The Role of Sex Hormones in Cartilaginous Tissues: A Scoping Review

Background

The use of sex hormones in the clinic for the management of musculoskeletal conditions is increasingly common. Despite this, the role of sex hormones in various joint tissues such as the intervertebral disc (IVD), temporomandibular joint (TMJ), and articular cartilage remains poorly understood. Here, we employ a database search strategy to critically examine the available literature in this field through a scoping review.

Methods

Using a 4-step protocol, primary research articles pertaining to sex hormones and the IVD, TMJ, or articular cartilage were identified and reviewed by two independent reviewers. ~3900 articles were identified in our initial search, and after review, ~140 were identified to be relevant to our tissues of interest and the effects of sex hormones.

Results

Within all joint tissues investigated here, there were limited investigations on the effects of testosterone. Studies reported here for these tissues indicate that sex hormones are likely beneficial in the context of age-associated joint diseases, but there are important limitations to how this translates to the clinic given that various animal models can display distinct responses to sex hormone exposure. Direct comparisons of sex hormone therapies are limited between biological sexes, but evidence indicates that the molecular responses are likely similar. Current evidence indicates that sex hormone exposure likely has anti-inflammatory effects within joint tissues at the level of gene and protein expression, but the mechanism is unknown.

Conclusion

Sex hormones such as testosterone and estrogen play an important role in inflammatory signaling within joint tissues, which could lead to novel interventions within the clinic for joint degeneration. However, understanding the biological mechanisms of hormones in these distinct tissues, between sexes, and with age is imperative for their proper implementation.