每个孩子一台笔记本电脑,20年后:一个有目的和遗产的项目

Q4 Engineering
Chris Boylan
{"title":"每个孩子一台笔记本电脑,20年后:一个有目的和遗产的项目","authors":"Chris Boylan","doi":"10.1002/msid.1552","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"<p>THE ONE LAPTOP PER CHILD (OLPC) PROGRAM HAD A SIMPLE PREMISE: IF EVERY child in the world had access to a free or low-cost laptop, vast learning opportunities would be within any child's reach. This access to technology and information would help narrow the educational gap between children with limited resources and those with ample means.</p><p>The idea for OLPC came from discussions between computer scientist and educator Seymour Papert and architect Nicholas Negroponte at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology's (MIT's) Media Lab in the early 2000s,<span><sup>1</sup></span> where the two were professors. Papert likened computers locked in the laboratories of higher learning institutions to books chained to the shelves of medieval libraries: Only those with privileged access were able to benefit from the knowledge hidden within. Negroponte compared the sharing of a computer with the sharing of a pencil. What if two people needed to write something—or learn something—at the same time?</p><p>Negroponte's belief was that the main barrier to providing advanced educational technology to the masses was the cost. In 2004, laptops and small desktop computers sold for more than US$1,500 each (approximately $2,500 in 2024 dollars). At the 2005 World Economic Forum in Davos, Switzerland, Negroponte urged the technology industry to solve the problem by creating a $100 laptop. He even demonstrated an early prototype of what such a laptop could look like.<span><sup>2</sup></span> A low-cost computer could enable millions of the devices to be sent worldwide, bringing knowledge to every corner of the world. Thus, the OLPC program and the non-profit organization of the same name were born.</p><p>Early in the program, it was clear to Negroponte that the key to reducing the laptop's cost was to reduce the display's cost, as it was the costliest component. When Negroponte returned to MIT from Switzerland in 2005, he met Mary Lou Jepsen, the display pioneer and SID Fellow. Their discussions turned to the display innovations required to enable a low-cost laptop that also would be extremely power efficient. Jepsen then signed on as one of the principals of the project and led the core development team.</p><p>SID member Scott Soong, who hails from the family-owned tech giant CHIMEI, learned about the project through the Industrial Technology Research Institute (ITRI), a research and development organization in Taiwan. Soong had studied global development at the University of Ann Arbor, Michigan, and had a keen interest on the effects of poverty on personal and economic development. When he learned about the project, he grabbed a 7-inch picture frame display, made by CHIMEI's subsidiary Chi Lin, hopped on a plane to Boston, and met with the OLPC team. “Ya gotta let me be a part of this!” said Soong. The team agreed. He then went back to the folks at CHIMEI and convinced them to be a part of the project.</p><p>Initial thoughts were that maybe a black and white e-ink type display might be the best choice because of its power efficiency, but this approach would not have been viable because the response time was too slow even for a graphical user interface (GUI). In addition, the project principals wanted to bring color and video into the lives of the kids using the devices, not just for aesthetic purposes but to enhance learning. Jepsen developed the architecture for an innovative LC transflective display. It functions as a color display in transmissive mode in low lighting but reverts to a monochrome display in reflective mode in direct sunlight. This design could provide high-power efficiency and readability in direct sunlight while also displaying a nice color screen inside the classroom or homes of the children who used them.*</p><p>“I designed the laptop from the screen backwards. This enabled new innovations around cost, power management, and durability. I also put in a sunlight-readable screen with an innovative color/monochrome architecture that gave retina resolution in the reading mode that surpassed the resolution of Apple screens at the time,” said Jepsen.</p><p>CHIMEI Optoelectronics and Chi Lin engineers collaborated with Jepsen and the OLPC design team to manufacture and deliver millions of these transflective displays. CHIMEI also provided the plastic formulation for the case in which the laptop was housed.</p><p>Many prominent technology companies pledged economic support for the program early on, including AMD, eBay, Google, Marvell Technology Group, News Corporation, and Nortel Networks. CHIMEI Optoelectronics and Chi Lin built the screen while HiMax produced the IC display drivers, reaching previously unseen power efficiency standards. Quanta Computer used these components (and others) to build the finished product in 2007 (<b>Fig</b>. 1).</p><p>However, the hardware was only part of the challenge, so the team worked to create a lightweight operating system (open-source Linux-based), a simplified GUI, and self-contained software bundles that were both powerful and easy to use.<span><sup>4</sup></span> Each laptop had to have access to a large repository of data stored locally, as many areas around the globe had no internet access (broadband or otherwise) in the mid-2000s. The laptop's design used a mesh network so that a single computer with internet access could share that access with other OLPC devices in its proximity.<span><sup>5</sup></span> To save cost, power, and weight, the local magnetic or optical hard drive was eliminated, instead relying on the onboard RAM and flash memory cards for data and software storage.</p><p>The program made significant progress in its first two years. Although they never quite reached the $100 price goal, Quanta Computer manufactured the “XO” at a respectable cost of $188, which went into production in 2007.<span><sup>6</sup></span> Each XO laptop included the transflective screen, an integrated video camera, a microphone, long-range Wi-Fi antennas, mesh networking, and a hybrid stylus and touchpad. The XO's 7.5-inch diagonal transflective LCD screen operated in two complementary modes. In reflective mode with the backlight off, the display provided a monochrome image with very high resolution—1,200 × 900 pixels at 200 dpi. In transmissive backlit mode, the display produced full RGB color, but instead of using traditional color filters over the LCD cells, the backlight employed a diffraction grating with lenses that split the light into separate elements of R-G-B and directed those colors into the liquid crystal cells. This eliminated a significant cause of light absorption in traditional RGB LCDs. Both modes could interact so as the ambient light increased, the user would see a combination of monochrome and color content in a complementary fashion. This innovation allowed for significantly lower total backlight energy needed for indoor viewing than other LCD designs of the time. Under high ambient conditions, the viewer would see a high-resolution monochrome image, and the backlight could be shut off to save power. Along with the XO's compact folding design, this allowed for its use as an e-reader device when the laptop was closed.</p><p>Along with a standard plug-in power supply, solar and mechanical (hand crank) power source options were demonstrated in early prototypes, allowing off-grid operation. However, after a less-than-impressive initial demonstration of the hand crank at the prototype's unveiling (by former Secretary-General of the United Nations Kofi Annan), the hand crank option was removed before the unit went into production.<span><sup>7</sup></span></p><p>By the end of 2007, OLPC had sold and distributed more than 600,000 XO laptops,<span><sup>8</sup></span> mostly in Uruguay, Peru, and Mexico. Additional units were sold and distributed in Brazil, Rwanda, Nicaragua, Paraguay, and Nigeria. The XO even saw a few thousand units sold in Alabama and Pennsylvania in the United States for distribution to low-income households. Over the next few years, several million of the OLPC devices were manufactured and distributed worldwide in various incarnations; all featured the innovative transflective display (<b>Fig</b>. 2).</p><p>Although many aspects of the initiative were successful, the OLPC program never quite hit the lofty goals of its founders. Without clear research studies to show the advantages of laptop access for school-age children, as well as extremely tight budgets in the targeted countries, the program did not reach the hundreds of millions of recipients as originally envisioned. In countries such as Peru, which had a fairly high distribution of the XO laptops, follow-up studies showed only minor improvements in math learning and no clearly identifiable improvements in English or other language learning among laptop recipients.</p><p>Many reasons were attributed to the program's somewhat limited success. Cultural issues sometimes stifled parental support as young students discovered Western thought and societal concepts, which conflicted with their communities’ traditional cultural practices and religious beliefs. Also, failure came from more mundane reasons. As many laptop owners can attest, computers break down or develop technical issues, both software- and hardware-related, over time. When you build a laptop at the lowest possible cost, such failures are more likely. Without adequate product support and technical assistance, many of these XO laptops never were deployed in schools or children's homes or had to be taken out of service prematurely, as they developed operational issues without local IT experts to address them. However, Jepsen told us that in some regions, children took the initiative to fix common issues themselves, even creating local repair stations within their communities, thereby extending the usable life of the devices.</p><p>Some years later, Soong visited one of the communities in Brazil that had purchased OLPC laptops for their students. Here he saw a teacher instructing the students on human viruses, which led to students searching the web and discovering the concept of computer viruses. This led them down an unintended but still educational path. What made the biggest impression on Soong was the obvious pride of ownership that these kids had for their laptops. They treated them carefully and decorated them with stickers to express their individuality (<b>Fig</b>. 3).</p><p>“I think that was something that we got right. Giving kids this pride of ownership. It was theirs. And this gave them the excitement to learn using this tool that they otherwise would have had no hope of owning or even using.”</p><p>But the idea that the great “digital divide” could be breached simply by delivering a one-size-fits-all hardware and software package may have been a bit optimistic. Perhaps it would have aided the program's success if more targeted groundwork had been provided to local governments at the project's outset on the value added and how it could be adapted for their specific social and cultural needs. But even if it never quite met its ambitious goals, the OLPC organization and program had positive impacts both in the communities it served and in the industry as a whole.</p><p>On the technical side, the XO laptop developed by OLPC and MIT offered significant innovations in many areas, including power supply design and power efficiency, display design, mesh networking abilities, keyboard, and touchpad design to provide a durable interactive laptop well suited for rugged environments. The unit's dual-mode screen—monochrome for outside, color for indoor use—offered versatility that had never been seen before in a low-budget computer. The intentional omission of all motor-driven moving parts led to the XO's high-power efficiency.</p><p>The technology underwent some updates through the years, including the XO-1.5, which had even fewer physical parts than the original model, the XO-3 tablet, and the XO-4 featuring new components and an optional touchscreen.</p><p>These innovations pushed more established brands to offer low-cost PCs to government and educational markets on the heels of XO's introduction. In 2007, Asus offered the first generation of its Eee laptop (a netbook) for $399, and in 2008, Intel offered the “Classmate” laptop for less than $250. In some cases, countries that initially committed to ordering the XO canceled their orders and opted for name-brand laptops instead to potentially get better performance and support for standard operating systems such as Windows.</p><p>In late 2024, Chromebook laptops from well-known PC-makers could be purchased at national discount retail chains for less than $100. Would this under-$100 laptop milestone have been reached today without the efforts of the OLPC program? We may never know.</p><p>When asked about the legacy of the OLPC project, Soong credits the birth of the educational PC market directly to the OLPC project. “Because there was this OLPC for that price point, all of a sudden, the educational PC market came about. Before that, these laptops were much more expensive, but now we have purpose-built computers and an ecosystem around it.”</p><p>From a display innovation perspective, although transflective displays have not seen much widespread commercialization, the quest for ever-increasing power efficiency has led to e-ink screens that can be used in the retail or outdoor environment for extended periods with no external power source. Soong's company, Agile Display Solutions, makes a 32-inch display that can last for two years on a single battery with no external battery source.</p><p>Looking back on the OLPC project, Soong said, “It was really important to me, personally, because we work to take care of our family, but we also work to hopefully give back to the community. And few of us have the opportunity to do this so early on in our careers. Also, the connections and contacts that I made in the OLPC project have helped me to develop innovative display products like e-paper/e-ink that are so efficient and inexpensive that they can be used to display product information and pricing on store shelves. Walmart is one of our customers, and they are in the process of rolling this out.”</p><p>“My current company, Pervasive Displays (a part of VusionGroup), is now making 1 to 1.5 million of these displays per week. With these network-enabled e-paper labels, companies can save on both materials and labor as price changes can be rolled out store-wide with the flip of a switch. And this can also save a lot of trees with the reduced use of paper in retail. It was the OLPC project that took me down this path.”</p><p>In consideration of the OLPC project's innovation and legacy, Jepsen said, “The OLPC architecture hasn't been matched or exceeded in the last 20 years. It's still the lowest power-consumption laptop and lowest-cost laptop. An innovative architecture enabled this. It was the first mesh-networked laptop, the first laptop designed for children who can't yet read, open source, rugged and droppable, and fixable by children who created repair stations in each country. It generated billions of dollars of revenue and kicked off the fastest-growing consumer electronics category ever recorded: the netbook.</p><p>“The OLPC changed the equation of what a minister of education could do for the children of their country, what could be done for education in a pandemic, and indeed as Sundar Pichai said, its legacy is the Chromebook from Google. It was the great privilege of my life to co-found this organization with Nicholas Negroponte and lead its technology and architecture,” said Jepsen.</p><p>“Two decades later, the machines are so durable and practical that many are actually still in use. And our design meant we delivered the first machines supporting many ‘minor’ languages, like Ethiopia's Amharic. Kids growing up using their own native tongues on computers? What a concept!”</p><p>While the original OLPC charitable organization disbanded in 2014, a nonprofit organization carries on its name and mission, touting that the program has led to the worldwide distribution of more than 3 million laptops and devices. According to their site, their ultimate goal “is to enable learning opportunities so children can transform their environments, societies, and realities.” You can read more about it at https://laptop.org.</p>","PeriodicalId":52450,"journal":{"name":"Information Display","volume":"41 1","pages":"34-37"},"PeriodicalIF":0.0000,"publicationDate":"2025-01-17","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1002/msid.1552","citationCount":"0","resultStr":"{\"title\":\"One Laptop Per Child, 20 Years Later: A Project with a Purpose and a Legacy\",\"authors\":\"Chris Boylan\",\"doi\":\"10.1002/msid.1552\",\"DOIUrl\":null,\"url\":null,\"abstract\":\"<p>THE ONE LAPTOP PER CHILD (OLPC) PROGRAM HAD A SIMPLE PREMISE: IF EVERY child in the world had access to a free or low-cost laptop, vast learning opportunities would be within any child's reach. This access to technology and information would help narrow the educational gap between children with limited resources and those with ample means.</p><p>The idea for OLPC came from discussions between computer scientist and educator Seymour Papert and architect Nicholas Negroponte at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology's (MIT's) Media Lab in the early 2000s,<span><sup>1</sup></span> where the two were professors. Papert likened computers locked in the laboratories of higher learning institutions to books chained to the shelves of medieval libraries: Only those with privileged access were able to benefit from the knowledge hidden within. Negroponte compared the sharing of a computer with the sharing of a pencil. What if two people needed to write something—or learn something—at the same time?</p><p>Negroponte's belief was that the main barrier to providing advanced educational technology to the masses was the cost. In 2004, laptops and small desktop computers sold for more than US$1,500 each (approximately $2,500 in 2024 dollars). At the 2005 World Economic Forum in Davos, Switzerland, Negroponte urged the technology industry to solve the problem by creating a $100 laptop. He even demonstrated an early prototype of what such a laptop could look like.<span><sup>2</sup></span> A low-cost computer could enable millions of the devices to be sent worldwide, bringing knowledge to every corner of the world. Thus, the OLPC program and the non-profit organization of the same name were born.</p><p>Early in the program, it was clear to Negroponte that the key to reducing the laptop's cost was to reduce the display's cost, as it was the costliest component. When Negroponte returned to MIT from Switzerland in 2005, he met Mary Lou Jepsen, the display pioneer and SID Fellow. Their discussions turned to the display innovations required to enable a low-cost laptop that also would be extremely power efficient. Jepsen then signed on as one of the principals of the project and led the core development team.</p><p>SID member Scott Soong, who hails from the family-owned tech giant CHIMEI, learned about the project through the Industrial Technology Research Institute (ITRI), a research and development organization in Taiwan. Soong had studied global development at the University of Ann Arbor, Michigan, and had a keen interest on the effects of poverty on personal and economic development. When he learned about the project, he grabbed a 7-inch picture frame display, made by CHIMEI's subsidiary Chi Lin, hopped on a plane to Boston, and met with the OLPC team. “Ya gotta let me be a part of this!” said Soong. The team agreed. He then went back to the folks at CHIMEI and convinced them to be a part of the project.</p><p>Initial thoughts were that maybe a black and white e-ink type display might be the best choice because of its power efficiency, but this approach would not have been viable because the response time was too slow even for a graphical user interface (GUI). In addition, the project principals wanted to bring color and video into the lives of the kids using the devices, not just for aesthetic purposes but to enhance learning. Jepsen developed the architecture for an innovative LC transflective display. It functions as a color display in transmissive mode in low lighting but reverts to a monochrome display in reflective mode in direct sunlight. This design could provide high-power efficiency and readability in direct sunlight while also displaying a nice color screen inside the classroom or homes of the children who used them.*</p><p>“I designed the laptop from the screen backwards. This enabled new innovations around cost, power management, and durability. I also put in a sunlight-readable screen with an innovative color/monochrome architecture that gave retina resolution in the reading mode that surpassed the resolution of Apple screens at the time,” said Jepsen.</p><p>CHIMEI Optoelectronics and Chi Lin engineers collaborated with Jepsen and the OLPC design team to manufacture and deliver millions of these transflective displays. CHIMEI also provided the plastic formulation for the case in which the laptop was housed.</p><p>Many prominent technology companies pledged economic support for the program early on, including AMD, eBay, Google, Marvell Technology Group, News Corporation, and Nortel Networks. CHIMEI Optoelectronics and Chi Lin built the screen while HiMax produced the IC display drivers, reaching previously unseen power efficiency standards. Quanta Computer used these components (and others) to build the finished product in 2007 (<b>Fig</b>. 1).</p><p>However, the hardware was only part of the challenge, so the team worked to create a lightweight operating system (open-source Linux-based), a simplified GUI, and self-contained software bundles that were both powerful and easy to use.<span><sup>4</sup></span> Each laptop had to have access to a large repository of data stored locally, as many areas around the globe had no internet access (broadband or otherwise) in the mid-2000s. The laptop's design used a mesh network so that a single computer with internet access could share that access with other OLPC devices in its proximity.<span><sup>5</sup></span> To save cost, power, and weight, the local magnetic or optical hard drive was eliminated, instead relying on the onboard RAM and flash memory cards for data and software storage.</p><p>The program made significant progress in its first two years. Although they never quite reached the $100 price goal, Quanta Computer manufactured the “XO” at a respectable cost of $188, which went into production in 2007.<span><sup>6</sup></span> Each XO laptop included the transflective screen, an integrated video camera, a microphone, long-range Wi-Fi antennas, mesh networking, and a hybrid stylus and touchpad. The XO's 7.5-inch diagonal transflective LCD screen operated in two complementary modes. In reflective mode with the backlight off, the display provided a monochrome image with very high resolution—1,200 × 900 pixels at 200 dpi. In transmissive backlit mode, the display produced full RGB color, but instead of using traditional color filters over the LCD cells, the backlight employed a diffraction grating with lenses that split the light into separate elements of R-G-B and directed those colors into the liquid crystal cells. This eliminated a significant cause of light absorption in traditional RGB LCDs. Both modes could interact so as the ambient light increased, the user would see a combination of monochrome and color content in a complementary fashion. This innovation allowed for significantly lower total backlight energy needed for indoor viewing than other LCD designs of the time. Under high ambient conditions, the viewer would see a high-resolution monochrome image, and the backlight could be shut off to save power. Along with the XO's compact folding design, this allowed for its use as an e-reader device when the laptop was closed.</p><p>Along with a standard plug-in power supply, solar and mechanical (hand crank) power source options were demonstrated in early prototypes, allowing off-grid operation. However, after a less-than-impressive initial demonstration of the hand crank at the prototype's unveiling (by former Secretary-General of the United Nations Kofi Annan), the hand crank option was removed before the unit went into production.<span><sup>7</sup></span></p><p>By the end of 2007, OLPC had sold and distributed more than 600,000 XO laptops,<span><sup>8</sup></span> mostly in Uruguay, Peru, and Mexico. Additional units were sold and distributed in Brazil, Rwanda, Nicaragua, Paraguay, and Nigeria. The XO even saw a few thousand units sold in Alabama and Pennsylvania in the United States for distribution to low-income households. Over the next few years, several million of the OLPC devices were manufactured and distributed worldwide in various incarnations; all featured the innovative transflective display (<b>Fig</b>. 2).</p><p>Although many aspects of the initiative were successful, the OLPC program never quite hit the lofty goals of its founders. Without clear research studies to show the advantages of laptop access for school-age children, as well as extremely tight budgets in the targeted countries, the program did not reach the hundreds of millions of recipients as originally envisioned. In countries such as Peru, which had a fairly high distribution of the XO laptops, follow-up studies showed only minor improvements in math learning and no clearly identifiable improvements in English or other language learning among laptop recipients.</p><p>Many reasons were attributed to the program's somewhat limited success. Cultural issues sometimes stifled parental support as young students discovered Western thought and societal concepts, which conflicted with their communities’ traditional cultural practices and religious beliefs. Also, failure came from more mundane reasons. As many laptop owners can attest, computers break down or develop technical issues, both software- and hardware-related, over time. When you build a laptop at the lowest possible cost, such failures are more likely. Without adequate product support and technical assistance, many of these XO laptops never were deployed in schools or children's homes or had to be taken out of service prematurely, as they developed operational issues without local IT experts to address them. However, Jepsen told us that in some regions, children took the initiative to fix common issues themselves, even creating local repair stations within their communities, thereby extending the usable life of the devices.</p><p>Some years later, Soong visited one of the communities in Brazil that had purchased OLPC laptops for their students. Here he saw a teacher instructing the students on human viruses, which led to students searching the web and discovering the concept of computer viruses. This led them down an unintended but still educational path. What made the biggest impression on Soong was the obvious pride of ownership that these kids had for their laptops. They treated them carefully and decorated them with stickers to express their individuality (<b>Fig</b>. 3).</p><p>“I think that was something that we got right. Giving kids this pride of ownership. It was theirs. And this gave them the excitement to learn using this tool that they otherwise would have had no hope of owning or even using.”</p><p>But the idea that the great “digital divide” could be breached simply by delivering a one-size-fits-all hardware and software package may have been a bit optimistic. Perhaps it would have aided the program's success if more targeted groundwork had been provided to local governments at the project's outset on the value added and how it could be adapted for their specific social and cultural needs. But even if it never quite met its ambitious goals, the OLPC organization and program had positive impacts both in the communities it served and in the industry as a whole.</p><p>On the technical side, the XO laptop developed by OLPC and MIT offered significant innovations in many areas, including power supply design and power efficiency, display design, mesh networking abilities, keyboard, and touchpad design to provide a durable interactive laptop well suited for rugged environments. The unit's dual-mode screen—monochrome for outside, color for indoor use—offered versatility that had never been seen before in a low-budget computer. The intentional omission of all motor-driven moving parts led to the XO's high-power efficiency.</p><p>The technology underwent some updates through the years, including the XO-1.5, which had even fewer physical parts than the original model, the XO-3 tablet, and the XO-4 featuring new components and an optional touchscreen.</p><p>These innovations pushed more established brands to offer low-cost PCs to government and educational markets on the heels of XO's introduction. In 2007, Asus offered the first generation of its Eee laptop (a netbook) for $399, and in 2008, Intel offered the “Classmate” laptop for less than $250. In some cases, countries that initially committed to ordering the XO canceled their orders and opted for name-brand laptops instead to potentially get better performance and support for standard operating systems such as Windows.</p><p>In late 2024, Chromebook laptops from well-known PC-makers could be purchased at national discount retail chains for less than $100. Would this under-$100 laptop milestone have been reached today without the efforts of the OLPC program? We may never know.</p><p>When asked about the legacy of the OLPC project, Soong credits the birth of the educational PC market directly to the OLPC project. “Because there was this OLPC for that price point, all of a sudden, the educational PC market came about. Before that, these laptops were much more expensive, but now we have purpose-built computers and an ecosystem around it.”</p><p>From a display innovation perspective, although transflective displays have not seen much widespread commercialization, the quest for ever-increasing power efficiency has led to e-ink screens that can be used in the retail or outdoor environment for extended periods with no external power source. Soong's company, Agile Display Solutions, makes a 32-inch display that can last for two years on a single battery with no external battery source.</p><p>Looking back on the OLPC project, Soong said, “It was really important to me, personally, because we work to take care of our family, but we also work to hopefully give back to the community. And few of us have the opportunity to do this so early on in our careers. Also, the connections and contacts that I made in the OLPC project have helped me to develop innovative display products like e-paper/e-ink that are so efficient and inexpensive that they can be used to display product information and pricing on store shelves. Walmart is one of our customers, and they are in the process of rolling this out.”</p><p>“My current company, Pervasive Displays (a part of VusionGroup), is now making 1 to 1.5 million of these displays per week. With these network-enabled e-paper labels, companies can save on both materials and labor as price changes can be rolled out store-wide with the flip of a switch. And this can also save a lot of trees with the reduced use of paper in retail. It was the OLPC project that took me down this path.”</p><p>In consideration of the OLPC project's innovation and legacy, Jepsen said, “The OLPC architecture hasn't been matched or exceeded in the last 20 years. It's still the lowest power-consumption laptop and lowest-cost laptop. An innovative architecture enabled this. It was the first mesh-networked laptop, the first laptop designed for children who can't yet read, open source, rugged and droppable, and fixable by children who created repair stations in each country. It generated billions of dollars of revenue and kicked off the fastest-growing consumer electronics category ever recorded: the netbook.</p><p>“The OLPC changed the equation of what a minister of education could do for the children of their country, what could be done for education in a pandemic, and indeed as Sundar Pichai said, its legacy is the Chromebook from Google. It was the great privilege of my life to co-found this organization with Nicholas Negroponte and lead its technology and architecture,” said Jepsen.</p><p>“Two decades later, the machines are so durable and practical that many are actually still in use. And our design meant we delivered the first machines supporting many ‘minor’ languages, like Ethiopia's Amharic. Kids growing up using their own native tongues on computers? What a concept!”</p><p>While the original OLPC charitable organization disbanded in 2014, a nonprofit organization carries on its name and mission, touting that the program has led to the worldwide distribution of more than 3 million laptops and devices. According to their site, their ultimate goal “is to enable learning opportunities so children can transform their environments, societies, and realities.” You can read more about it at https://laptop.org.</p>\",\"PeriodicalId\":52450,\"journal\":{\"name\":\"Information Display\",\"volume\":\"41 1\",\"pages\":\"34-37\"},\"PeriodicalIF\":0.0000,\"publicationDate\":\"2025-01-17\",\"publicationTypes\":\"Journal Article\",\"fieldsOfStudy\":null,\"isOpenAccess\":false,\"openAccessPdf\":\"https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1002/msid.1552\",\"citationCount\":\"0\",\"resultStr\":null,\"platform\":\"Semanticscholar\",\"paperid\":null,\"PeriodicalName\":\"Information Display\",\"FirstCategoryId\":\"1085\",\"ListUrlMain\":\"https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/msid.1552\",\"RegionNum\":0,\"RegionCategory\":null,\"ArticlePicture\":[],\"TitleCN\":null,\"AbstractTextCN\":null,\"PMCID\":null,\"EPubDate\":\"\",\"PubModel\":\"\",\"JCR\":\"Q4\",\"JCRName\":\"Engineering\",\"Score\":null,\"Total\":0}","platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Information Display","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/msid.1552","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"Q4","JCRName":"Engineering","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0

摘要

每个孩子一台笔记本电脑(OLPC)计划有一个简单的前提:如果世界上每个孩子都能获得一台免费或廉价的笔记本电脑,那么任何孩子都能获得大量的学习机会。这种获得技术和信息的机会将有助于缩小资源有限的儿童与资源充足的儿童之间的教育差距。OLPC的想法来自于21世纪初计算机科学家和教育家Seymour Papert和建筑师Nicholas Negroponte在麻省理工学院(MIT)媒体实验室的讨论,当时两人都是教授。佩珀特把锁在高等院校实验室里的电脑比作锁在中世纪图书馆书架上的书:只有那些有特权的人才能从其中隐藏的知识中受益。尼葛洛庞帝把共用一台电脑比作共用一支铅笔。如果两个人同时需要写点什么——或者学点什么呢?内格罗蓬特认为,向大众提供先进教育技术的主要障碍是成本。2004年,笔记本电脑和小型台式电脑每台售价超过1500美元(相当于2024年的2500美元)。2005年在瑞士达沃斯举行的世界经济论坛上,内格罗蓬特敦促科技行业通过制造100美元的笔记本电脑来解决这个问题。他甚至还展示了这种笔记本电脑的早期原型一台低成本的计算机可以使数以百万计的设备发送到世界各地,将知识带到世界的每一个角落。于是,OLPC项目和同名的非营利组织诞生了。在项目初期,尼葛洛庞帝就很清楚,降低笔记本电脑成本的关键是降低显示器的成本,因为显示器是最昂贵的部件。内格罗蓬特2005年从瑞士回到麻省理工学院时,遇到了显示器先驱、SID研究员玛丽·卢·杰普森(Mary Lou Jepsen)。他们的讨论转向了显示器方面的创新,以使低成本的笔记本电脑成为可能,同时也非常节能。Jepsen随后签约成为该项目的负责人之一,并领导核心开发团队。SID成员Scott Soong来自家族科技巨头CHIMEI,他通过台湾的一个研究和发展机构工业技术研究院(ITRI)了解到这个项目。宋子文曾在密歇根州安娜堡大学研究全球发展,并对贫困对个人和经济发展的影响有着浓厚的兴趣。当他得知这个项目时,他拿了一个7英寸的相框显示器,由CHIMEI的子公司Chi Lin生产,跳上了飞往波士顿的飞机,与OLPC团队会面。“你得让我参与进来!”宋子文说。团队同意了。然后,他回到CHIMEI,说服他们加入这个项目。最初的想法是,黑白电子墨水类型的显示器可能是最佳选择,因为它的功率效率高,但这种方法并不可行,因为即使对于图形用户界面(GUI),响应时间也太慢了。此外,项目负责人希望将色彩和视频带入使用这些设备的孩子们的生活中,不仅是为了美观,而且是为了加强学习。杰普森开发了一种创新的LC反射显示器的架构。它的功能作为一个彩色显示在透射模式在低照明,但恢复到单色显示在反射模式在阳光直射。这种设计可以在阳光直射下提供高功率效率和可读性,同时还可以在教室或使用它们的孩子的家中显示漂亮的彩色屏幕。“我从屏幕的反面设计了这款笔记本电脑。这使得围绕成本、电源管理和耐用性的创新成为可能。我还安装了一个阳光下可读的屏幕,它具有创新的彩色/单色架构,在阅读模式下提供的视网膜分辨率超过了当时苹果屏幕的分辨率,”杰普森说。奇美光电和奇林工程师与吉普森和OLPC设计团队合作,制造并交付了数百万台这种反射显示器。奇美还提供了笔记本电脑外壳的塑料配方。许多著名的科技公司在早期就承诺为该计划提供经济支持,包括AMD、eBay、b谷歌、Marvell科技集团、新闻集团和北电网络。CHIMEI Optoelectronics和Chi Lin制造了屏幕,而HiMax生产了IC显示驱动器,达到了以前从未见过的能效标准。广达计算机在2007年使用这些组件(和其他组件)构建成品(图1)。然而,硬件只是挑战的一部分,因此该团队致力于创建轻量级操作系统(基于开源linux),简化的GUI和功能强大且易于使用的自包含软件包。 每台笔记本电脑都必须能够访问本地存储的大型数据存储库,因为在2000年代中期,全球许多地区都没有互联网接入(宽带或其他)。这款笔记本电脑的设计使用了网状网络,这样一台接入互联网的电脑就可以与附近的其他OLPC设备共享访问权限为了节省成本、电力和重量,本地磁性或光学硬盘驱动器被淘汰,取而代之的是依靠板载RAM和闪存卡来存储数据和软件。该项目在头两年取得了重大进展。尽管从未达到100美元的价格目标,广达电脑还是以188美元的可观成本生产了“XO”,并于2007年投入生产。每台XO笔记本电脑都包括反光屏幕、集成摄像机、麦克风、远程Wi-Fi天线、网状网络以及混合触控笔和触摸板。XO的7.5英寸对角线反射LCD屏幕在两种互补模式下运行。在关闭背光的反射模式下,显示器提供了一个非常高分辨率的单色图像——1200 × 900像素,200 dpi。在透射背光模式下,显示器产生全RGB颜色,但不是在LCD单元上使用传统的滤色器,背光采用带透镜的衍射光栅,将光分解成单独的R-G-B元素,并将这些颜色引导到液晶单元中。这消除了传统RGB液晶中光吸收的一个重要原因。两种模式可以相互作用,因此随着环境光的增加,用户将以互补的方式看到单色和彩色内容的组合。与当时的其他LCD设计相比,这一创新使得室内观看所需的总背光能量显著降低。在高环境条件下,观看者将看到高分辨率的单色图像,并且可以关闭背光以节省电力。再加上XO紧凑的折叠设计,这使得它可以在笔记本电脑关闭时作为电子阅读器使用。在早期的原型中,除了标准的插入式电源外,还展示了太阳能和机械(手摇曲柄)电源选项,允许离网运行。然而,在原型揭幕仪式上(由联合国前秘书长科菲·安南),手摇曲柄的初步演示不太令人印象深刻,手摇曲柄选项在该单位投入生产之前被移除。到2007年底,OLPC已经销售和分销了60多万台XO笔记本电脑,其中大部分在乌拉圭、秘鲁和墨西哥。其他单位在巴西、卢旺达、尼加拉瓜、巴拉圭和尼日利亚销售和分销。XO甚至在美国阿拉巴马州和宾夕法尼亚州销售了几千台,分发给低收入家庭。在接下来的几年里,数百万的OLPC设备被制造出来,并以各种形式分布在世界各地;虽然该计划的许多方面都取得了成功,但OLPC计划从未完全实现其创始人的崇高目标。由于没有明确的研究来证明学龄儿童使用笔记本电脑的优势,再加上目标国家的预算极其紧张,该项目没有像最初设想的那样惠及数亿受益者。在秘鲁等XO笔记本电脑分布相当高的国家,后续研究表明,笔记本电脑接收者在数学学习方面只有微小的改善,在英语或其他语言学习方面没有明显的改善。许多原因都归因于该计划在某种程度上的有限成功。当年轻学生发现西方思想和社会观念与他们所在社区的传统文化习俗和宗教信仰相冲突时,文化问题有时会扼杀父母的支持。同样,失败也来自更平凡的原因。正如许多笔记本电脑用户可以证明的那样,随着时间的推移,电脑会出现故障或出现与软件和硬件相关的技术问题。当你以尽可能低的成本制造一台笔记本电脑时,这种故障更有可能发生。由于没有足够的产品支持和技术支持,许多XO笔记本电脑从未在学校或儿童家中部署,或者不得不过早地停止服务,因为它们在没有当地IT专家解决的情况下出现了操作问题。然而,杰普森告诉我们,在一些地区,孩子们主动自己解决常见的问题,甚至在他们的社区内建立了当地的维修站,从而延长了设备的使用寿命。几年后,宋子瑜访问了巴西一个为学生购买OLPC笔记本电脑的社区。在这里,他看到一位老师在给学生讲授人类病毒,这导致学生们上网搜索,发现了计算机病毒的概念。这让他们走上了一条意想不到但仍具有教育意义的道路。 它创造了数十亿美元的收入,并开创了有史以来增长最快的消费电子产品类别:上网本。“OLPC改变了教育部长为本国儿童所能做的事情,改变了在大流行时期为教育所能做的事情,正如桑达尔·皮查伊所说,它的遗产是b谷歌的Chromebook。与尼古拉斯·内格罗蓬特共同创建这个组织并领导它的技术和架构是我一生中最大的荣幸,”杰普森说。二十年后,这种机器非常耐用和实用,许多机器实际上仍在使用。我们的设计意味着我们提供了第一台支持许多“次要”语言的机器,比如埃塞俄比亚的阿姆哈拉语。孩子们在电脑上使用母语长大?这是什么概念啊!”虽然最初的OLPC慈善组织于2014年解散,但一个非营利组织继续沿用其名称和使命,宣称该计划已在全球范围内分发了300多万台笔记本电脑和设备。根据他们的网站,他们的最终目标是“提供学习机会,让孩子们能够改变他们的环境、社会和现实。”你可以在https://laptop.org上了解更多。
本文章由计算机程序翻译,如有差异,请以英文原文为准。

One Laptop Per Child, 20 Years Later: A Project with a Purpose and a Legacy

One Laptop Per Child, 20 Years Later: A Project with a Purpose and a Legacy

THE ONE LAPTOP PER CHILD (OLPC) PROGRAM HAD A SIMPLE PREMISE: IF EVERY child in the world had access to a free or low-cost laptop, vast learning opportunities would be within any child's reach. This access to technology and information would help narrow the educational gap between children with limited resources and those with ample means.

The idea for OLPC came from discussions between computer scientist and educator Seymour Papert and architect Nicholas Negroponte at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology's (MIT's) Media Lab in the early 2000s,1 where the two were professors. Papert likened computers locked in the laboratories of higher learning institutions to books chained to the shelves of medieval libraries: Only those with privileged access were able to benefit from the knowledge hidden within. Negroponte compared the sharing of a computer with the sharing of a pencil. What if two people needed to write something—or learn something—at the same time?

Negroponte's belief was that the main barrier to providing advanced educational technology to the masses was the cost. In 2004, laptops and small desktop computers sold for more than US$1,500 each (approximately $2,500 in 2024 dollars). At the 2005 World Economic Forum in Davos, Switzerland, Negroponte urged the technology industry to solve the problem by creating a $100 laptop. He even demonstrated an early prototype of what such a laptop could look like.2 A low-cost computer could enable millions of the devices to be sent worldwide, bringing knowledge to every corner of the world. Thus, the OLPC program and the non-profit organization of the same name were born.

Early in the program, it was clear to Negroponte that the key to reducing the laptop's cost was to reduce the display's cost, as it was the costliest component. When Negroponte returned to MIT from Switzerland in 2005, he met Mary Lou Jepsen, the display pioneer and SID Fellow. Their discussions turned to the display innovations required to enable a low-cost laptop that also would be extremely power efficient. Jepsen then signed on as one of the principals of the project and led the core development team.

SID member Scott Soong, who hails from the family-owned tech giant CHIMEI, learned about the project through the Industrial Technology Research Institute (ITRI), a research and development organization in Taiwan. Soong had studied global development at the University of Ann Arbor, Michigan, and had a keen interest on the effects of poverty on personal and economic development. When he learned about the project, he grabbed a 7-inch picture frame display, made by CHIMEI's subsidiary Chi Lin, hopped on a plane to Boston, and met with the OLPC team. “Ya gotta let me be a part of this!” said Soong. The team agreed. He then went back to the folks at CHIMEI and convinced them to be a part of the project.

Initial thoughts were that maybe a black and white e-ink type display might be the best choice because of its power efficiency, but this approach would not have been viable because the response time was too slow even for a graphical user interface (GUI). In addition, the project principals wanted to bring color and video into the lives of the kids using the devices, not just for aesthetic purposes but to enhance learning. Jepsen developed the architecture for an innovative LC transflective display. It functions as a color display in transmissive mode in low lighting but reverts to a monochrome display in reflective mode in direct sunlight. This design could provide high-power efficiency and readability in direct sunlight while also displaying a nice color screen inside the classroom or homes of the children who used them.*

“I designed the laptop from the screen backwards. This enabled new innovations around cost, power management, and durability. I also put in a sunlight-readable screen with an innovative color/monochrome architecture that gave retina resolution in the reading mode that surpassed the resolution of Apple screens at the time,” said Jepsen.

CHIMEI Optoelectronics and Chi Lin engineers collaborated with Jepsen and the OLPC design team to manufacture and deliver millions of these transflective displays. CHIMEI also provided the plastic formulation for the case in which the laptop was housed.

Many prominent technology companies pledged economic support for the program early on, including AMD, eBay, Google, Marvell Technology Group, News Corporation, and Nortel Networks. CHIMEI Optoelectronics and Chi Lin built the screen while HiMax produced the IC display drivers, reaching previously unseen power efficiency standards. Quanta Computer used these components (and others) to build the finished product in 2007 (Fig. 1).

However, the hardware was only part of the challenge, so the team worked to create a lightweight operating system (open-source Linux-based), a simplified GUI, and self-contained software bundles that were both powerful and easy to use.4 Each laptop had to have access to a large repository of data stored locally, as many areas around the globe had no internet access (broadband or otherwise) in the mid-2000s. The laptop's design used a mesh network so that a single computer with internet access could share that access with other OLPC devices in its proximity.5 To save cost, power, and weight, the local magnetic or optical hard drive was eliminated, instead relying on the onboard RAM and flash memory cards for data and software storage.

The program made significant progress in its first two years. Although they never quite reached the $100 price goal, Quanta Computer manufactured the “XO” at a respectable cost of $188, which went into production in 2007.6 Each XO laptop included the transflective screen, an integrated video camera, a microphone, long-range Wi-Fi antennas, mesh networking, and a hybrid stylus and touchpad. The XO's 7.5-inch diagonal transflective LCD screen operated in two complementary modes. In reflective mode with the backlight off, the display provided a monochrome image with very high resolution—1,200 × 900 pixels at 200 dpi. In transmissive backlit mode, the display produced full RGB color, but instead of using traditional color filters over the LCD cells, the backlight employed a diffraction grating with lenses that split the light into separate elements of R-G-B and directed those colors into the liquid crystal cells. This eliminated a significant cause of light absorption in traditional RGB LCDs. Both modes could interact so as the ambient light increased, the user would see a combination of monochrome and color content in a complementary fashion. This innovation allowed for significantly lower total backlight energy needed for indoor viewing than other LCD designs of the time. Under high ambient conditions, the viewer would see a high-resolution monochrome image, and the backlight could be shut off to save power. Along with the XO's compact folding design, this allowed for its use as an e-reader device when the laptop was closed.

Along with a standard plug-in power supply, solar and mechanical (hand crank) power source options were demonstrated in early prototypes, allowing off-grid operation. However, after a less-than-impressive initial demonstration of the hand crank at the prototype's unveiling (by former Secretary-General of the United Nations Kofi Annan), the hand crank option was removed before the unit went into production.7

By the end of 2007, OLPC had sold and distributed more than 600,000 XO laptops,8 mostly in Uruguay, Peru, and Mexico. Additional units were sold and distributed in Brazil, Rwanda, Nicaragua, Paraguay, and Nigeria. The XO even saw a few thousand units sold in Alabama and Pennsylvania in the United States for distribution to low-income households. Over the next few years, several million of the OLPC devices were manufactured and distributed worldwide in various incarnations; all featured the innovative transflective display (Fig. 2).

Although many aspects of the initiative were successful, the OLPC program never quite hit the lofty goals of its founders. Without clear research studies to show the advantages of laptop access for school-age children, as well as extremely tight budgets in the targeted countries, the program did not reach the hundreds of millions of recipients as originally envisioned. In countries such as Peru, which had a fairly high distribution of the XO laptops, follow-up studies showed only minor improvements in math learning and no clearly identifiable improvements in English or other language learning among laptop recipients.

Many reasons were attributed to the program's somewhat limited success. Cultural issues sometimes stifled parental support as young students discovered Western thought and societal concepts, which conflicted with their communities’ traditional cultural practices and religious beliefs. Also, failure came from more mundane reasons. As many laptop owners can attest, computers break down or develop technical issues, both software- and hardware-related, over time. When you build a laptop at the lowest possible cost, such failures are more likely. Without adequate product support and technical assistance, many of these XO laptops never were deployed in schools or children's homes or had to be taken out of service prematurely, as they developed operational issues without local IT experts to address them. However, Jepsen told us that in some regions, children took the initiative to fix common issues themselves, even creating local repair stations within their communities, thereby extending the usable life of the devices.

Some years later, Soong visited one of the communities in Brazil that had purchased OLPC laptops for their students. Here he saw a teacher instructing the students on human viruses, which led to students searching the web and discovering the concept of computer viruses. This led them down an unintended but still educational path. What made the biggest impression on Soong was the obvious pride of ownership that these kids had for their laptops. They treated them carefully and decorated them with stickers to express their individuality (Fig. 3).

“I think that was something that we got right. Giving kids this pride of ownership. It was theirs. And this gave them the excitement to learn using this tool that they otherwise would have had no hope of owning or even using.”

But the idea that the great “digital divide” could be breached simply by delivering a one-size-fits-all hardware and software package may have been a bit optimistic. Perhaps it would have aided the program's success if more targeted groundwork had been provided to local governments at the project's outset on the value added and how it could be adapted for their specific social and cultural needs. But even if it never quite met its ambitious goals, the OLPC organization and program had positive impacts both in the communities it served and in the industry as a whole.

On the technical side, the XO laptop developed by OLPC and MIT offered significant innovations in many areas, including power supply design and power efficiency, display design, mesh networking abilities, keyboard, and touchpad design to provide a durable interactive laptop well suited for rugged environments. The unit's dual-mode screen—monochrome for outside, color for indoor use—offered versatility that had never been seen before in a low-budget computer. The intentional omission of all motor-driven moving parts led to the XO's high-power efficiency.

The technology underwent some updates through the years, including the XO-1.5, which had even fewer physical parts than the original model, the XO-3 tablet, and the XO-4 featuring new components and an optional touchscreen.

These innovations pushed more established brands to offer low-cost PCs to government and educational markets on the heels of XO's introduction. In 2007, Asus offered the first generation of its Eee laptop (a netbook) for $399, and in 2008, Intel offered the “Classmate” laptop for less than $250. In some cases, countries that initially committed to ordering the XO canceled their orders and opted for name-brand laptops instead to potentially get better performance and support for standard operating systems such as Windows.

In late 2024, Chromebook laptops from well-known PC-makers could be purchased at national discount retail chains for less than $100. Would this under-$100 laptop milestone have been reached today without the efforts of the OLPC program? We may never know.

When asked about the legacy of the OLPC project, Soong credits the birth of the educational PC market directly to the OLPC project. “Because there was this OLPC for that price point, all of a sudden, the educational PC market came about. Before that, these laptops were much more expensive, but now we have purpose-built computers and an ecosystem around it.”

From a display innovation perspective, although transflective displays have not seen much widespread commercialization, the quest for ever-increasing power efficiency has led to e-ink screens that can be used in the retail or outdoor environment for extended periods with no external power source. Soong's company, Agile Display Solutions, makes a 32-inch display that can last for two years on a single battery with no external battery source.

Looking back on the OLPC project, Soong said, “It was really important to me, personally, because we work to take care of our family, but we also work to hopefully give back to the community. And few of us have the opportunity to do this so early on in our careers. Also, the connections and contacts that I made in the OLPC project have helped me to develop innovative display products like e-paper/e-ink that are so efficient and inexpensive that they can be used to display product information and pricing on store shelves. Walmart is one of our customers, and they are in the process of rolling this out.”

“My current company, Pervasive Displays (a part of VusionGroup), is now making 1 to 1.5 million of these displays per week. With these network-enabled e-paper labels, companies can save on both materials and labor as price changes can be rolled out store-wide with the flip of a switch. And this can also save a lot of trees with the reduced use of paper in retail. It was the OLPC project that took me down this path.”

In consideration of the OLPC project's innovation and legacy, Jepsen said, “The OLPC architecture hasn't been matched or exceeded in the last 20 years. It's still the lowest power-consumption laptop and lowest-cost laptop. An innovative architecture enabled this. It was the first mesh-networked laptop, the first laptop designed for children who can't yet read, open source, rugged and droppable, and fixable by children who created repair stations in each country. It generated billions of dollars of revenue and kicked off the fastest-growing consumer electronics category ever recorded: the netbook.

“The OLPC changed the equation of what a minister of education could do for the children of their country, what could be done for education in a pandemic, and indeed as Sundar Pichai said, its legacy is the Chromebook from Google. It was the great privilege of my life to co-found this organization with Nicholas Negroponte and lead its technology and architecture,” said Jepsen.

“Two decades later, the machines are so durable and practical that many are actually still in use. And our design meant we delivered the first machines supporting many ‘minor’ languages, like Ethiopia's Amharic. Kids growing up using their own native tongues on computers? What a concept!”

While the original OLPC charitable organization disbanded in 2014, a nonprofit organization carries on its name and mission, touting that the program has led to the worldwide distribution of more than 3 million laptops and devices. According to their site, their ultimate goal “is to enable learning opportunities so children can transform their environments, societies, and realities.” You can read more about it at https://laptop.org.

求助全文
通过发布文献求助,成功后即可免费获取论文全文。 去求助
来源期刊
Information Display
Information Display Engineering-Electrical and Electronic Engineering
CiteScore
1.40
自引率
0.00%
发文量
85
期刊介绍: Information Display Magazine invites other opinions on editorials or other subjects from members of the international display community. We welcome your comments and suggestions.
×
引用
GB/T 7714-2015
复制
MLA
复制
APA
复制
导出至
BibTeX EndNote RefMan NoteFirst NoteExpress
×
提示
您的信息不完整,为了账户安全,请先补充。
现在去补充
×
提示
您因"违规操作"
具体请查看互助需知
我知道了
×
提示
确定
请完成安全验证×
copy
已复制链接
快去分享给好友吧!
我知道了
右上角分享
点击右上角分享
0
联系我们:info@booksci.cn Book学术提供免费学术资源搜索服务,方便国内外学者检索中英文文献。致力于提供最便捷和优质的服务体验。 Copyright © 2023 布克学术 All rights reserved.
京ICP备2023020795号-1
ghs 京公网安备 11010802042870号
Book学术文献互助
Book学术文献互助群
群 号:481959085
Book学术官方微信