Cropping system support in downy mildew control in basil in organic farming: a two-year open field experiment

Basil Downy Mildew (BDM), caused by the oomycete Peronospora belbahrii, is a major issue for sweet basil (Ocimum basilicum L.) production worldwide. Currently, the disease is mainly controlled by chemical fungicides, but the development of populations of the pathogen which are resistant to the most widely used compounds is leading to the research of alternative crop protection strategies. Therefore, in this paper, some cropping variables were tested in a field trial conducted in two consecutive years (2021 and 2022) in Northern Italy in organic farming conditions, with the overall objective to optimize basil productivity and quality and limit BDM occurrence. These include two basil varieties, two sowing densities (dense, 30 kg/ha, and sparse, 15 kg/ha), and two irrigation systems (drip and sprinkler). A higher incidence and severity of BDM in 2022 compared to 2021 was observed, mainly due to the different climatic conditions that occurred in the two years. Year 2022 was characterized by high temperatures and repeated drought phenomena that led to basil stress and BDM severe outbreak. Moreover, variety 1 (considered resistant to P. belbahrii) was confirmed to be completely resistant in 2021 but it was found to be susceptible the following year, with disease incidence and severity comparable to variety 2 (medium susceptible). No differences were detected in terms of BDM occurrence and crop yield between the two sowing densities (mean of 58.4% and 26.6% of BDM incidence and severity, respectively; mean yield 1.4 kg/m²), while it emerged that drip irrigation can be useful in reducing BDM (−23.1% BDM severity). Therefore, this study suggests that the crop protection strategies tested, even if not definitive solutions, can significantly contribute to manage BDM more effectively, while preserving basil productivity and quality.