Population dynamics of defective viral genomes of tomato black ring virus during host-to-host transmission.

Defective viral genomes (DVGs) emerge during error-prone replication of viral genomes and contain deletions, insertions, genomic rearrangements, and hypermutations. These large-effect mutations result in the inability of DVGs to complete an infectious cycle in the absence of a helper wild-type virus. It has been shown that in vitro DVGs usually accumulate in viral populations when a virus is serially passaged in the same host at a high multiplicity of infection. To investigate the impact of host-to-host transmission on DVG formation and population dynamics in vivo, we conducted evolution experiments with tomato black ring virus (TBRV). TBRV was sequentially passaged through a combination of four distinct host species: quinoa, tobacco, lettuce, and spinach. The host was changed every fifth passage. The diversity and population dynamics of DVGs were analyzed based on the RNA-Seq data obtained through sequencing of viral RNA after 20 passages. Our findings indicate the possibility of TBRV DVGs generation when the virus was passaged through different host species. The level of DVG abundance varied across host plant combinations, with a weak indication that the host species past sequence may play a role in DVGs generation. Most abundant DVGs in the TBRV evolved populations were derived from RNA1. Deletions were the most prevalent class of DVGs, followed by insertions. The deletion DVG subpopulation exhibited substantial diversity in species composition and the richness of the deletions species was correlated with their abundance. Longer DVGs characterized by small deletions were predominant, whereas those shorter than 1,000 nucleotides constituted less than 2%.

Importance: Defective viral genomes (DVGs) have been identified in vivo and in vitro for different virus species infecting humans, animals, and plants. The ability to form DVGs during the passaging of virus in one host has been demonstrated, i.e., for tomato black ring virus (TBRV). In our research, RNA-Seq data obtained after TBRV passaging through a combination of four distinct host species were analyzed. Our results indicate that the level of DVG abundance varied across host plant combinations. Deletions were the most prevalent class of DVGs, with the domination of longer species. Additionally, the conserved junction sites in the TBRV genome were identified, resulting in the generation of identical deletions in independently evolved viral lineages. In summary, our findings provide significant insights into the origin and structure of DVGs of plant viruses. The obtained results will help in understanding viral evolution and host-virus interactions.