Calcite recrystallization and its impact on speleothem geochemistry

Speleothems are among the most important archives for past climatic and environmental change. Calcite recrystallization can modify the authigenic structure and geochemical composition of the speleothems and affect the reliability of calcite stalagmites as repositories of authigenic geochemical proxies of past climates and environments. The criteria for distinguishing primary from secondary speleothem calcite, and the conditions (open or semi-closed) of speleothem calcite recrystallization remain poorly understood. Thus, in this study, we investigated the fabric, geochemical composition, and recrystallization dynamics of a partially recrystallized calcite stalagmite (DDH-Z-2) from Didonghe Cave in Shaanxi Province, China, through petrographic observations, fluorescence microscopy, and geochemical analyses (stable isotopes, trace elements, UTh isotopes). We found that: (1) in the DDH-Z-2 stalagmite, open elongated columnar calcite recrystallized into compact elongated columnar calcite. Particulate organic matter and fulvic and humic acids were removed during recrystallization, while aromatic compounds were preserved and became incorporated into the secondary calcite; (2) calcite recrystallization was affected by multiple factors, including external fluid chemistry, primary calcite microstructure, and organic matter; (3) calcite recrystallization occurred under open, fluid-buffered conditions for alteration of the stable isotopes (δ¹⁸O and δ¹³C) and trace elements (Mg, Sr, U). The effect of external fluid composition on trace element (Mg, Sr) composition of secondary calcite varied across the stages of calcite recrystallization. Caution should, therefore, be exercised when using geochemical proxies in stalagmites composed of inclusion-free elongated columnar calcite: such calcite is likely to be recrystallized, and thus record the composition of reactive fluids at the time of recrystallization. Regarding the geochemical system of speleothem diagenesis, the contribution of the parent material and the sources of reactive fluids are key factors to consider.