Ranking the oil contribution of individual layers in a lacustrine shale oil system based on non-hydrocarbon analysis by FT-ICR MS

Identifying the dominating oil-producing layer(s) within a shaly system, typically characterized by multiple layers with similar properties, is always a critical yet formidable task, as the oil component disparities among these closely adjacent layers are too minor to be resolved by the traditional geochemical fingerprints. This challenge is now likely addressed by high-resolution Fourier Transform Ion Cyclotron Resonance Mass Spectrometry (FT-ICR MS), which can resolve thousands of non-hydrocarbons that could serve as new fingerprints. Taking a typical shaly system in the Ordos Basin in China as an example, the specific proportions of non-hydrocarbon compounds from the retained petroleum of different source rock layers (rock extracts) and the produced oil at the wellhead were identified by FT-ICR MS. Their compositional similarity was calculated using a multidimensional scaling (MDS) method, and the layers hosting the retained petroleum with higher compositional similarity to the produced oils are considered to be the main contributors to oil production. The results show that the main producing layers identified by FT-ICR MS differ from those proposed based on traditional fingerprints like the Rock-Eval parameters. A typical example is that the thick low-TOC shales, conventionally proposed to be unessential to oil production, seem to have a similar contribution, if not higher, to their thick silty counterparts. This divergence may be attributed to the fact that the conventional fingerprints primarily rely on the rock extracts from a vertical well section, which may only represent a limited lateral area, while the non-hydrocarbon similarity approach involving the produced oil appears to be more realistic, as it can consider the engineering processes, like the horizontal well track and the hydraulic fracturing effects. The current approach provides a novel route for identifying the dominating producing layer(s) in a shale oil system, which may have extensive potential for optimizing the production strategy of shale oil wells.