Symmetrization of Strong Hydrogen Bond under High Pressure in Bihydroxide-Ion-Containing NaCu2(SO4)2·H3O2 Revealed by Experimental Charge Density, Single-Crystal Electron Diffraction, and Neutron Diffraction Studies

In minerals and inorganic compounds, strong hydrogen bonding can lead to the formation of complex ionic species such as the H₃O₂^– bihydroxide anion and Zundel cation H₅O₂⁺. We studied [NaCu₂(SO₄)₂·H₃O₂] natrochalcite, which contains bihydroxide anions and undergoes hydrogen bond symmetrization at the lowest pressure reported so far among inorganic compounds. Hydrogen bond symmetrization leads to changes in the bulk modulus, seismic wave velocities, and proton mobility and plays a primary role in high-temperature superconductivity, but its characteristics are not well understood due to a lack of systematic studies and limitations of experimental methods sensitive to this subtle change. In this work, we applied experimental charge density analysis based on in situ single-crystal X-ray diffraction data, along with the single-crystal neutron and electron diffraction experiments, to probe the behavior of hydrogen atoms during the hydrogen bond symmetrization process under high-pressure conditions. On the way to the symmetrical H-bonding, natrochalcite undergoes a series of complex redistributions of electron density, which we trace with multipole refinement and detailed analysis of changes in the Laplacian of electron density values. Additionally, we deconvoluted the equation of state (volume of the unit cell vs pressure relation) into the atomic equation of states describing dependencies of atomic charges or volumes vs pressure.