A tale of two localizations: coexistence of flat bands and Anderson localization in a photonics-inspired amorphous system

Emerging experimental platforms use amorphousness, a constrained form of disorder, to tailor meta-material properties. We study localization under this type of disorder in a class of $2D$ models generalizing recent experiments on photonic systems. We explore two kinds of localization that emerge in these models: Anderson localization by disorder, and the existence of compact, macroscopically degenerate localized states as in many crystalline flat bands. We find localization properties to depend on the symmetry class within a family of amorphized kagom\'{e} tight-binding models, set by a tunable synthetic magnetic field. The flat-band-like degeneracy innate to kagom\'{e} lattices survives under amorphousness without on-site disorder. This phenomenon arises from the cooperation between the structure of the compact localized states and the geometry of the amorphous graph. For particular values of the field, such states emerge in the amorphous system that were not present on the kagom\'{e} lattice in the same field. For generic states, the standard paradigm of Anderson localization is found to apply as expected for systems with particle-hole symmetry (class D), while a similar interpretation does not extend to our results in the general unitary case (class A). The structure of amorphous graphs, which arise in current photonics experiments, allows exact statements about flat-band-like states, including such states that only exist in amorphous systems, and demonstrates how the qualitative behavior of a disordered system can be tuned at fixed graph topology.