《中东戏剧:在表演与政治之间》,巴巴克·拉希米主编(书评)

Q-mars Haeri
{"title":"《中东戏剧:在表演与政治之间》,巴巴克·拉希米主编(书评)","authors":"Q-mars Haeri","doi":"10.1353/dtc.2023.a912009","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"Reviewed by: Theater in the Middle East: Between Performance and Politics ed. by Babak Rahimi Q-mars Haeri Theater in the Middle East: Between Performance and Politics. Edited by Babak Rahimi. Anthem Press, 2020. Hardcover $125, E-book $40. 184 pages. 7 illustrations. Theater in the Middle East: Between Performance and Politics is a long overdue and necessary book on the topic of Middle Eastern theatre. Theatre and performance studies in the Global North have been dominated by a narrative that theatre does not exist in the Middle East, largely due to a certain interpretation of Islam that does not allow representational art. Scholars have been working to change that narrative for the past two decades, but prior to this book, no collection has brought together the work many have done to depict the true diversity of the region’s performance traditions. From court festivities in 1850s Iran to radio drama in the Syrian diaspora of the 2010s, this anthology presents diverse forms of performance that address notions of nationalism and transnationalism, gender performativity and representation, and the interconnectivity of Indigenous “traditional” and “modern” theatre. Babak Rahimi’s introduction to Theater in the Middle East serves two important purposes. On the one hand, it offers a brief yet comprehensive history of theatre in the region. It provides immense knowledge on the topic to the general reader and to the specialist alike. While it may be impossible to write about all forms of theatre in the region, Rahimi has managed to put together interconnected theatre histories of North Africa, the Levant, Iran, and the Gulf countries. In doing so, he provides necessary context for the chapters that follow. On the other hand, this introduction is a reflection on the concept of translation and the ways in which translation (both literary and embodied) have shaped performances in the region. He argues that theatrical performances occur “under changing conditions that reflect both local and trans-local influences” (9). With this in mind, he problematizes the identifier “Middle East” as itself “a geographical imaginary of a Eurocentric bias” (4) and attempts to redefine Middle Eastern theatre in terms of practices that are experientially and hermeneutically complex as well as transcultural. Theater in the Middle East is divided into two parts. Part 1, “Pedagogy and Tradition,” is about pedagogues of the Middle East as well as how Middle Eastern theatre is taught in North America. For example, in chapter 1 Michael Malek Najjar [End Page 79] describes his process of co-teaching Middle Eastern theatre with Sahar Assaf. Najjar provided students with materials that accurately reflected different perspectives on areas of transnational conflict. Throughout the chapter, the course is discussed as both made possible and limited by the number of English translations of Middle Eastern plays. For those teaching courses on Middle Eastern theatre, this chapter serves as a great reference, as it categorizes and presents valuable resources and a list of plays. Authors in part 1 also explore the interplay between “traditional” performance forms and “modern theatre.” As Rahimi mentions, cultural progress in the Middle East has been attributed to European colonization and the Westernization of art. As a result, the term modern theatre, in a regional context, usually refers to productions of European plays in proscenium theatres. Rana Salimi challenges these preconceived notions about modernization in Iran by focusing on women’s performances in the nineteenth-century Qajar court. In her view, such court performances paved the way for the women’s movements that followed in the twentieth century and beyond. Salimi acknowledges that many performances carried out under the Shah were not empowering; nonetheless, the court of the 1850s–1890s also featured performances by and for women, including cross-dressing traditional religious roles, which for centuries had been exclusively performed by men. Similarly, Khalid Amine’s Moroccan case studies reveal women’s empowerment in and the political potential of traditional forms. Amine focuses on the contemporary theatrical utilization of al-halqa, a storytelling genre performed in a circular format with a narrative similar to Shahrzad’s One Thousand and One Nights—a story within a story. In this fascinating chapter, Amine argues that this form is “self-generating” and, as exemplified by...","PeriodicalId":488979,"journal":{"name":"Journal of dramatic theory and criticism","volume":"12 1","pages":"0"},"PeriodicalIF":0.0000,"publicationDate":"2023-06-01","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":"{\"title\":\"Theater in the Middle East: Between Performance and Politics ed. by Babak Rahimi (review)\",\"authors\":\"Q-mars Haeri\",\"doi\":\"10.1353/dtc.2023.a912009\",\"DOIUrl\":null,\"url\":null,\"abstract\":\"Reviewed by: Theater in the Middle East: Between Performance and Politics ed. by Babak Rahimi Q-mars Haeri Theater in the Middle East: Between Performance and Politics. Edited by Babak Rahimi. Anthem Press, 2020. Hardcover $125, E-book $40. 184 pages. 7 illustrations. Theater in the Middle East: Between Performance and Politics is a long overdue and necessary book on the topic of Middle Eastern theatre. Theatre and performance studies in the Global North have been dominated by a narrative that theatre does not exist in the Middle East, largely due to a certain interpretation of Islam that does not allow representational art. Scholars have been working to change that narrative for the past two decades, but prior to this book, no collection has brought together the work many have done to depict the true diversity of the region’s performance traditions. From court festivities in 1850s Iran to radio drama in the Syrian diaspora of the 2010s, this anthology presents diverse forms of performance that address notions of nationalism and transnationalism, gender performativity and representation, and the interconnectivity of Indigenous “traditional” and “modern” theatre. Babak Rahimi’s introduction to Theater in the Middle East serves two important purposes. On the one hand, it offers a brief yet comprehensive history of theatre in the region. It provides immense knowledge on the topic to the general reader and to the specialist alike. While it may be impossible to write about all forms of theatre in the region, Rahimi has managed to put together interconnected theatre histories of North Africa, the Levant, Iran, and the Gulf countries. In doing so, he provides necessary context for the chapters that follow. On the other hand, this introduction is a reflection on the concept of translation and the ways in which translation (both literary and embodied) have shaped performances in the region. He argues that theatrical performances occur “under changing conditions that reflect both local and trans-local influences” (9). With this in mind, he problematizes the identifier “Middle East” as itself “a geographical imaginary of a Eurocentric bias” (4) and attempts to redefine Middle Eastern theatre in terms of practices that are experientially and hermeneutically complex as well as transcultural. Theater in the Middle East is divided into two parts. Part 1, “Pedagogy and Tradition,” is about pedagogues of the Middle East as well as how Middle Eastern theatre is taught in North America. For example, in chapter 1 Michael Malek Najjar [End Page 79] describes his process of co-teaching Middle Eastern theatre with Sahar Assaf. Najjar provided students with materials that accurately reflected different perspectives on areas of transnational conflict. Throughout the chapter, the course is discussed as both made possible and limited by the number of English translations of Middle Eastern plays. For those teaching courses on Middle Eastern theatre, this chapter serves as a great reference, as it categorizes and presents valuable resources and a list of plays. Authors in part 1 also explore the interplay between “traditional” performance forms and “modern theatre.” As Rahimi mentions, cultural progress in the Middle East has been attributed to European colonization and the Westernization of art. As a result, the term modern theatre, in a regional context, usually refers to productions of European plays in proscenium theatres. Rana Salimi challenges these preconceived notions about modernization in Iran by focusing on women’s performances in the nineteenth-century Qajar court. In her view, such court performances paved the way for the women’s movements that followed in the twentieth century and beyond. Salimi acknowledges that many performances carried out under the Shah were not empowering; nonetheless, the court of the 1850s–1890s also featured performances by and for women, including cross-dressing traditional religious roles, which for centuries had been exclusively performed by men. Similarly, Khalid Amine’s Moroccan case studies reveal women’s empowerment in and the political potential of traditional forms. Amine focuses on the contemporary theatrical utilization of al-halqa, a storytelling genre performed in a circular format with a narrative similar to Shahrzad’s One Thousand and One Nights—a story within a story. In this fascinating chapter, Amine argues that this form is “self-generating” and, as exemplified by...\",\"PeriodicalId\":488979,\"journal\":{\"name\":\"Journal of dramatic theory and criticism\",\"volume\":\"12 1\",\"pages\":\"0\"},\"PeriodicalIF\":0.0000,\"publicationDate\":\"2023-06-01\",\"publicationTypes\":\"Journal Article\",\"fieldsOfStudy\":null,\"isOpenAccess\":false,\"openAccessPdf\":\"\",\"citationCount\":\"0\",\"resultStr\":null,\"platform\":\"Semanticscholar\",\"paperid\":null,\"PeriodicalName\":\"Journal of dramatic theory and criticism\",\"FirstCategoryId\":\"1085\",\"ListUrlMain\":\"https://doi.org/10.1353/dtc.2023.a912009\",\"RegionNum\":0,\"RegionCategory\":null,\"ArticlePicture\":[],\"TitleCN\":null,\"AbstractTextCN\":null,\"PMCID\":null,\"EPubDate\":\"\",\"PubModel\":\"\",\"JCR\":\"\",\"JCRName\":\"\",\"Score\":null,\"Total\":0}","platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Journal of dramatic theory and criticism","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.1353/dtc.2023.a912009","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"","JCRName":"","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0

摘要

评:《中东戏剧:表演与政治之间》,作者:巴巴克·拉希米·q·马斯·哈里。Babak Rahimi编辑。国歌出版社,2020年。精装本125美元,电子书40美元。184页。7插图。《中东戏剧:在表演与政治之间》是一本姗姗来迟的关于中东戏剧的必读书籍。全球北方的戏剧和表演研究一直被一种叙事所主导,即中东不存在戏剧,这主要是由于对伊斯兰教的某种解释不允许具象艺术。在过去的二十年里,学者们一直在努力改变这种说法,但在这本书之前,没有一本文集汇集了许多人所做的工作,以描绘该地区表演传统的真正多样性。从19世纪50年代伊朗的宫廷庆典到2010年代叙利亚侨民的广播剧,这本选集呈现了不同形式的表演,探讨了民族主义和跨国主义的概念,性别表演和表现,以及土著“传统”和“现代”戏剧的相互联系。巴巴克·拉希米对中东戏剧的介绍有两个重要目的。一方面,它提供了一个简短而全面的戏剧在该地区的历史。它为普通读者和专家提供了关于该主题的大量知识。虽然不可能写出该地区所有形式的戏剧,但拉希米设法将北非、黎凡特、伊朗和海湾国家相互关联的戏剧历史汇集在一起。在这样做的过程中,他为接下来的章节提供了必要的背景。另一方面,这篇介绍是对翻译概念的反思,以及翻译(文学和具体化)如何塑造了该地区的表演。他认为,戏剧表演发生在“反映本地和跨本地影响的不断变化的条件下”(9)。考虑到这一点,他将“中东”这个标识符本身视为“欧洲中心主义偏见的地理想象”(4),并试图根据经验和解释学上的复杂以及跨文化的实践来重新定义中东戏剧。中东地区的戏剧分为两部分。第一部分,“教育学与传统”,是关于中东的教师,以及中东戏剧是如何在北美教授的。例如,在第一章中,Michael Malek Najjar [End Page 79]描述了他与Sahar Assaf共同教授中东戏剧的过程。纳贾尔为学生提供的材料准确地反映了对跨国冲突领域的不同观点。在这一章中,我们讨论了中东戏剧英译本的数量,这使得这门课程成为可能,也受到了限制。对于那些讲授中东戏剧课程的人来说,本章是一个很好的参考,因为它对有价值的资源和戏剧列表进行了分类和介绍。作者在第一部分中还探讨了“传统”表演形式与“现代戏剧”之间的相互作用。正如拉希米所提到的,中东的文化进步归功于欧洲的殖民和艺术的西方化。因此,术语现代戏剧,在一个地区的背景下,通常是指在舞台剧院制作的欧洲戏剧。Rana Salimi通过关注19世纪卡扎尔宫廷中的女性表演,挑战了这些关于伊朗现代化的先入为主的观念。在她看来,这样的宫廷表演为20世纪及以后的妇女运动铺平了道路。萨利米承认,在沙阿统治下进行的许多表演都没有赋予权力;尽管如此,19世纪50年代至90年代的宫廷也以女性表演为特色,包括几个世纪以来一直由男性表演的传统宗教角色。同样,Khalid Amine的摩洛哥案例研究揭示了妇女在传统形式中的赋权和政治潜力。阿明关注当代戏剧对al-halqa的运用,al-halqa是一种以循环形式表演的叙事形式,类似于沙扎德的《一千零一夜》——故事中的故事。在这一引人入胜的章节中,Amine认为这种形式是“自我生成的”,并且,如…
本文章由计算机程序翻译,如有差异,请以英文原文为准。
Theater in the Middle East: Between Performance and Politics ed. by Babak Rahimi (review)
Reviewed by: Theater in the Middle East: Between Performance and Politics ed. by Babak Rahimi Q-mars Haeri Theater in the Middle East: Between Performance and Politics. Edited by Babak Rahimi. Anthem Press, 2020. Hardcover $125, E-book $40. 184 pages. 7 illustrations. Theater in the Middle East: Between Performance and Politics is a long overdue and necessary book on the topic of Middle Eastern theatre. Theatre and performance studies in the Global North have been dominated by a narrative that theatre does not exist in the Middle East, largely due to a certain interpretation of Islam that does not allow representational art. Scholars have been working to change that narrative for the past two decades, but prior to this book, no collection has brought together the work many have done to depict the true diversity of the region’s performance traditions. From court festivities in 1850s Iran to radio drama in the Syrian diaspora of the 2010s, this anthology presents diverse forms of performance that address notions of nationalism and transnationalism, gender performativity and representation, and the interconnectivity of Indigenous “traditional” and “modern” theatre. Babak Rahimi’s introduction to Theater in the Middle East serves two important purposes. On the one hand, it offers a brief yet comprehensive history of theatre in the region. It provides immense knowledge on the topic to the general reader and to the specialist alike. While it may be impossible to write about all forms of theatre in the region, Rahimi has managed to put together interconnected theatre histories of North Africa, the Levant, Iran, and the Gulf countries. In doing so, he provides necessary context for the chapters that follow. On the other hand, this introduction is a reflection on the concept of translation and the ways in which translation (both literary and embodied) have shaped performances in the region. He argues that theatrical performances occur “under changing conditions that reflect both local and trans-local influences” (9). With this in mind, he problematizes the identifier “Middle East” as itself “a geographical imaginary of a Eurocentric bias” (4) and attempts to redefine Middle Eastern theatre in terms of practices that are experientially and hermeneutically complex as well as transcultural. Theater in the Middle East is divided into two parts. Part 1, “Pedagogy and Tradition,” is about pedagogues of the Middle East as well as how Middle Eastern theatre is taught in North America. For example, in chapter 1 Michael Malek Najjar [End Page 79] describes his process of co-teaching Middle Eastern theatre with Sahar Assaf. Najjar provided students with materials that accurately reflected different perspectives on areas of transnational conflict. Throughout the chapter, the course is discussed as both made possible and limited by the number of English translations of Middle Eastern plays. For those teaching courses on Middle Eastern theatre, this chapter serves as a great reference, as it categorizes and presents valuable resources and a list of plays. Authors in part 1 also explore the interplay between “traditional” performance forms and “modern theatre.” As Rahimi mentions, cultural progress in the Middle East has been attributed to European colonization and the Westernization of art. As a result, the term modern theatre, in a regional context, usually refers to productions of European plays in proscenium theatres. Rana Salimi challenges these preconceived notions about modernization in Iran by focusing on women’s performances in the nineteenth-century Qajar court. In her view, such court performances paved the way for the women’s movements that followed in the twentieth century and beyond. Salimi acknowledges that many performances carried out under the Shah were not empowering; nonetheless, the court of the 1850s–1890s also featured performances by and for women, including cross-dressing traditional religious roles, which for centuries had been exclusively performed by men. Similarly, Khalid Amine’s Moroccan case studies reveal women’s empowerment in and the political potential of traditional forms. Amine focuses on the contemporary theatrical utilization of al-halqa, a storytelling genre performed in a circular format with a narrative similar to Shahrzad’s One Thousand and One Nights—a story within a story. In this fascinating chapter, Amine argues that this form is “self-generating” and, as exemplified by...
求助全文
通过发布文献求助,成功后即可免费获取论文全文。 去求助
来源期刊
自引率
0.00%
发文量
0
×
引用
GB/T 7714-2015
复制
MLA
复制
APA
复制
导出至
BibTeX EndNote RefMan NoteFirst NoteExpress
×
提示
您的信息不完整,为了账户安全,请先补充。
现在去补充
×
提示
您因"违规操作"
具体请查看互助需知
我知道了
×
提示
确定
请完成安全验证×
copy
已复制链接
快去分享给好友吧!
我知道了
右上角分享
点击右上角分享
0
联系我们:info@booksci.cn Book学术提供免费学术资源搜索服务,方便国内外学者检索中英文文献。致力于提供最便捷和优质的服务体验。 Copyright © 2023 布克学术 All rights reserved.
京ICP备2023020795号-1
ghs 京公网安备 11010802042870号
Book学术文献互助
Book学术文献互助群
群 号:604180095
Book学术官方微信