Specific leaf area and its within-individual variation in understory evergreen and deciduous woody species in New Zealand

Specific leaf area (SLA) plays a critical role in carbon assimilation and nutrient cycling. While leaf habit (deciduous vs. evergreen) has often been recognized as a reliable predictor of SLA—with deciduous species typically having higher mean SLA values due to lower concentration of structural components compared to evergreens—high variation in SLA among evergreen species suggests further investigation of variation for species with this leaf habit could improve predictions of SLA effects on community and ecosystem processes. Furthermore, the presence of leaves of different ages in evergreen plants, emerging over multiple years, could amplify the within-individual variation in SLA, which remains underexplored. Here we report variations of SLA measured from c. 2000 leaves collected from 36 individuals across 19 woody species in an understory environment in New Zealand (NZ). We found that while most deciduous species, predominantly non-native, clustered towards higher SLA values, evergreen species presented a wide SLA spectrum. Moreover, we found that while being deciduous, having a smaller leaf size, and younger leaves, collected from lateral branches, correlated with elevated SLA values, the leaf habit did not primarily drive the within-individual SLA variation. Instead, smaller leaf size emerged as a significant predictor of within-individual SLA variation. The branch-order effect on SLA underscores a methodological consideration: accurate estimation of total leaf area in evergreen trees requires representative sampling across all branch orders. Our study also highlights the need for integrating leaf traits such as leaf size and branch order into functional trait analyses. Further research is vital to understand the underlying mechanisms of these trait variations and their impacts on ecosystem functioning.