Empirical Predictability Study of SDN Switches

To meet their increasingly stringent dependability requirements, communication networks need to be predictable, both in terms of correctness and performance. In principle, Software-Defined Networks (SDN) enable such more predictable networks, however, these networks still depend the underlying switches. This paper presents an empirical study of the predictability of SDN switches. Our extensive benchmarking of seven hardware OpenFlow switches from four different manufacturers raises several concerns regarding the dependability of these switches. We uncover several incorrect and unpredictable behaviors and performance issues. In particular, we identify unpredictable behaviors related to the management of flows and buffers, and observe that existing quality-of-service mechanisms, such as priority queuing, introduce unexpected overheads. The latter, in turn, can lead to violations of latency guarantees. Based on our insights, we discuss first solutions toward more predictable architectures.