Comparison of second-order spectral line widths formulae

Frequently used second-order spectral line width formulae from the projector operator and kinetic theory methods have not been formally compared previously. It is shown that a systematic second-order expansion of the projection operator expression including initial correlations agrees with the second-order kinetic theory result. The agreement assumes a common approximation in the projector operator method that introduces a screened radiator–perturber interaction to account for neglected electron–electron correlations. On the other hand, it is shown that the usual width expression from the projection operator approach neglecting initial correlations differs from kinetic theory. The differences, however, are at least third order in the radiator–perturber interaction. The comparisons suggest using the more compact width expression from kinetic theory, which includes initial correlations and a systematic screening of the radiator–perturber interactions, as the starting point for second-order width calculations.