Patients' perspectives on optimal doctor–patient interactions during medical consultation: Lessons for medical educators

Background Perceptions of patients of the nature and quality of the interaction with their doctors during consultation are potentially an important factor determining patient satisfaction and doctors' success. Failure by medical doctors to understand how patients perceive them or what patients desire from them may hinder the establishment of strong, trust-based doctor-patient relationships. The purpose of this study was to explore the health service users' views in a region of Botswana on what constitutes optimal doctor-patient interaction during consultation and propose recommendations for integration into medical education curricula. Methods A purposive sample of 12 individuals was selected in a setting where health and well-being are underpinned by principles of interdependence and interpersonal connections (botho/ubuntu philosophy) for semi-structured interviews using the critical incident technique to elicit desired behaviors and actions of medical doctors during consultation. The participants described their good and bad consultation experiences with medical doctors. The data were analyzed using thematic analysis. Results Three themes, derived from 11 codes, were identified from the data: conversational skills (welcoming and focused), interpersonal skills (humane, respectful, empathetic, unprejudiced, and personal), and professional traits (humble, trustworthy, thorough, and empowering). Discussion Many expressed desires or expectations correspond with humanistic attributes described in the literature, suggesting their universal value. More importantly, the desires and expectations align with the principles of the Bantu philosophy of botho/ubuntu. Accordingly, educators should intentionally provide learning opportunities for students to promote the development of the desired attributes that enhance an effective doctor-patient relationship but should employ culturally relevant pedagogy.