Preservice teachers’ errors in the creation and extension of sequences using color tiles: An exploratory study

Recognizing, building, describing, extending, and analyzing patterns are key components of algebraic reasoning. Oftentimes pattern-based instruction is used to support the understanding of functions and variables. In this study, elementary preservice teachers (n = 23) were asked to explore, extend, explain, create equations for, and analyze linear, geometric, and quadratic integer patterns using color tiles. Then they created, extended, described, and analyzed their own patterns while working in groups (n = 8). The research question was: What algebraic errors do PSTs demonstrate in the process of constructing, explaining, and analyzing their own linear, geometric, and quadratic patterns using color tiles? The analysis, which focused on errors and misunderstandings preservice teachers demonstrated in their final unit, revealed three specific areas of difficulties: figural errors, explanation challenges, and improper use of algebraic language. Participants failed to connect their algebraic images in a coherent manner, there was confusion in articulating their algebraic thought processes, and algebraic terminology was improperly used. Implications for teaching and further research are described.