{"title":"栖息地丧失:恢复中的印度河海豚面临的持续挑战","authors":"Farooq Shah, Mingyang Chen, Wei Wu, Jianhong Sun","doi":"10.1111/acv.70006","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"<p>River dolphins are among the world's rarest and most endangered marine mammals (Waqas et al. <span>2012</span>). One such species, the Indus River Dolphin “<i>Platanista minor</i>,” locally known as “Bhulan” or “Blind Fish,” is endemic to the Indus River in Pakistan and a small part of India. With fewer than two thousand individuals, it is one of the only four river dolphins that spend their entire lives in freshwater (WWF <span>2022a</span>). Tragically, the Indus River Dolphin is the second most extinction-prone dolphin species globally (Reeves et al. <span>2000</span>) and is also included in the IUCN Red List of Threatened Species (CITES <span>2024</span>; IUCN <span>2022</span>).</p><p>To protect this unique species from extinction, the government of Pakistan has implemented several initiatives, particularly involving indigenous communities. With the support of WWF (World Wildlife Fund) Pakistan, various awareness campaigns and capacity-building sessions have been organized for the public. The government has also imposed a strict ban on hunting and established several protected areas, such as the Indus Dolphin Game Reserve in the Sindh province, where the species can thrive. As a result, significant progress has been made in protecting the dolphins and even reversing their population decline (Scientia Magazine <span>2019</span>).</p><p>Despite this glimmer of hope, the Indus River Dolphin remains highly vulnerable to the looming threats with the burgeoning demands for food, water, and electricity from the entire country, pushing this species closer to extinction. Additionally, the extensive construction of dams and barrages has fragmented and degraded its natural habitat (Braulik et al. <span>2021</span>). As a result, the current habitat has shrunk (<i>Ibid</i>) to just 410 miles, a drastic decline from its historical range that once stretched from the Himalayan mountains to the Arabian Sea (National Geographic <span>2020</span>). Confinement within such a narrow range poses a significant risk to the species' survival. Moreover, threats such as poaching, entanglement in fishing nets, trapping in extensive irrigation canals, and the discharge of untreated sewage as well as agricultural and industrial waste also endanger this species (Braulik et al. <span>2015</span>). Climate change further exacerbates these risks through increases in temperature, variations in river flows, and frequent occurrences of extreme weather events (Mongabay <span>2024</span>).</p><p>Successful conservation requires a holistic approach integrating various management strategies and prioritizing the engagement of key stakeholders (Challender et al. <span>2024</span>). To protect the biodiversity of the Indus River, it is essential to implement stringent policies that limit human activities both along the riverbank and within the water itself. For those reliant on fishing, alternative sources of food and income are crucial. Research elsewhere indicates that nearly 75% of Hong Kong fishermen would pursue alternative income opportunities if offered adequate compensation (Teh et al. <span>2008</span>). Similarly, studies in Ghana suggest that alternative livelihoods can effectively alleviate fishing pressure (Asiedu and Nunoo <span>2013</span>).</p><p>Meanwhile, the number of monitoring observers should be increased to enhance the protection of this imperiled species. In addition to traditional monitoring and surveillance strategies, modern tools such as Automatic Identification Systems, Vessel Monitoring Systems, and Electronic Monitoring Systems should be employed (Cremers et al. <span>2020</span>). Furthermore, it is essential to provide adequate logistics to the rangers and the rescue teams who actively monitor the region for illegal poaching and dredging activities. The use of signaling devices and sensors can significantly enhance monitoring and rescue operations during emergencies. For instance, electronic devices, like pingers in Indonesia, have been proven highly effective in deterring dolphins from getting entangled in nets (WWF <span>2021</span>). Similarly, the passive acoustic monitoring system installed in the Mediterranean Sea can detect bottlenose dolphins in real time, showcasing the effectiveness of such devices in conservation (Brunoldi et al. <span>2016</span>). Recent satellite tagging of the dolphins in Pakistan is a significant advancement, expected to provide crucial insights into this unique mammal (WWF <span>2022b</span>).</p><p>Carefully relocating dolphins, especially those trapped in irrigation canals (Nabi et al. <span>2021</span>; Figure 1) upstream of the Indus River, could enhance their chances of survival. Valuable lessons can be learned from China's successful relocation of finless porpoises from the Yangtze River to safer ecosystems, where they are thriving now (WWF <span>2015</span>). However, any proposed translocations must be thoroughly researched and meticulously planned before implementation (Braulik et al. <span>2015</span>). It is essential to engage expertise in the translocation process and to assess the safety of the receiving ecosystem (Braulik et al. <span>2024</span>) to avoid further endangering the species. This precaution is critical, given that there have already been reports of deaths during capture or transportation (Singh et al. <span>2023</span>). Furthermore, reversing population decline can be strengthened through scientific research, comprehensive monitoring, community awareness and involvement, and enhanced collaboration among various stakeholders.</p><p>Farooq Shah and Mingyang Chen conceptualized and drafted the original manuscript. Wei Wu and Jianhong Sun drafted, reviewed and edited the manuscript.</p><p>The authors declare no conflicts of interest.</p>","PeriodicalId":50786,"journal":{"name":"Animal Conservation","volume":"28 4","pages":"471-473"},"PeriodicalIF":2.6000,"publicationDate":"2025-03-03","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"https://zslpublications.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1111/acv.70006","citationCount":"0","resultStr":"{\"title\":\"Habitat Loss: A Continuing Challenge for the Recovering Indus River Dolphin\",\"authors\":\"Farooq Shah, Mingyang Chen, Wei Wu, Jianhong Sun\",\"doi\":\"10.1111/acv.70006\",\"DOIUrl\":null,\"url\":null,\"abstract\":\"<p>River dolphins are among the world's rarest and most endangered marine mammals (Waqas et al. <span>2012</span>). One such species, the Indus River Dolphin “<i>Platanista minor</i>,” locally known as “Bhulan” or “Blind Fish,” is endemic to the Indus River in Pakistan and a small part of India. With fewer than two thousand individuals, it is one of the only four river dolphins that spend their entire lives in freshwater (WWF <span>2022a</span>). Tragically, the Indus River Dolphin is the second most extinction-prone dolphin species globally (Reeves et al. <span>2000</span>) and is also included in the IUCN Red List of Threatened Species (CITES <span>2024</span>; IUCN <span>2022</span>).</p><p>To protect this unique species from extinction, the government of Pakistan has implemented several initiatives, particularly involving indigenous communities. With the support of WWF (World Wildlife Fund) Pakistan, various awareness campaigns and capacity-building sessions have been organized for the public. The government has also imposed a strict ban on hunting and established several protected areas, such as the Indus Dolphin Game Reserve in the Sindh province, where the species can thrive. As a result, significant progress has been made in protecting the dolphins and even reversing their population decline (Scientia Magazine <span>2019</span>).</p><p>Despite this glimmer of hope, the Indus River Dolphin remains highly vulnerable to the looming threats with the burgeoning demands for food, water, and electricity from the entire country, pushing this species closer to extinction. Additionally, the extensive construction of dams and barrages has fragmented and degraded its natural habitat (Braulik et al. <span>2021</span>). As a result, the current habitat has shrunk (<i>Ibid</i>) to just 410 miles, a drastic decline from its historical range that once stretched from the Himalayan mountains to the Arabian Sea (National Geographic <span>2020</span>). Confinement within such a narrow range poses a significant risk to the species' survival. Moreover, threats such as poaching, entanglement in fishing nets, trapping in extensive irrigation canals, and the discharge of untreated sewage as well as agricultural and industrial waste also endanger this species (Braulik et al. <span>2015</span>). Climate change further exacerbates these risks through increases in temperature, variations in river flows, and frequent occurrences of extreme weather events (Mongabay <span>2024</span>).</p><p>Successful conservation requires a holistic approach integrating various management strategies and prioritizing the engagement of key stakeholders (Challender et al. <span>2024</span>). To protect the biodiversity of the Indus River, it is essential to implement stringent policies that limit human activities both along the riverbank and within the water itself. For those reliant on fishing, alternative sources of food and income are crucial. Research elsewhere indicates that nearly 75% of Hong Kong fishermen would pursue alternative income opportunities if offered adequate compensation (Teh et al. <span>2008</span>). Similarly, studies in Ghana suggest that alternative livelihoods can effectively alleviate fishing pressure (Asiedu and Nunoo <span>2013</span>).</p><p>Meanwhile, the number of monitoring observers should be increased to enhance the protection of this imperiled species. In addition to traditional monitoring and surveillance strategies, modern tools such as Automatic Identification Systems, Vessel Monitoring Systems, and Electronic Monitoring Systems should be employed (Cremers et al. <span>2020</span>). Furthermore, it is essential to provide adequate logistics to the rangers and the rescue teams who actively monitor the region for illegal poaching and dredging activities. The use of signaling devices and sensors can significantly enhance monitoring and rescue operations during emergencies. For instance, electronic devices, like pingers in Indonesia, have been proven highly effective in deterring dolphins from getting entangled in nets (WWF <span>2021</span>). Similarly, the passive acoustic monitoring system installed in the Mediterranean Sea can detect bottlenose dolphins in real time, showcasing the effectiveness of such devices in conservation (Brunoldi et al. <span>2016</span>). Recent satellite tagging of the dolphins in Pakistan is a significant advancement, expected to provide crucial insights into this unique mammal (WWF <span>2022b</span>).</p><p>Carefully relocating dolphins, especially those trapped in irrigation canals (Nabi et al. <span>2021</span>; Figure 1) upstream of the Indus River, could enhance their chances of survival. Valuable lessons can be learned from China's successful relocation of finless porpoises from the Yangtze River to safer ecosystems, where they are thriving now (WWF <span>2015</span>). However, any proposed translocations must be thoroughly researched and meticulously planned before implementation (Braulik et al. <span>2015</span>). It is essential to engage expertise in the translocation process and to assess the safety of the receiving ecosystem (Braulik et al. <span>2024</span>) to avoid further endangering the species. This precaution is critical, given that there have already been reports of deaths during capture or transportation (Singh et al. <span>2023</span>). Furthermore, reversing population decline can be strengthened through scientific research, comprehensive monitoring, community awareness and involvement, and enhanced collaboration among various stakeholders.</p><p>Farooq Shah and Mingyang Chen conceptualized and drafted the original manuscript. Wei Wu and Jianhong Sun drafted, reviewed and edited the manuscript.</p><p>The authors declare no conflicts of interest.</p>\",\"PeriodicalId\":50786,\"journal\":{\"name\":\"Animal Conservation\",\"volume\":\"28 4\",\"pages\":\"471-473\"},\"PeriodicalIF\":2.6000,\"publicationDate\":\"2025-03-03\",\"publicationTypes\":\"Journal Article\",\"fieldsOfStudy\":null,\"isOpenAccess\":false,\"openAccessPdf\":\"https://zslpublications.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1111/acv.70006\",\"citationCount\":\"0\",\"resultStr\":null,\"platform\":\"Semanticscholar\",\"paperid\":null,\"PeriodicalName\":\"Animal Conservation\",\"FirstCategoryId\":\"93\",\"ListUrlMain\":\"https://zslpublications.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/acv.70006\",\"RegionNum\":2,\"RegionCategory\":\"环境科学与生态学\",\"ArticlePicture\":[],\"TitleCN\":null,\"AbstractTextCN\":null,\"PMCID\":null,\"EPubDate\":\"\",\"PubModel\":\"\",\"JCR\":\"Q1\",\"JCRName\":\"BIODIVERSITY CONSERVATION\",\"Score\":null,\"Total\":0}","platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Animal Conservation","FirstCategoryId":"93","ListUrlMain":"https://zslpublications.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/acv.70006","RegionNum":2,"RegionCategory":"环境科学与生态学","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"Q1","JCRName":"BIODIVERSITY CONSERVATION","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
摘要
河豚是世界上最稀有和最濒危的海洋哺乳动物之一(Waqas et al. 2012)。其中一个物种,印度河海豚“Platanista minor”,在当地被称为“Bhulan”或“盲鱼”,是巴基斯坦印度河和印度一小部分地区的特有物种。它是仅有的四种一生都在淡水中度过的河豚之一,数量不到2000只(WWF 2022a)。不幸的是,印度河豚是全球第二大最容易灭绝的海豚物种(Reeves et al. 2000),也被列入IUCN濒危物种红色名录(CITES 2024; IUCN 2022)。为了保护这种独特的物种免于灭绝,巴基斯坦政府已经实施了几项倡议,特别是涉及土著社区。在世界自然基金会巴基斯坦分会的支持下,为公众组织了各种宣传活动和能力建设会议。政府还严格禁止狩猎,并建立了几个保护区,比如信德省的印度河海豚保护区,在那里海豚可以茁壮成长。因此,在保护海豚方面取得了重大进展,甚至扭转了海豚数量下降的趋势(《科学杂志》2019年)。尽管有一线希望,但随着整个国家对食物、水和电的需求不断增长,印度河海豚在迫在眉睫的威胁面前仍然非常脆弱,使这个物种更接近灭绝。此外,水坝和拦河坝的大量建设使其自然栖息地破碎和退化(Braulik et al. 2021)。因此,目前的栖息地已经缩小(同上)到只有410英里,与曾经从喜马拉雅山脉延伸到阿拉伯海的历史范围相比急剧下降(国家地理2020)。在如此狭窄的范围内,对物种的生存构成了重大风险。此外,偷猎、渔网缠绕、大面积灌溉渠诱捕、未经处理的污水以及农业和工业废物的排放等威胁也危及该物种(Braulik et al. 2015)。气候变化通过温度升高、河流流量变化和极端天气事件的频繁发生进一步加剧了这些风险(Mongabay 2024)。成功的保护需要综合各种管理策略的整体方法,并优先考虑关键利益相关者的参与(Challender et al. 2024)。为了保护印度河的生物多样性,必须实施严格的政策,限制人类在河岸和河水内的活动。对于那些依赖捕鱼的人来说,其他食物和收入来源至关重要。其他研究表明,如果获得足够的补偿,近75%的香港渔民会寻求其他收入机会(Teh et al. 2008)。同样,加纳的研究表明,替代生计可以有效缓解捕捞压力(Asiedu和nuoo, 2013)。同时,应增加监测观察员的数量,以加强对这一濒危物种的保护。除了传统的监测和监视策略外,还应采用自动识别系统、船舶监测系统和电子监测系统等现代工具(Cremers et al. 2020)。此外,为积极监控该地区非法偷猎和疏浚活动的护林员和救援队提供充足的后勤保障至关重要。使用信号装置和传感器可以大大加强紧急情况下的监测和救援行动。例如,印度尼西亚的电子设备,如ping仪,已被证明在阻止海豚被网缠住方面非常有效(WWF 2021)。同样,安装在地中海的被动声学监测系统可以实时检测到宽吻海豚,展示了此类设备在保护中的有效性(Brunoldi et al. 2016)。最近对巴基斯坦海豚的卫星标记是一项重大进展,有望为这种独特的哺乳动物提供重要的见解(WWF 2022b)。小心地重新安置海豚,特别是那些被困在印度河上游灌溉渠中的海豚(Nabi et al. 2021;图1),可以提高它们的生存机会。中国成功地将江豚从长江转移到更安全的生态系统,在那里它们正在茁壮成长,从中可以学到宝贵的经验(WWF 2015)。然而,任何提议的易位都必须在实施前进行彻底的研究和精心的计划(Braulik et al. 2015)。必须在迁移过程中吸收专业知识,并评估接收生态系统的安全性(Braulik et al. 2024),以避免进一步危及该物种。 鉴于已经有捕获或运输过程中死亡的报告,这种预防措施至关重要(Singh et al. 2023)。此外,可以通过科学研究、全面监测、社区意识和参与以及加强各利益攸关方之间的合作来加强扭转人口下降的趋势。Farooq Shah和Mingyang Chen构思并起草了原始手稿。吴伟、孙建宏起草、审稿、编辑。作者声明无利益冲突。
Habitat Loss: A Continuing Challenge for the Recovering Indus River Dolphin
River dolphins are among the world's rarest and most endangered marine mammals (Waqas et al. 2012). One such species, the Indus River Dolphin “Platanista minor,” locally known as “Bhulan” or “Blind Fish,” is endemic to the Indus River in Pakistan and a small part of India. With fewer than two thousand individuals, it is one of the only four river dolphins that spend their entire lives in freshwater (WWF 2022a). Tragically, the Indus River Dolphin is the second most extinction-prone dolphin species globally (Reeves et al. 2000) and is also included in the IUCN Red List of Threatened Species (CITES 2024; IUCN 2022).
To protect this unique species from extinction, the government of Pakistan has implemented several initiatives, particularly involving indigenous communities. With the support of WWF (World Wildlife Fund) Pakistan, various awareness campaigns and capacity-building sessions have been organized for the public. The government has also imposed a strict ban on hunting and established several protected areas, such as the Indus Dolphin Game Reserve in the Sindh province, where the species can thrive. As a result, significant progress has been made in protecting the dolphins and even reversing their population decline (Scientia Magazine 2019).
Despite this glimmer of hope, the Indus River Dolphin remains highly vulnerable to the looming threats with the burgeoning demands for food, water, and electricity from the entire country, pushing this species closer to extinction. Additionally, the extensive construction of dams and barrages has fragmented and degraded its natural habitat (Braulik et al. 2021). As a result, the current habitat has shrunk (Ibid) to just 410 miles, a drastic decline from its historical range that once stretched from the Himalayan mountains to the Arabian Sea (National Geographic 2020). Confinement within such a narrow range poses a significant risk to the species' survival. Moreover, threats such as poaching, entanglement in fishing nets, trapping in extensive irrigation canals, and the discharge of untreated sewage as well as agricultural and industrial waste also endanger this species (Braulik et al. 2015). Climate change further exacerbates these risks through increases in temperature, variations in river flows, and frequent occurrences of extreme weather events (Mongabay 2024).
Successful conservation requires a holistic approach integrating various management strategies and prioritizing the engagement of key stakeholders (Challender et al. 2024). To protect the biodiversity of the Indus River, it is essential to implement stringent policies that limit human activities both along the riverbank and within the water itself. For those reliant on fishing, alternative sources of food and income are crucial. Research elsewhere indicates that nearly 75% of Hong Kong fishermen would pursue alternative income opportunities if offered adequate compensation (Teh et al. 2008). Similarly, studies in Ghana suggest that alternative livelihoods can effectively alleviate fishing pressure (Asiedu and Nunoo 2013).
Meanwhile, the number of monitoring observers should be increased to enhance the protection of this imperiled species. In addition to traditional monitoring and surveillance strategies, modern tools such as Automatic Identification Systems, Vessel Monitoring Systems, and Electronic Monitoring Systems should be employed (Cremers et al. 2020). Furthermore, it is essential to provide adequate logistics to the rangers and the rescue teams who actively monitor the region for illegal poaching and dredging activities. The use of signaling devices and sensors can significantly enhance monitoring and rescue operations during emergencies. For instance, electronic devices, like pingers in Indonesia, have been proven highly effective in deterring dolphins from getting entangled in nets (WWF 2021). Similarly, the passive acoustic monitoring system installed in the Mediterranean Sea can detect bottlenose dolphins in real time, showcasing the effectiveness of such devices in conservation (Brunoldi et al. 2016). Recent satellite tagging of the dolphins in Pakistan is a significant advancement, expected to provide crucial insights into this unique mammal (WWF 2022b).
Carefully relocating dolphins, especially those trapped in irrigation canals (Nabi et al. 2021; Figure 1) upstream of the Indus River, could enhance their chances of survival. Valuable lessons can be learned from China's successful relocation of finless porpoises from the Yangtze River to safer ecosystems, where they are thriving now (WWF 2015). However, any proposed translocations must be thoroughly researched and meticulously planned before implementation (Braulik et al. 2015). It is essential to engage expertise in the translocation process and to assess the safety of the receiving ecosystem (Braulik et al. 2024) to avoid further endangering the species. This precaution is critical, given that there have already been reports of deaths during capture or transportation (Singh et al. 2023). Furthermore, reversing population decline can be strengthened through scientific research, comprehensive monitoring, community awareness and involvement, and enhanced collaboration among various stakeholders.
Farooq Shah and Mingyang Chen conceptualized and drafted the original manuscript. Wei Wu and Jianhong Sun drafted, reviewed and edited the manuscript.
期刊介绍:
Animal Conservation provides a forum for rapid publication of novel, peer-reviewed research into the conservation of animal species and their habitats. The focus is on rigorous quantitative studies of an empirical or theoretical nature, which may relate to populations, species or communities and their conservation. We encourage the submission of single-species papers that have clear broader implications for conservation of other species or systems. A central theme is to publish important new ideas of broad interest and with findings that advance the scientific basis of conservation. Subjects covered include population biology, epidemiology, evolutionary ecology, population genetics, biodiversity, biogeography, palaeobiology and conservation economics.