Comparative analysis of continuous similarity measures for compound identification in mass spectrometry-based metabolomics

In mass spectrometry (MS)-based metabolomics, the most straightforward and efficient approach for compound identification is the comparison of similarity scores between experimental spectra and reference spectra. Among various single and composite similarity measures, the Cosine Correlation is favored due to its simplicity, efficiency, and effectiveness. Recently, the Shannon Entropy Correlation has shown superior performance over several other measures, including the Cosine Correlation, in LC-MS-based metabolomics, particularly concerning receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curves and false discovery rates. However, previous comparisons did not consider the weight factor transformation, which is critical for achieving higher accuracy with the cosine correlation. This study conducted a comparative analysis of the Cosine Correlation and Shannon Entropy Correlation, incorporating the weight factor transformation during preprocessing. Additionally, we developed a novel entropy correlation measure, the Tsallis Entropy Correlation, which offers greater versatility than the Shannon Entropy Correlation. Our accuracy-based results indicate that the weight factor transformation is essential for achieving higher identification performance in both LC-MS and GC-MS-based compound identification. Although the Tsallis Entropy Correlation outperforms the Shannon Entropy Correlation in terms of accuracy, it comes with higher computational expense. In contrast, the Cosine Correlation, when combined with the weight factor transformation, achieves the highest accuracy and the lowest computational expense, demonstrating both robustness and efficiency in MS-based compound identification.