Patients, colleagues, systems, and self: Exploring layers of physician emotions in caring for pregnant people who use substances and their newborns

Introduction

Pregnant people who use substances experience significant stigma, including in healthcare settings, where physicians make high-stakes decisions about treatment plans, resource allocation, and even a person's ability to parent. Previous psychology research has demonstrated the influence of emotions on decision-making, as well as on the development and expression of stigma. Yet the specific content of physician emotions, as well as approaches to processing these emotions, has been relatively under-examined. We sought to better understand the emotional experiences of physicians who practice in safety-net labor and delivery/inpatient settings to inform strategies to facilitate more humanizing, equitable care.

Methods

From March 2021 to June 2022, the study team conducted semi-structured interviews with 24 San Francisco Bay Area-based physicians (obstetrics-gynecology, pediatrics, family medicine) caring for pregnant people who use substances and/or their newborns. We used deductive and inductive coding and identified themes regarding the nature, etiology, and processing of physician emotions.

Results

Physicians described experiencing a range of emotions related to interpersonal (patients, colleagues), systems-level, and internal dynamics. Emotions such as anger, sadness, frustration, and helplessness resulted from their deep care and empathy for patients, witnessing stigmatizing colleague behaviors, disagreement with punitive systems, and recognition of their own limitations in effecting change. Few participants identified strategies for processing these emotions, and several described efforts to disengage from their emotional experience to preserve their sense of well-being and professionalism.

Conclusions

Physicians caring for pregnant people who use substances and their newborns experienced intense, multi-layered emotions. This study posits that additional efforts to support physician emotional processing and structural competency could improve healthcare experiences and outcomes for pregnant people who use substances.