而言,2024年自然灾害造成的死亡人数超过16753人,其中极端天气事件占大多数(2024年灾害流行病学研究中心)。这一数字令人震惊,因为在过去的20年里,灾害仅夺去了65,566人的生命(2024年灾害流行病学研究中心)。我和我的编辑同事们很清楚,我们需要以不同的方式思考护士在灾难中的角色,因为许多国家正在经历重大的大规模伤亡事件,而灾难能力并没有真正融入护理教育。在灾难期间,护士作为第一响应者,管理分类,稳定病人并提供紧急护理。与此同时,来自公共卫生等其他非紧急护理领域的同事正在确保对无法获得药物的流离失所者进行适当管理。无论在哪里提供护理,护士在紧急情况下都需要聪明才智和足智多谋,以便在资源有限的不寻常环境中提供护理(Veenema 2009)。除了身体健康和紧急护理之外,护士还有重要的作用。它们处理灾害对个人和社区的长期影响。灾后,护士向受灾害和冲突影响的人们提供心理急救和创伤知情干预。这类事件对人口的精神健康造成的影响是深远的,对护士和其他卫生保健工作者的影响也是如此。2019冠状病毒病大流行凸显了必须在极端环境下工作、必须做出具有挑战性的道德决定对个人造成的道德侮辱和伤害的影响(Scott et al. 2023)。在灾害和冲突期间工作也会带来这样的挑战,我们需要确保劳动力既有弹性,也有支持,以提供此类护理(Xue et al. 2020)。在灾难发生后的一段时间里,当人们试图恢复正常的时候,护理的作用也延伸到发展社区的恢复能力。这一角色需要一套不同的技能和知识,因为它涉及更广泛的公共卫生干预措施,包括监测疾病和与社区合作重建社会结构和加强社区网络(灾后恢复委员会,公共卫生研究所,2015年)。显然,无论是自然灾害还是人为灾害,以及诸如新出现的传染病、生物恐怖主义和大规模伤亡事件等其他挑战,对世界上许多国家来说都是一个始终存在的威胁。正如前面所强调的,气候变化也导致了更多的极端天气事件,这使得自然灾害更加频繁和强烈(Vernick 2025)。现在,“一生一次”的事件每十年发生两到三次是很常见的。极端天气事件、过热和干旱现在影响着许多大陆。由于全球气温上升,风暴、暴雨和飓风等天气事件现在比以前更加强烈(地球正义2024)。2025年6月,在赫尔辛基举行的国际护士理事会(ICN)大会上,ICN首席执行官霍华德·卡顿(Howard Catton)呼吁所有国家的护士关注气候变化和冲突等全球危机,无论他们离自己的国家有多远。这再次表明,各国需要从不同的角度考虑护士和其他卫生专业人员的灾害能力。虽然这些能力多年来一直植根于面临地质和其他威胁的国家,但地球上每个国家现在都面临着极端天气造成的灾难威胁。所有灾难都会给公众和医护人员带来道德挑战和心理创伤,而冲突和战争则会带来长期的挑战或无法忍受的状况。在冲突期间,护士承担着护理、个人风险和关心自己家庭的三重负担。 尽管如此,平民护士仍然不加歧视地提供护理,与受伤的平民一起治疗双方的伤员。在冲突期间,我们越来越多地看到违反国际人道主义法的对卫生设施和卫生工作者的袭击。《日内瓦公约》及其相关议定书规定了这种保护,而如果医院被敌人用于军事行动,则可能失去这种保护。尽管有这种立场,红十字国际委员会明确表示,医院可能失去保护这一事实并不是攻击医院的自由许可证(红十字国际委员会,2023年)。设施如何以及为什么会失去保护,缺乏明确性是一个问题。越来越多的卫生设施被用作盾牌,使卫生保健工作者和患者面临更大的攻击风险。我的观点是,医院‘实施对敌人有害的行为’的概念需要紧急澄清,因为实施这种行为的不是医院设施或工作人员,而是占领这些设施的军队或恐怖主义部队。一想到病人和工作人员不是自己的过错而被困在交火中,对医疗设施的袭击就更加令人憎恶。ICN多次呼吁保护护士、卫生保健工作者和设施,最近全国护理协会代表理事会在2025年6月的会议上提出了一项动议,进一步加强了这一呼吁。尽管如此,在许多冲突地区,攻击仍在继续,并以军事行动发生在这些设施的概念作为借口。联合国概述了冲突如何变得更加根深蒂固,尽管自1946年以来,战争和冲突造成的绝对死亡人数逐年下降。然而,国家内部团体之间的冲突更多了,欧洲和中东地区也发生了引人注目的战争。全球冲突现在处于自第二次世界大战以来的最高水平(Bowman 2025)。在受冲突影响地区工作或在专制政权下提供护理的护士比以往任何时候都多。当然,我们不应该忘记在前线工作的军人同事,他们照顾受伤的士兵。这些人中有许多人还在民用医疗服务机构工作,对战争和冲突带来的挑战,他们并不比他们的同事更加免疫。认识到灾害、战争和冲突变得越来越普遍,需要做些什么来确保卫生保健服务具有复原力,并确保护士做好充分准备?国际护士理事会于2019年发布了第二版灾难护理核心能力(ICN 2019)。核心能力涵盖八个范畴,包括准备及计划、通讯、事故管理、安全及保安、评估、干预、复原及法律及道德。该框架考虑了三个级别的护士,从1级(所有注册护士)到2级(在自己的组织中指定监督和领导应对措施的护士),最后是3级(可部署团队中的一员)护士。核心能力是制定教育计划的有用框架,许多国家已将1级能力纳入注册前护理计划(Ranse et al. 2022; Erkin和Kiyan 2025)。联合国在2022年警告说,世界上有一半的国家没有做好应对灾害的准备(联合国减少灾害风险办公室2022年)。亚太地区和非洲的许多这些国家容易遭受极端天气事件和其他形式的自然灾害,这些灾害往往导致干旱、作物歉收和饥荒。其他国家正在经历越来越多的野火和极端高温事件,并报告感觉准备不足,包括葡萄牙、希腊、西班牙和意大利(Yanatma 2025)。显然,随着灾害风险的增加和冲突的加剧,我们需要确保所有国家都将灾害护理能力纳入初级护士教育,并使医院和公共卫生部门的从业人员做好应对紧急情况的准备。没有这样的准备,各国将无法应对极端天气、自然灾害或冲突引起的紧急情况。本期特刊汇集了大量有关备灾的已发表论文,探讨了应对自然灾害和气候相关灾害的系统准备。在战争和冲突期间,人口的大规模迁移是一个共同特征,无论是在一个国家内部还是到其他国家,两篇论文探讨了来自乌克兰和叙利亚的流离失所人口。特刊还包括广泛的战争和冲突经历,包括一篇启发性的论文《隐藏的声音》,探讨了军事政变期间缅甸护士的工作。
本文章由计算机程序翻译,如有差异,请以英文原文为准。

The Indispensable Role of Nurses in Disasters, War and Conflict: Clinical Excellence in the Most Challenging Environments

The Indispensable Role of Nurses in Disasters, War and Conflict: Clinical Excellence in the Most Challenging Environments

Nurses are an integral element of the global response to healthcare emergencies, whether they are caused by natural disasters, terrorism, armed conflicts or humanitarian crises. In all of these circumstances, the fragility of many countries healthcare system is laid bare and staff are left to cope as front-line providers (Al Thobaity 2024). Nurses are major contributors at times of war and disaster as they work not only in the immediate emergency response, but they cope with the psychological and long-term aspects of recovery. When International Nursing Review put out the call for papers for this virtual special issue in 2024, the world had faced unprecedented global disaster challenges. Hurricane Helene and Typhoon Yagi had caused widespread damage, and flooding had also claimed a number of lives in Africa, Spain, Brazil, Bangladesh and India. Other countries were impacted by extreme heat with thousands of people dying in Saudi Arabia, North America and Pakistan. Overall, natural disasters killed more than 16,753 people in 2024, with extreme weather events accounting for the majority of these fatalities (Centre for Research on the Epidemiology of Disasters 2024). This figure is staggering as disasters had only claimed 65,566 lives in the previous 20-year period (Centre for Research on the Epidemiology of Disasters 2024). It was clear to me and my fellow editors that we needed to think differently about the role of nurses in disasters as many countries were now experiencing significant mass casualty events when disaster competencies were not really embedded in nursing education.

During disasters, nurses act as first responders, managing triage, stabilizing patients and delivering emergency care. At the same time, colleagues from other non-emergency care areas, such as public health, are ensuring that displaced people with no access to medication are appropriately managed. Wherever care is provided, nurses need ingenuity and resourcefulness in emergency situations in order to deliver care in unusual environments with resource limitations (Veenema 2009).

Nurses have a significant role beyond physical health and immediate emergency care. They address the longer-term impact of disasters on individuals and communities. In the aftermath, nurses deliver psychological first aid and trauma-informed interventions to people impacted by disasters and conflict. The mental health toll of such events on the population is profound, as is the impact on nurses and other healthcare workers. The COVID-19 pandemic has brought into the spotlight the impact of moral insult and injury that having to work in extreme circumstances and having to make challenging ethical decisions has on individuals (Scott et al. 2023). Working during disasters and conflict also brings such challenges and we need to ensure the workforce is both resilient and supported to deliver such care (Xue et al. 2020). The nursing role also extends in developing community resilience in the period after a disaster as people try to return to some sense of normality. This role requires a different set of skills and knowledge as it involves wider public health interventions, including monitoring for disease and working with communities to rebuild social structures and strengthening community networks (Committee on Post-Disaster Recovery, Institute of Public Health 2015).

It is clear that disasters, either natural or manmade, and other challenges such as emerging infections, bioterrorism and mass casualty events are an ever present threat for many countries around the world. As highlighted earlier, climate change is also causing more extreme weather events, which make natural disasters more frequent and more intense (Vernick 2025). It is now common to see ‘once-in-a-lifetime’ events occurring two to three times in a decade. Extreme weather events, excessive heat and drought now affect a number of continents. Weather events such as storms, torrential rain and hurricanes are now more intense than they were previously, fuelled by a rise in global temperatures (Earth Justice 2024). At the International Council of Nurses (ICN) Congress in Helsinki, in June 2025, Howard Catton, CEO of the ICN, called on nurses from all countries to pay attention to global crises like climate change and conflict no matter how far removed they seem to be from their own country. This reaffirms that countries need to think differently about disaster competencies for nurses and other health professionals. While such competencies have been embedded for many years in countries that face geological and other threats, every country on earth now faces the threat of disaster because of extreme weather.

While all disasters bring ethical challenges and psychological trauma for the public and healthcare staff, conflict and war bring extended periods of challenging or intolerable conditions. During conflict, nurses carry a triple burden of caregiving, personal risk and concern about their own families. Despite this, civilian nurses provide care without discrimination, treating the wounded from either side alongside injured civilians. Increasingly, we are seeing attacks on health facilities and healthcare workers during conflict, breaching international humanitarian law. This protection is afforded by the Geneva Convention and associated protocols, and while hospitals can lose such protection if they are used by the enemy for military operations. Despite this position, the International Committee of the Red Cross is clear that the fact that hospitals can lose protection is not a free licence to attack them (ICRC 2023). The lack of clarity around how and why facilities can lose their protections is a concern. Increasingly, health facilities are used as a shield, placing healthcare workers and patients at increased risk of attack. My view is that this notion of a hospital ‘carrying out an act harmful to the enemy’ requires urgent clarification, as it is not the facility or the staff who are carrying out the act but the military or terrorist forces who are occupying the facilities. The thought of patients and staff being caught in the crossfire through no fault of their own makes an attack on a facility even more abhorrent. The ICN has called numerous times for the protection of nurses, healthcare workers and facilities, and this was reinforced by a motion of the recent Council of National Nursing Association Representatives at their meeting in June 2025. Despite this, attacks continue in numerous conflict zones, with the notion of military operations taking place in the facilities used as a justification.

The United Nations outlines how conflict is becoming more entrenched, although the absolute number of deaths as a result of war and conflict has declined year by year since 1946. Yet there is more conflict between groups within countries, as well as notable wars in Europe and the Middle East. Global conflict is now at the highest level since the Second World War (Bowman 2025). More nurses than ever before are working in areas affected by conflict or delivering care under repressive regimes. Of course, we should not forget our military colleagues working at the front lines, providing care to injured soldiers. Many of these individuals also work in civilian healthcare services and are no more immune to the challenges that war and conflict bring than their colleagues.

Recognizing that disasters, war and conflict are becoming increasingly common, what needs to be done to ensure healthcare services are resilient and nurses are well prepared. The International Council of Nurses launched the second version of their disaster nursing core competencies in 2019 (ICN 2019). The core competencies cover eight domains from preparation and planning, communication, incident management, safety and security, assessment, intervention, recover and law and ethics. The framework considers three levels of nurses from Level 1, all registered nurses, through to Level 2, a nurse designated in their own organization to supervise and lead the response, and finally Level 3 for a nurse who is part of a deployable team. The core competencies are a useful framework to develop education programmes, and many countries have gone on to integrate Level 1 competencies into pre-registration nursing programmes (Ranse et al. 2022; Erkin and Kiyan 2025).

Level 1 preparation is not universal across the world, and the United Nations warned in 2022 that half the world was not prepared for disasters (United Nations Office for Disaster Risk Reduction 2022). Many of these countries in the Asia-Pacific region and Africa are prone to extreme weather events and other forms of natural disaster, which often lead to drought, crop failure and famine. Other countries are experiencing increasing events with wildfires and extreme heat, and report feeling less well prepared than they should be, including Portugal, Greece, Spain and Italy (Yanatma 2025). It is clear that with the increased risk of disaster and rising conflict, we need to ensure all countries are embedding disaster nursing competencies in initial nurse education as well as preparing practitioners in hospitals and public health to deal with emergencies. Without such preparation, countries will not be able to cope with emergencies arising from extreme weather, natural disasters or conflict.

This Special Issue brings together a wide collection of published papers around disaster preparedness, exploring system preparation for natural and climate-related disasters. The mass migration of people is a common feature, either within a country or to other countries during war and conflict, and two papers explore displaced populations from Ukraine and Syria. The Special Issue also includes wide-ranging experiences of war and conflict, including an enlightening paper on Voice from Hiding, exploring the work of nurses in Myanmar during the military coup.

Three papers explore the emerging threats from bioterrorism, mass casualty events caused by extreme heat and nuclear and radiological disasters. Several papers examine the immediate and long-term recovery of the devastating Türkiye–Syria earthquakes.

The Special Issue also explores disasters through the eyes of various vulnerable populations, including children, newborn infants and mothers, and those with chronic conditions.

It is abundantly clear that as we enter an era of marked climate emergencies, increasing armed conflict and displaced populations, the role of the nurse must be redefined as central to disaster and crisis response. Countries that have viewed disasters elsewhere need to prepare for climate-related catastrophes within their own borders. At the same time, clarity is needed that it is never acceptable to target health facilities and health workers. Disaster preparedness must be embedded into all nursing programmes, and staff must be adequately prepared and supported throughout their careers. Unless we prepare, we will be doomed to fail, and the people we serve simply deserve better.

None of the authors have a conflict of interest to disclose.

求助全文
通过发布文献求助,成功后即可免费获取论文全文。 去求助
来源期刊
CiteScore
7.90
自引率
7.30%
发文量
72
审稿时长
6-12 weeks
期刊介绍: International Nursing Review is a key resource for nurses world-wide. Articles are encouraged that reflect the ICN"s five key values: flexibility, inclusiveness, partnership, achievement and visionary leadership. Authors are encouraged to identify the relevance of local issues for the global community and to describe their work and to document their experience.
×
引用
GB/T 7714-2015
复制
MLA
复制
APA
复制
导出至
BibTeX EndNote RefMan NoteFirst NoteExpress
×
提示
您的信息不完整,为了账户安全,请先补充。
现在去补充
×
提示
您因"违规操作"
具体请查看互助需知
我知道了
×
提示
确定
请完成安全验证×
copy
已复制链接
快去分享给好友吧!
我知道了
右上角分享
点击右上角分享
0
联系我们:info@booksci.cn Book学术提供免费学术资源搜索服务,方便国内外学者检索中英文文献。致力于提供最便捷和优质的服务体验。 Copyright © 2023 布克学术 All rights reserved.
京ICP备2023020795号-1
ghs 京公网安备 11010802042870号
Book学术文献互助
Book学术文献互助群
群 号:604180095
Book学术官方微信