{"title":"幕后:剧作家的女同性恋作品","authors":"Alec Pollak","doi":"10.1353/tyr.2023.a908673","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"Hansberry OffstageThe playwright's lesbian writings Alec Pollak (bio) Click for larger view View full resolution David Attie, contact sheets of Lorraine Hansberry portrait session, 1959. David Attie/Archive Photos via Getty Images. [End Page 60] With each passing year, Lorraine Hansberry rests more comfortably on her laurels. She is secure in the pantheon of twentieth-century literary greats, unequivocally a foremother of Black American drama. This has not always been the case: Hansberry died young, a one-hit wonder and widely misunderstood. A Raisin in the Sun, her 1959 play about a Black American family's struggle against housing segregation, made her the first Broadway-produced Black woman playwright and the youngest-ever winner of the New York Drama Critics' Circle Award. Hansberry's politics may have been far-left, but audiences [End Page 61] understood Raisin as a liberal paean to assimilation. As Black art and politics took an increasingly militant turn in the years after Hansberry's death, her popularity waned. Thanks to the tireless work of her literary estate—headed in its early years by her ex-husband, Robert Nemiroff—Hansberry never slipped entirely out of print or public consciousness, but her afterlife has been full of false starts. Critics, eager to explain away a young Black woman who challenged the limits of their understanding, have been quick to write off Hansberry's oeuvre beyond Raisin as \"the poor remnants of an unfinished life.\" As a result, Hansberry's life and influence have come in and out of focus since her death in 1965: she has been rediscovered each decade, celebrated, and then sidelined anew. Today, we are in the midst of a Hansberry renaissance that one hopes will be her last. Since 2014, three biographies, two documentaries, and a half-dozen exhibitions, commemorative works, and awards-nominated theater revivals have recovered what Soyica Diggs Colbert has called Hansberry's \"radical vision\" as an enduring source of wisdom for the present. For the first time, Hansberry's sexuality has emerged as a meaningful component of her identity, one that demands consideration in any account of her life and work. The timing isn't a coincidence: in 2014, the Lorraine Hansberry Literary Trust avowed publicly that Hansberry was a lesbian and greenlit an unprecedented number of projects. Since then, ten years of commemorative works have reinvented Hansberry as a prophet of feminism, postcolonialism, LGBTQ rights, and Black nationalism who lived an extraordinarily full life, despite her untimely death. With unprecedented access to Hansberry's archive and an engaged, obliging literary estate, the story of Hansberry's multidimensional life seems finally within reach. But the work of understanding her life is far from over. Recent biographers have acknowledged Hansberry's lesbianism, but they have not plumbed the depths of her queer archive or reckoned with her sexuality on Hansberry's own terms: as the \"great personal contradiction\" of her life. Hansberry explored this \"great personal contradiction\" across a series of lesbian-themed stories, four [End Page 62] of which she published in the early gay magazines The Ladder and ONE under the pen name Emily Jones. These four stories, along with snippets of diary entries and letters that have been quoted by her latest biographers, are the primary materials from which contemporary critics have gleaned insight into Hansberry's sexuality. But Hansberry wrote these stories during the self-professed \"childhood\" of her homosexuality, and they are but a small part of her queer corpus. The richer story of Hansberry's lesbianism can be found in a handful of unpublished stories and plays, housed among her papers at the Schomburg Center for Research in Black Culture, in which she explores the evolution of her homosexuality, its role in her life, and its compatibility with the other dimensions of her identity. Unlike her key writings on feminism, anticolonialism, and Blackness, many of which have been published and pored over, these stories remain largely untouched. The Hansberry proffered by the past decade's reappraisals is fearless and fully formed—as clear-eyed and analytically astute about \"the question of homosexuality\" as she is about feminism, colonialism, and Black liberation. \"She was a feminist before the feminist movement,\" explains Imani...","PeriodicalId":43039,"journal":{"name":"YALE REVIEW","volume":"24 1","pages":"0"},"PeriodicalIF":0.1000,"publicationDate":"2023-09-01","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":"{\"title\":\"Hansberry Offstage: The playwright's lesbian writings\",\"authors\":\"Alec Pollak\",\"doi\":\"10.1353/tyr.2023.a908673\",\"DOIUrl\":null,\"url\":null,\"abstract\":\"Hansberry OffstageThe playwright's lesbian writings Alec Pollak (bio) Click for larger view View full resolution David Attie, contact sheets of Lorraine Hansberry portrait session, 1959. David Attie/Archive Photos via Getty Images. [End Page 60] With each passing year, Lorraine Hansberry rests more comfortably on her laurels. She is secure in the pantheon of twentieth-century literary greats, unequivocally a foremother of Black American drama. This has not always been the case: Hansberry died young, a one-hit wonder and widely misunderstood. A Raisin in the Sun, her 1959 play about a Black American family's struggle against housing segregation, made her the first Broadway-produced Black woman playwright and the youngest-ever winner of the New York Drama Critics' Circle Award. Hansberry's politics may have been far-left, but audiences [End Page 61] understood Raisin as a liberal paean to assimilation. As Black art and politics took an increasingly militant turn in the years after Hansberry's death, her popularity waned. Thanks to the tireless work of her literary estate—headed in its early years by her ex-husband, Robert Nemiroff—Hansberry never slipped entirely out of print or public consciousness, but her afterlife has been full of false starts. Critics, eager to explain away a young Black woman who challenged the limits of their understanding, have been quick to write off Hansberry's oeuvre beyond Raisin as \\\"the poor remnants of an unfinished life.\\\" As a result, Hansberry's life and influence have come in and out of focus since her death in 1965: she has been rediscovered each decade, celebrated, and then sidelined anew. Today, we are in the midst of a Hansberry renaissance that one hopes will be her last. Since 2014, three biographies, two documentaries, and a half-dozen exhibitions, commemorative works, and awards-nominated theater revivals have recovered what Soyica Diggs Colbert has called Hansberry's \\\"radical vision\\\" as an enduring source of wisdom for the present. For the first time, Hansberry's sexuality has emerged as a meaningful component of her identity, one that demands consideration in any account of her life and work. The timing isn't a coincidence: in 2014, the Lorraine Hansberry Literary Trust avowed publicly that Hansberry was a lesbian and greenlit an unprecedented number of projects. Since then, ten years of commemorative works have reinvented Hansberry as a prophet of feminism, postcolonialism, LGBTQ rights, and Black nationalism who lived an extraordinarily full life, despite her untimely death. With unprecedented access to Hansberry's archive and an engaged, obliging literary estate, the story of Hansberry's multidimensional life seems finally within reach. But the work of understanding her life is far from over. Recent biographers have acknowledged Hansberry's lesbianism, but they have not plumbed the depths of her queer archive or reckoned with her sexuality on Hansberry's own terms: as the \\\"great personal contradiction\\\" of her life. Hansberry explored this \\\"great personal contradiction\\\" across a series of lesbian-themed stories, four [End Page 62] of which she published in the early gay magazines The Ladder and ONE under the pen name Emily Jones. These four stories, along with snippets of diary entries and letters that have been quoted by her latest biographers, are the primary materials from which contemporary critics have gleaned insight into Hansberry's sexuality. But Hansberry wrote these stories during the self-professed \\\"childhood\\\" of her homosexuality, and they are but a small part of her queer corpus. The richer story of Hansberry's lesbianism can be found in a handful of unpublished stories and plays, housed among her papers at the Schomburg Center for Research in Black Culture, in which she explores the evolution of her homosexuality, its role in her life, and its compatibility with the other dimensions of her identity. Unlike her key writings on feminism, anticolonialism, and Blackness, many of which have been published and pored over, these stories remain largely untouched. The Hansberry proffered by the past decade's reappraisals is fearless and fully formed—as clear-eyed and analytically astute about \\\"the question of homosexuality\\\" as she is about feminism, colonialism, and Black liberation. \\\"She was a feminist before the feminist movement,\\\" explains Imani...\",\"PeriodicalId\":43039,\"journal\":{\"name\":\"YALE REVIEW\",\"volume\":\"24 1\",\"pages\":\"0\"},\"PeriodicalIF\":0.1000,\"publicationDate\":\"2023-09-01\",\"publicationTypes\":\"Journal Article\",\"fieldsOfStudy\":null,\"isOpenAccess\":false,\"openAccessPdf\":\"\",\"citationCount\":\"0\",\"resultStr\":null,\"platform\":\"Semanticscholar\",\"paperid\":null,\"PeriodicalName\":\"YALE REVIEW\",\"FirstCategoryId\":\"1085\",\"ListUrlMain\":\"https://doi.org/10.1353/tyr.2023.a908673\",\"RegionNum\":4,\"RegionCategory\":\"文学\",\"ArticlePicture\":[],\"TitleCN\":null,\"AbstractTextCN\":null,\"PMCID\":null,\"EPubDate\":\"\",\"PubModel\":\"\",\"JCR\":\"0\",\"JCRName\":\"LITERARY REVIEWS\",\"Score\":null,\"Total\":0}","platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"YALE REVIEW","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.1353/tyr.2023.a908673","RegionNum":4,"RegionCategory":"文学","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"0","JCRName":"LITERARY REVIEWS","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
摘要
舞台下剧作家的女同性恋作品亚历克·波拉克(传记)点击查看大图查看全分辨率大卫·阿蒂,洛林·汉斯伯里肖像会议的联系表,1959年。大卫·阿蒂/档案照片通过盖蒂图片。随着时间的流逝,洛林·汉斯伯里更加舒适地享受着她的荣誉。她在20世纪文学伟人的万神殿中占有一席之地,毫无疑问,她是美国黑人戏剧的鼻祖。但事实并非总是如此:汉斯伯里英年早逝,是昙花一现的奇迹,被广泛误解。1959年,她的戏剧《太阳下的葡萄干》(A Raisin the Sun)讲述了一个美国黑人家庭反对住房隔离的斗争,使她成为百老汇第一位黑人女剧作家,也是纽约戏剧评论家圈奖(New York Drama Critics’Circle Award)有史以来最年轻的获奖者。汉斯伯里的政治主张可能是极左翼的,但观众却把《葡萄干》理解为对同化的自由主义赞歌。在汉斯伯里死后的几年里,黑人艺术和政治变得越来越激进,她的受欢迎程度也在下降。由于她的文学遗产(早年由她的前夫掌管)孜孜不倦的工作,罗伯特·内米罗夫-汉斯伯里从未完全从出版物或公众意识中消失,但她的死后却充满了错误的开端。评论家们急于为这位挑战他们理解极限的年轻黑人女性开脱,他们很快就把汉斯伯里在《葡萄干》之外的全部作品斥为“未完成生命的可怜残余物”。因此,自1965年汉斯伯里去世以来,她的生活和影响就时而受到关注,时而淡出人们的视线:她每十年都被重新发现,被庆祝,然后再次被边缘化。今天,我们正处于汉斯伯里的复兴之中,人们希望这将是她的最后一次复兴。自2014年以来,汉斯伯里的三部传记、两部纪录片、六场展览、纪念作品和获奖提名的戏剧复兴,恢复了索伊卡·迪格斯·科尔伯特(Soyica Diggs Colbert)所称的“激进愿景”,成为当今智慧的持久源泉。汉斯伯里的性取向第一次成为她身份的一个有意义的组成部分,在任何对她生活和工作的描述中都需要考虑到这一点。这个时机并非巧合:2014年,洛林·汉斯伯里文学信托基金会公开承认汉斯伯里是女同性恋,并为空前数量的项目开绿灯。从那以后,10年的纪念作品将汉斯伯里重塑为女权主义、后殖民主义、LGBTQ权利和黑人民族主义的先知,尽管她英年早逝,但她的一生非常充实。随着对汉斯伯里档案的前所未有的访问,以及一个忙碌的、乐于助人的文学遗产,汉斯伯里多维度生活的故事似乎终于触手可及。但了解她生活的工作远未结束。最近的传记作家已经承认了汉斯伯里的女同性恋身份,但他们并没有深入研究她的同性恋档案,也没有用汉斯伯里自己的方式来看待她的性取向:作为她生活中“巨大的个人矛盾”。汉斯伯里通过一系列以女同性恋为主题的故事探索了这种“巨大的个人矛盾”,其中四篇以笔名艾米丽·琼斯(Emily Jones)发表在早期的同性恋杂志《阶梯》(the Ladder)和《ONE》(ONE)上。这四个故事,加上她最近的传记作者引用的日记和信件的片段,是当代评论家了解汉斯伯里性取向的主要材料。但汉斯伯里写这些故事的时候,她自称是同性恋的“童年”,而这些故事只是她酷儿作品的一小部分。汉斯伯里更丰富的女同性恋故事可以在一些未发表的故事和戏剧中找到,这些故事和戏剧收藏在她在朔姆伯格黑人文化研究中心的论文中,她探讨了她的同性恋的演变,它在她生活中的作用,以及它与她身份的其他方面的兼容性。与她关于女权主义、反殖民主义和黑人问题的主要著作不同,她的许多作品都已出版并被广泛关注,而这些故事基本上没有被触及。在过去十年的重新评价中,汉斯伯里是无所畏惧的、完全形成的——她对“同性恋问题”的看法与对女权主义、殖民主义和黑人解放的看法一样清晰、分析敏锐。“在女权主义运动之前,她就是一个女权主义者,”伊玛尼解释说。
Hansberry Offstage: The playwright's lesbian writings
Hansberry OffstageThe playwright's lesbian writings Alec Pollak (bio) Click for larger view View full resolution David Attie, contact sheets of Lorraine Hansberry portrait session, 1959. David Attie/Archive Photos via Getty Images. [End Page 60] With each passing year, Lorraine Hansberry rests more comfortably on her laurels. She is secure in the pantheon of twentieth-century literary greats, unequivocally a foremother of Black American drama. This has not always been the case: Hansberry died young, a one-hit wonder and widely misunderstood. A Raisin in the Sun, her 1959 play about a Black American family's struggle against housing segregation, made her the first Broadway-produced Black woman playwright and the youngest-ever winner of the New York Drama Critics' Circle Award. Hansberry's politics may have been far-left, but audiences [End Page 61] understood Raisin as a liberal paean to assimilation. As Black art and politics took an increasingly militant turn in the years after Hansberry's death, her popularity waned. Thanks to the tireless work of her literary estate—headed in its early years by her ex-husband, Robert Nemiroff—Hansberry never slipped entirely out of print or public consciousness, but her afterlife has been full of false starts. Critics, eager to explain away a young Black woman who challenged the limits of their understanding, have been quick to write off Hansberry's oeuvre beyond Raisin as "the poor remnants of an unfinished life." As a result, Hansberry's life and influence have come in and out of focus since her death in 1965: she has been rediscovered each decade, celebrated, and then sidelined anew. Today, we are in the midst of a Hansberry renaissance that one hopes will be her last. Since 2014, three biographies, two documentaries, and a half-dozen exhibitions, commemorative works, and awards-nominated theater revivals have recovered what Soyica Diggs Colbert has called Hansberry's "radical vision" as an enduring source of wisdom for the present. For the first time, Hansberry's sexuality has emerged as a meaningful component of her identity, one that demands consideration in any account of her life and work. The timing isn't a coincidence: in 2014, the Lorraine Hansberry Literary Trust avowed publicly that Hansberry was a lesbian and greenlit an unprecedented number of projects. Since then, ten years of commemorative works have reinvented Hansberry as a prophet of feminism, postcolonialism, LGBTQ rights, and Black nationalism who lived an extraordinarily full life, despite her untimely death. With unprecedented access to Hansberry's archive and an engaged, obliging literary estate, the story of Hansberry's multidimensional life seems finally within reach. But the work of understanding her life is far from over. Recent biographers have acknowledged Hansberry's lesbianism, but they have not plumbed the depths of her queer archive or reckoned with her sexuality on Hansberry's own terms: as the "great personal contradiction" of her life. Hansberry explored this "great personal contradiction" across a series of lesbian-themed stories, four [End Page 62] of which she published in the early gay magazines The Ladder and ONE under the pen name Emily Jones. These four stories, along with snippets of diary entries and letters that have been quoted by her latest biographers, are the primary materials from which contemporary critics have gleaned insight into Hansberry's sexuality. But Hansberry wrote these stories during the self-professed "childhood" of her homosexuality, and they are but a small part of her queer corpus. The richer story of Hansberry's lesbianism can be found in a handful of unpublished stories and plays, housed among her papers at the Schomburg Center for Research in Black Culture, in which she explores the evolution of her homosexuality, its role in her life, and its compatibility with the other dimensions of her identity. Unlike her key writings on feminism, anticolonialism, and Blackness, many of which have been published and pored over, these stories remain largely untouched. The Hansberry proffered by the past decade's reappraisals is fearless and fully formed—as clear-eyed and analytically astute about "the question of homosexuality" as she is about feminism, colonialism, and Black liberation. "She was a feminist before the feminist movement," explains Imani...