Health-related Quality of Life Assessment in Renal Cell Cancer: A Scoping Review.

Background and objective: In oncology, patient-reported outcome measures (PROMs) capturing health-related quality of life (HRQOL) play an increasing role in clinical trials, drug approval, and policy making. This scoping review aimed to identify and elaborate on HRQOL-focussed PROMs used in renal cell cancer (RCC) clinical trials.

Methods: MEDLINE, Web of Science, PsychINFO, Academic Search Elite, CINAHL, Embase, and the Cochrane Library were searched systematically for original peer-reviewed articles on clinical trials including RCC patients and using PROMs, published between 1950 and 2023. Prespecified trial characteristics and information on the PROMs used were extracted. Frequencies and proportions of categorical data, and ranges and medians of continuous variables were calculated.

Key findings and limitations: Of the 48 unique studies included, the majority followed a randomised controlled design (34, 71%) and evaluated systemic treatments (38, 79%). The trials used 27 different PROMs (max = 6, median = 2), of which only 4 (15%) were developed specifically for kidney cancer patients. Of the trials, 46% did not use any RCC-specific PROM. European Quality of Life-5 Dimensions (EQ-5D), European Organisation for Research and Treatment of Cancer Quality of Life Core Questionnaire (EORTC QLQ-C30), Functional Assessment of Cancer Therapy Kidney Symptom Index (FKSI) -15/19-item version, FKSI-Disease Related Symptoms, and Functional Assessment of Cancer Therapy-General (FACT-G) were the most frequently used questionnaires, with pain, ability to work, fatigue, worry, and sleep quality being the most commonly assessed issues.

Conclusions and clinical implications: A variety of PROMs are used in RCC patients, hindering interpretability across trials. The PROMs used differ in terms of both the domains assessed and how the issues are translated into questionnaire items. Though RCC-specific PROMs exist, these have flaws in terms of relevance to patients. To answer predefined relevant HRQOL research questions, revised RCC-specific PROMs and standardisation of their integration into clinical trials are warranted.

Patient summary: Researchers are more and more interested in the health-related quality of life of kidney cancer patients and use questionnaires to measure it. This review shows that there are many different health-related quality of life questionnaires that are used in different combinations in clinical trials for kidney cancer patients. This makes it very difficult to compare these study results and draw reliable conclusions for the actual clinical treatment. It was even found that some of the questionnaires used do not capture things that patients actually consider important (eg, emotional issues such as dealing with thoughts about cancer and depression). Therefore, more work needs to be done to develop questionnaires that ask what is really important to kidney cancer patients' health-related quality of life. If these questionnaires are used in a consistent way in clinical trials, the results can be better compared. This will help treat kidney cancer patients in the best possible way.