Do current economic evaluations fully capture vaccine value: a review of evidence from India.

Introduction: Traditional economic evaluations typically focus on direct health effects and costs offset to the healthcare system. However, vaccines offer significant indirect benefits beyond direct health effects, such as herd immunity, reduced force of infection, reduction in antimicrobial resistance, and others. Failure to consider these benefits while evaluating vaccines may undervalue vaccines. Therefore, it is argued that the full value of vaccines should be estimated by incorporating these broader benefits.

Areas covered: This review presents the broader value domains proposed in literature by various frameworks, and their definitions. The review of economic evidence of vaccine use in India to discuss to what extent these broader value domains have been considered in economic evaluations in India has been presented. We also discuss specific considerations that need to be taken care of while developing value frameworks or guidelines for the economic evaluation of vaccines.

Expert opinion: To develop a comprehensive framework tailored to the country needs, prioritize relevant value domains and optimal methodologies based on the country's healthcare context, and data availability. These value domains must align with people's as well as decision-makers preferences to ensure economic assessments are relevant and actionable.