Clinical parameter-guided initial resuscitation in adult patients with septic shock: A systematic review and network meta-analysis

Aim

To identify the most useful tissue perfusion parameter for initial resuscitation in sepsis/septic shock adults using a network meta-analysis.

Methods

We searched major databases until December 2022 for randomized trials comparing four tissue perfusion parameters or against usual care. The primary outcome was short-term mortality up to 90 days. The Confidence in Network Meta-Analysis web application was used to assess the quality of evidence.

Results

Seventeen trials were identified. Lactate-guided therapy (risk ratios, 0.59; 95% confidence intervals [0.45–0.76]; high certainty) and capillary refill time-guided therapy (risk ratios, 0.53; 95% confidence intervals [0.33–0.86]; high certainty) were significantly associated with lower short-term mortality compared with usual care, whereas central venous oxygen saturation-guided therapy (risk ratio, 1.50; 95% confidence intervals [1.16–1.94]; moderate certainty) increased the risk of short-term mortality compared with lactate-guided therapy.

Conclusions

Lactate or capillary refill time-guided initial resuscitation for sepsis/septic shock patients may decrease short-term mortality. More research is essential to personalize and optimize treatment strategies for septic shock resuscitation.