Education Research: Quality and Validity Evidence for a National In-Training Examination for Epilepsy Fellows

Background and Objectives Epilepsy education has been transformed over the past 2 decades, leading to a need for structured formative assessment tools. The American Epilepsy Society developed the Epilepsy Fellowship In-Training Examination (EpiFITE) to provide high-quality formative assessment for fellows, to stimulate program improvement, and to guide future learning and teaching. The aim of this study was to explore validity evidence for the EpiFITE in meeting these goals. Methods Validity evidence was sought from multiple sources. The content of the examination was linked to the American Board of Psychiatry and Neurology blueprint for initial certification in epilepsy, and items were developed by trained experts. Internal structure was studied using internal consistency and item analysis. Surveys of fellows and fellowship directors focused on the examination experience (response process) and how results influenced fellow assessment, future learning, and program improvement (relationship to other variables and consequences). Results The EpiFITE was first administered in 2020, with 172 examinees from 67 programs. By 2022 (year 3), the EpiFITE was completed by 195 epilepsy fellows from 77 programs. The overall mean score of the examination was stable from year to year, and the committee predicted the difficulty of individual items with a high degree of accuracy. The examination had high internal consistency (Cronbach α 0.76–0.81). The median item discrimination index ranged from 0.17 in 2020 to 0.21 in 2022. Discrimination indices were lower (mean ≤0.10) for items that were either very easy or very difficult and significantly higher (mean >0.20) for other items. Program directors and epilepsy fellows agreed the examination questions were appropriate and agreed that the EpiFITE helped them identify areas for self-directed learning. Program directors also found the examination helpful in identifying areas of strength and areas for improvement within their programs. Discussion There are several sources of evidence of the quality and validity of the EpiFITE. By exploring this validity evidence, we have identified several best practices in the development and evaluation of a subspecialty examination, and this experience could be helpful for developers of in-training examinations in other subspecialties.