Compositional Analysis of Conventional and Unconventional Permian Basin-Produced Waters: A Simple Tool for Predicting Major Ion Composition

Treatment methods for produced water (PW) are significantly affected by a high concentration of total dissolved solids (TDS), a summation of dissolved organic and inorganic compositions. Understanding the constituents of TDS to eliminate or prevent chemical reactions is critical in the design optimization of the treatment processes. In this paper, two PW geochemical data sets generated from conventional and unconventional reservoirs in the Permian Basin were analyzed to correlate constituents with TDS. Compositional data sets from over 115,000 PW samples originally reported by the U.S. Geological Survey (USGS) and 45 oil and gas operations were analyzed. Data preprocessing, culling, systematized- and meta-analysis, and statistical techniques were adapted to associate the data. Subcompositional geochemical data were transformed into isometric log ratios and are presented in bivariate and multivariate plots. Results indicate that Na+ and Ca2+ were the dominant cations and Cl− was the dominant anion. No observable trend differences in the Na+, Cl−, Ca2+, Mg+, and SO42− concentrations between PW from conventional and unconventional wells were registered. Variations in the isometric log ratio of Na/Cl and Ca/SO4 with TDS revealed that Na/Cl was nearly constant over the range of TDS, suggesting mineral buffering or a lack of significant water/rock reactions involving Na and Cl, and that Ca/SO4 increased with TDS, indicating that low-salinity fluids may have dissolved anhydrite producing a value near zero, with Ca gain and/or SO4 loss with increasing salinity. In all 10 counties and 8 formations investigated in this work, the ln (Ca/SO4) denotes Ca gain/SO4 loss relative to their composition in anhydrite or Permian seawater. Likely mechanisms leading to elevated ln (Ca/SO4) include sulfate reduction, dolomitization of calcite, Na/Ca cation exchange, albitization, and anhydrite precipitation from Ca-rich fluids. Results from this work are important as it is revealed that Ca/SO4 and Na/Cl can potentially be predicted from PW TDS concentrations. This information was combined to create a reservoir or location-specific model to estimate Na, Cl, Ca, and SO4 concentrations in Permian Basin PW, a powerful tool to improve treatment and reuse options in areas with few direct data.