Performances of Pointing Phonological Memory Tasks between Children with and without Speech Sound Disorders

Objectives: A new phonological memory task using pointing responses was developed and the performance of each sub-task was compared between children with and without speech sound disorders (SSD). Methods: 16 children with SSD and 14 typically developing children (TD) performed pointing memory tasks, which consists of four sub-tasks—auditory short-term, auditory working, visual short-term, and visual working memory; and performances between groups and between each sub-task were compared. In addition, the correlation between the new task and the existing task (digit span task), vocabulary sizes and the accuracy of consonants was analyzed. Results: First, the SSD group showed significantly lower performance in the pointing memory tasks than the TD group. Second, both the SSD and TD groups showed significantly higher performance in auditory stimulation compared with visual stimulation, and in short-term memory than working memory. Third, in the case of the TD group, the performance of the auditory short-term memory task was much better, and there were no significant differences among the other three sub-tasks, while the SSD group showed a sequential decline in performances among the four sub-tasks. Finally, there was a high correlation between the new task and the existing task, vocabulary sizes, and the accuracy of consonants. Conclusion: The low performance in the phonological memory task of the SSD group is not due to weakness in articulation or in auditory processing, but to defects in phonological short-term/working memory itself. The results of this study provide meaningful information on the different performance patterns of phonological memory tasks according to stimulus modalities between the SSD and TD groups.