Follow-up biopsies in gastrointestinal immune checkpoint inhibitor toxicity may show markedly different inflammatory patterns than initial injury

Colitis is a common manifestation of immune checkpoint inhibitor (ICI) toxicity and can present with varied histologic patterns of inflammation, some of which have been shown to be associated with specific ICI drug types. Although the histologic features of ICI colitis seen at the time of diagnosis have been described, there have been few reports following these patients over time. We evaluated initial and follow-up biopsies in 30 patients with ICI colitis and found that 37% of patients developed a different pattern of injury on follow-up biopsy compared to the initial biopsy. Patients with a different inflammatory pattern were more likely to have restarted ICI therapy before their follow-up biopsy (64%) compared to those without a change in inflammatory pattern (11%; P < 0.01). The majority of these patients had changed ICI drug types (86%). Additionally, many cases changed to an inflammatory bowel disease (IBD)-like pattern (36%), raising a question of de novo IBD. However, all of our patients with an IBD-like pattern experienced sustained resolution of symptoms without steroids or other immunosuppressive medications following discontinuation of ICI therapy, consistent with a diagnosis of ICI toxicity. Our findings suggest that follow-up biopsies in patients with ICI colitis may show a different histology and that this does not necessarily warrant a change in the histologic diagnosis to another disease.