{"title":"21世纪初乌克兰小提琴微缩中巴洛克风格的风格化:音乐意识形成的细节","authors":"A. Melnyk","doi":"10.34064/KHNUM2-19.09","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"Introduction. Nowadays, continuing the neo-style trend in musical art started in the 20 century, increased attention is being attracted to the intentions of stylization and reinterpretation of a certain historical artistic models, where stylistic allusions (a kind of indirect citation, hint) use. This stylistic phenomenon has special spiritual and ethical preconditions that culturologists interpret in view of the so-called neo-restoration trends in culture. The above also applies to Ukrainian violin music, where the creative method of stylization, which has acquired such great importance in the art of the twentieth century, is actively in demand even today, in the modern postmodern style situation. Thus, the appearance of pieces in the Ukrainian violin repertoire, which even by their name declare its relation with the models of baroque genres, programming a certain creative idea, deserves to be studied in order to explore their direct relation to the original genre form and identify the algorithms for its stylization. All this, at least, will have a positive effect on the practice of the perception of stylization artifacts of a certain genre invariant, including the miniatures of the baroque type. The material of this research is the works of modern Ukrainian composers in the genre of violin miniatures, based on stylization of Baroque genre forms, which have taken a prominent place in academic musical creativity in general and in the history of the formation of the violin repertoire in particular. The stylistic variety of genre reminiscences in the Ukrainian violin repertoire is reflected in a number of materials by Ukrainian researchers (I. Andrievskyi, I. Hrebneva, V. Zaranskyi, I. Karachevtseva, V. Lapsiuk, I. Pilatiuk, S. Sandiuk, L. Skrypnyk, S. Yadlovskyi), where, in particular, the question of the demand for the so-called “violin miniature” (A. Haray, N. Pilatiuk) appears. However, the conceptual definition of a violin miniature today does not look completely methodologically adequate: the stereotypical norms of comprehending this class of genres touch exclusively the side of scale proportions, which contradicts the latest approaches to the interpretation of genre forms by the method of semantic analysis, namely, when the genre invariant is considered as a sign of a certain typed content. However, only taking into account the act of typification, the reference indications necessary for the formation of musical consciousness are established, which serve as a reliable guide in recognizing the genre nature of a work and discovering the cultural, historical and communicative ties necessary for its understanding. Thus, the purpose of this article is to reveal the peculiarities of stylistic modifications of baroque genres in the Ukrainian violin repertoire of the early XXI century and to propose methodological guidelines for analyzing the diversity of interpretations of the genre invariant under the influence of the historically actual style. The complex of the analytical methods (analysis, synthesis, induction, deduction, comparative studies), as well as the historicaltypological and the prognostic approach was used in this research. Results of the research. The examples of stylization of baroque genres prove that in the postmodern stylistic dimension the intention to genre-stylistic allusions to the historically known is an important factor in the expression of the cultureforming ties of distant eras with modernity. Quite often, the very name of the genre used by the composer gives an orientation towards the perception of the range of corresponding historical and stylistic associations. The method of stylizing baroque genres and their rethinking thanks to new means of musical expression (specific melodic development, a special character of sound production and articulation, etc.) gives vivid artistic results. The samples examined demonstrate a variety of interesting author’s solutions based on the involvement of a historical genre model. Thus, Hanna Leonova’s Toccata (2010) is quite consistent with the genre image oftoccata as a “motor” piece. However, we note that the genre form of toccata is by no means associated (at least for today) with the actual violin repertoire, especially with the miniature, since it primarily existed in clavier music (recall, in particular, the clavier toccatas by J. S. Bach), and a row of the samples has a magnificent solemnity of sound and compositional monumentality. Nevertheless, the author found the opportunities to implement the “toccata” style, hinting at the genesis of this genre (etymologically – from “touch”, “sort out”), thanks to the compositional and performance specifics – improvisation, stability of rhythmical “motor” movement and high virtuosity. In “Sarabanda” by Vitalii Manik (2013) we observe only partial keeping of the three-beat meter normative for the chosen genre model, however, with a polyphonic presentation adequate in relation to the primary stylistic modus; in “Minuet” by Oleksii Voitenko (2003) – the stylistics of “music to dance”, but within the compositional boundaries of sonatina without the developing part. Victor Telichko’s “Partita” (2011) demonstrates cyclicality and reliance on dance elements, quite characteristic of the baroque version of this genre, but embodied in Ukrainian folk material. Avoiding quotations, the author preserves the melodic-rhythmic structure of folk-song material and creates his own thematic complex. At the same time, the use of a solo violin in this work is fully consistent with the traditions of the Baroque era, namely, Bach’s partita model; that is why a kind of allusion to the genre invariant arises. That is, applying allusions to baroque genres in violin miniature, contemporary Ukrainian composers demonstrate at least two approaches: the first is stylistic adequacy to the genre invariant (in its baroque version); the second is its actual stylization with the introduction of either a certain stylistic context, or an individual author’s compositional idea. Conclusions. Thus, the new conceptualization of the violin miniature requires an appropriate research approach, the basis of which is the semantic method of analyzing the genre invariant in musical works-stylizations, which has proven its fruitfulness in the postmodern era. Since the method of stylization always provides for a special relation to the genre invariant, the constancy of which has the ability to accumulate ever new typifying meanings, only a combination of analytical discourses that take into account both the genesis of the genre form and its stylistic modifications can form theoretically verified analytical models that are useful, among other things, in the learning process, contributing to the development of the musical consciousness of the recipient – the performer and the listener.","PeriodicalId":302721,"journal":{"name":"Aspects of Historical Musicology","volume":"EM-14 3","pages":"0"},"PeriodicalIF":0.0000,"publicationDate":"2020-02-07","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":"{\"title\":\"Stylization of Baroque genres in the Ukrainian violin miniature of the early 21st century: specifics of musical consciousness formation\",\"authors\":\"A. Melnyk\",\"doi\":\"10.34064/KHNUM2-19.09\",\"DOIUrl\":null,\"url\":null,\"abstract\":\"Introduction. Nowadays, continuing the neo-style trend in musical art started in the 20 century, increased attention is being attracted to the intentions of stylization and reinterpretation of a certain historical artistic models, where stylistic allusions (a kind of indirect citation, hint) use. This stylistic phenomenon has special spiritual and ethical preconditions that culturologists interpret in view of the so-called neo-restoration trends in culture. The above also applies to Ukrainian violin music, where the creative method of stylization, which has acquired such great importance in the art of the twentieth century, is actively in demand even today, in the modern postmodern style situation. Thus, the appearance of pieces in the Ukrainian violin repertoire, which even by their name declare its relation with the models of baroque genres, programming a certain creative idea, deserves to be studied in order to explore their direct relation to the original genre form and identify the algorithms for its stylization. All this, at least, will have a positive effect on the practice of the perception of stylization artifacts of a certain genre invariant, including the miniatures of the baroque type. The material of this research is the works of modern Ukrainian composers in the genre of violin miniatures, based on stylization of Baroque genre forms, which have taken a prominent place in academic musical creativity in general and in the history of the formation of the violin repertoire in particular. The stylistic variety of genre reminiscences in the Ukrainian violin repertoire is reflected in a number of materials by Ukrainian researchers (I. Andrievskyi, I. Hrebneva, V. Zaranskyi, I. Karachevtseva, V. Lapsiuk, I. Pilatiuk, S. Sandiuk, L. Skrypnyk, S. Yadlovskyi), where, in particular, the question of the demand for the so-called “violin miniature” (A. Haray, N. Pilatiuk) appears. However, the conceptual definition of a violin miniature today does not look completely methodologically adequate: the stereotypical norms of comprehending this class of genres touch exclusively the side of scale proportions, which contradicts the latest approaches to the interpretation of genre forms by the method of semantic analysis, namely, when the genre invariant is considered as a sign of a certain typed content. However, only taking into account the act of typification, the reference indications necessary for the formation of musical consciousness are established, which serve as a reliable guide in recognizing the genre nature of a work and discovering the cultural, historical and communicative ties necessary for its understanding. Thus, the purpose of this article is to reveal the peculiarities of stylistic modifications of baroque genres in the Ukrainian violin repertoire of the early XXI century and to propose methodological guidelines for analyzing the diversity of interpretations of the genre invariant under the influence of the historically actual style. The complex of the analytical methods (analysis, synthesis, induction, deduction, comparative studies), as well as the historicaltypological and the prognostic approach was used in this research. Results of the research. The examples of stylization of baroque genres prove that in the postmodern stylistic dimension the intention to genre-stylistic allusions to the historically known is an important factor in the expression of the cultureforming ties of distant eras with modernity. Quite often, the very name of the genre used by the composer gives an orientation towards the perception of the range of corresponding historical and stylistic associations. The method of stylizing baroque genres and their rethinking thanks to new means of musical expression (specific melodic development, a special character of sound production and articulation, etc.) gives vivid artistic results. The samples examined demonstrate a variety of interesting author’s solutions based on the involvement of a historical genre model. Thus, Hanna Leonova’s Toccata (2010) is quite consistent with the genre image oftoccata as a “motor” piece. However, we note that the genre form of toccata is by no means associated (at least for today) with the actual violin repertoire, especially with the miniature, since it primarily existed in clavier music (recall, in particular, the clavier toccatas by J. S. Bach), and a row of the samples has a magnificent solemnity of sound and compositional monumentality. Nevertheless, the author found the opportunities to implement the “toccata” style, hinting at the genesis of this genre (etymologically – from “touch”, “sort out”), thanks to the compositional and performance specifics – improvisation, stability of rhythmical “motor” movement and high virtuosity. In “Sarabanda” by Vitalii Manik (2013) we observe only partial keeping of the three-beat meter normative for the chosen genre model, however, with a polyphonic presentation adequate in relation to the primary stylistic modus; in “Minuet” by Oleksii Voitenko (2003) – the stylistics of “music to dance”, but within the compositional boundaries of sonatina without the developing part. Victor Telichko’s “Partita” (2011) demonstrates cyclicality and reliance on dance elements, quite characteristic of the baroque version of this genre, but embodied in Ukrainian folk material. Avoiding quotations, the author preserves the melodic-rhythmic structure of folk-song material and creates his own thematic complex. At the same time, the use of a solo violin in this work is fully consistent with the traditions of the Baroque era, namely, Bach’s partita model; that is why a kind of allusion to the genre invariant arises. That is, applying allusions to baroque genres in violin miniature, contemporary Ukrainian composers demonstrate at least two approaches: the first is stylistic adequacy to the genre invariant (in its baroque version); the second is its actual stylization with the introduction of either a certain stylistic context, or an individual author’s compositional idea. Conclusions. Thus, the new conceptualization of the violin miniature requires an appropriate research approach, the basis of which is the semantic method of analyzing the genre invariant in musical works-stylizations, which has proven its fruitfulness in the postmodern era. Since the method of stylization always provides for a special relation to the genre invariant, the constancy of which has the ability to accumulate ever new typifying meanings, only a combination of analytical discourses that take into account both the genesis of the genre form and its stylistic modifications can form theoretically verified analytical models that are useful, among other things, in the learning process, contributing to the development of the musical consciousness of the recipient – the performer and the listener.\",\"PeriodicalId\":302721,\"journal\":{\"name\":\"Aspects of Historical Musicology\",\"volume\":\"EM-14 3\",\"pages\":\"0\"},\"PeriodicalIF\":0.0000,\"publicationDate\":\"2020-02-07\",\"publicationTypes\":\"Journal Article\",\"fieldsOfStudy\":null,\"isOpenAccess\":false,\"openAccessPdf\":\"\",\"citationCount\":\"0\",\"resultStr\":null,\"platform\":\"Semanticscholar\",\"paperid\":null,\"PeriodicalName\":\"Aspects of Historical Musicology\",\"FirstCategoryId\":\"1085\",\"ListUrlMain\":\"https://doi.org/10.34064/KHNUM2-19.09\",\"RegionNum\":0,\"RegionCategory\":null,\"ArticlePicture\":[],\"TitleCN\":null,\"AbstractTextCN\":null,\"PMCID\":null,\"EPubDate\":\"\",\"PubModel\":\"\",\"JCR\":\"\",\"JCRName\":\"\",\"Score\":null,\"Total\":0}","platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Aspects of Historical Musicology","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.34064/KHNUM2-19.09","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"","JCRName":"","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
摘要
介绍。如今,延续着始于20世纪的音乐艺术的新风格趋势,人们越来越关注对某些历史艺术模式进行风格化和重新诠释的意图,其中使用了风格典故(一种间接引用,暗示)。这种文体现象具有特殊的精神和伦理前提,文化学家根据所谓的文化新修复趋势来解释这种前提。上述情况也适用于乌克兰小提琴音乐,其中风格化的创造性方法,在二十世纪的艺术中获得了如此巨大的重要性,即使在今天,在现代后现代风格的情况下,也是积极的需求。因此,乌克兰小提琴保留曲目中的作品的出现值得研究,以探索它们与原始流派形式的直接关系,并确定其风格化的算法,即使它们的名字也表明它与巴洛克风格的模式有关,编程了某种创造性的想法。所有这一切,至少,将对某种类型不变的风格化人工制品的感知实践产生积极影响,包括巴洛克类型的微缩。本研究的材料是现代乌克兰作曲家在小提琴微缩流派的作品,基于巴洛克流派形式的风格化,这在学术音乐创作中占据了突出的地位,特别是在小提琴曲目的形成历史中。乌克兰研究人员(I. Andrievskyi, I. Hrebneva, V. Zaranskyi, I. Karachevtseva, V. Lapsiuk, I. Pilatiuk, S. Sandiuk, L. Skrypnyk, S. Yadlovskyi)的许多材料反映了乌克兰小提琴曲目中的风格多样性,特别是对所谓的“小提琴微型”(a . Haray, N. Pilatiuk)的需求问题。然而,今天小提琴微缩的概念定义在方法论上看起来并不完全合适:理解这类类型的刻板规范只涉及尺度比例方面,这与通过语义分析方法解释类型形式的最新方法相矛盾,即,当类型不变式被认为是某种类型内容的标志时。然而,只有考虑到类型化行为,才能建立音乐意识形成所必需的参考指示,这是认识作品类型性质和发现理解作品所必需的文化、历史和交流联系的可靠指南。因此,本文的目的是揭示二十一世纪早期乌克兰小提琴保留曲目中巴洛克风格的风格修改的特殊性,并提出在历史实际风格影响下分析类型不变解释的多样性的方法论指导方针。本研究采用了分析、综合、归纳、演绎、比较研究等综合分析方法,以及历史类型学方法和预测方法。研究结果。巴洛克风格风格化的例子证明,在后现代的风格维度中,对历史已知的类型风格典故的意图是表达遥远时代与现代性的文化改革联系的重要因素。通常情况下,作曲家所使用的音乐类型的名字会给人一种对相应的历史和风格联系范围的感知方向。巴洛克风格的风格化方法以及由于新的音乐表现手段(特定的旋律发展、声音制作和发音的特殊特征等)而进行的重新思考,产生了生动的艺术效果。研究的样本展示了基于历史类型模型的各种有趣的作者解决方案。因此,Hanna Leonova的Toccata(2010)与Toccata作为一个“马达”作品的类型形象是相当一致的。然而,我们注意到托卡塔的体裁形式与实际的小提琴曲目没有任何联系(至少在今天),特别是与缩微曲,因为它主要存在于键盘音乐中(特别是回想一下J. S.巴赫的键盘托卡塔),并且一排样品具有宏伟的声音庄严和作曲纪念性。尽管如此,作者还是找到了实现“托卡塔”风格的机会,暗示了这一流派的起源(词源学上-来自“触摸”,“整理”),这要归功于作曲和表演的特点-即兴,有节奏的“运动”运动的稳定性和精湛的技艺。
Stylization of Baroque genres in the Ukrainian violin miniature of the early 21st century: specifics of musical consciousness formation
Introduction. Nowadays, continuing the neo-style trend in musical art started in the 20 century, increased attention is being attracted to the intentions of stylization and reinterpretation of a certain historical artistic models, where stylistic allusions (a kind of indirect citation, hint) use. This stylistic phenomenon has special spiritual and ethical preconditions that culturologists interpret in view of the so-called neo-restoration trends in culture. The above also applies to Ukrainian violin music, where the creative method of stylization, which has acquired such great importance in the art of the twentieth century, is actively in demand even today, in the modern postmodern style situation. Thus, the appearance of pieces in the Ukrainian violin repertoire, which even by their name declare its relation with the models of baroque genres, programming a certain creative idea, deserves to be studied in order to explore their direct relation to the original genre form and identify the algorithms for its stylization. All this, at least, will have a positive effect on the practice of the perception of stylization artifacts of a certain genre invariant, including the miniatures of the baroque type. The material of this research is the works of modern Ukrainian composers in the genre of violin miniatures, based on stylization of Baroque genre forms, which have taken a prominent place in academic musical creativity in general and in the history of the formation of the violin repertoire in particular. The stylistic variety of genre reminiscences in the Ukrainian violin repertoire is reflected in a number of materials by Ukrainian researchers (I. Andrievskyi, I. Hrebneva, V. Zaranskyi, I. Karachevtseva, V. Lapsiuk, I. Pilatiuk, S. Sandiuk, L. Skrypnyk, S. Yadlovskyi), where, in particular, the question of the demand for the so-called “violin miniature” (A. Haray, N. Pilatiuk) appears. However, the conceptual definition of a violin miniature today does not look completely methodologically adequate: the stereotypical norms of comprehending this class of genres touch exclusively the side of scale proportions, which contradicts the latest approaches to the interpretation of genre forms by the method of semantic analysis, namely, when the genre invariant is considered as a sign of a certain typed content. However, only taking into account the act of typification, the reference indications necessary for the formation of musical consciousness are established, which serve as a reliable guide in recognizing the genre nature of a work and discovering the cultural, historical and communicative ties necessary for its understanding. Thus, the purpose of this article is to reveal the peculiarities of stylistic modifications of baroque genres in the Ukrainian violin repertoire of the early XXI century and to propose methodological guidelines for analyzing the diversity of interpretations of the genre invariant under the influence of the historically actual style. The complex of the analytical methods (analysis, synthesis, induction, deduction, comparative studies), as well as the historicaltypological and the prognostic approach was used in this research. Results of the research. The examples of stylization of baroque genres prove that in the postmodern stylistic dimension the intention to genre-stylistic allusions to the historically known is an important factor in the expression of the cultureforming ties of distant eras with modernity. Quite often, the very name of the genre used by the composer gives an orientation towards the perception of the range of corresponding historical and stylistic associations. The method of stylizing baroque genres and their rethinking thanks to new means of musical expression (specific melodic development, a special character of sound production and articulation, etc.) gives vivid artistic results. The samples examined demonstrate a variety of interesting author’s solutions based on the involvement of a historical genre model. Thus, Hanna Leonova’s Toccata (2010) is quite consistent with the genre image oftoccata as a “motor” piece. However, we note that the genre form of toccata is by no means associated (at least for today) with the actual violin repertoire, especially with the miniature, since it primarily existed in clavier music (recall, in particular, the clavier toccatas by J. S. Bach), and a row of the samples has a magnificent solemnity of sound and compositional monumentality. Nevertheless, the author found the opportunities to implement the “toccata” style, hinting at the genesis of this genre (etymologically – from “touch”, “sort out”), thanks to the compositional and performance specifics – improvisation, stability of rhythmical “motor” movement and high virtuosity. In “Sarabanda” by Vitalii Manik (2013) we observe only partial keeping of the three-beat meter normative for the chosen genre model, however, with a polyphonic presentation adequate in relation to the primary stylistic modus; in “Minuet” by Oleksii Voitenko (2003) – the stylistics of “music to dance”, but within the compositional boundaries of sonatina without the developing part. Victor Telichko’s “Partita” (2011) demonstrates cyclicality and reliance on dance elements, quite characteristic of the baroque version of this genre, but embodied in Ukrainian folk material. Avoiding quotations, the author preserves the melodic-rhythmic structure of folk-song material and creates his own thematic complex. At the same time, the use of a solo violin in this work is fully consistent with the traditions of the Baroque era, namely, Bach’s partita model; that is why a kind of allusion to the genre invariant arises. That is, applying allusions to baroque genres in violin miniature, contemporary Ukrainian composers demonstrate at least two approaches: the first is stylistic adequacy to the genre invariant (in its baroque version); the second is its actual stylization with the introduction of either a certain stylistic context, or an individual author’s compositional idea. Conclusions. Thus, the new conceptualization of the violin miniature requires an appropriate research approach, the basis of which is the semantic method of analyzing the genre invariant in musical works-stylizations, which has proven its fruitfulness in the postmodern era. Since the method of stylization always provides for a special relation to the genre invariant, the constancy of which has the ability to accumulate ever new typifying meanings, only a combination of analytical discourses that take into account both the genesis of the genre form and its stylistic modifications can form theoretically verified analytical models that are useful, among other things, in the learning process, contributing to the development of the musical consciousness of the recipient – the performer and the listener.