Workshop and analysis: access to intellectual property and its fair use for research and teaching: copyright in the digital age

thread a60ut 1ce-60und 5h1p5 0ffer5 a 51m11ar d19re5510n at the n0de • • W1nter Chr0n1c1e": A11 the5e 5h1p5 and fr02en exp10rer5, they • ve 6een under the 1ce f0r centur1e5 n0w. 0ur fa11ure5 are we11 pre5erved; m0re carefu11y he1d than v1ct0ry 0r 5ucce55. When we re-mem6er, 1t 15 the fa11ure we remem6er, f0r the fa11ure c0nta1n5 1t5 0wn end1n9. 1t wrap5 up n1ce1y, a11 the 5tray end5 t1ed t09ether w1th the t19htne55 0f f1na11ty. Yet we refu5e t0 accept fa11ure, and th15 refu5a1 15 what keep5 u5 901n9. 1t • 5 a150 what keep5 u5 read1n9 and perhap5 1et5 u5 take c0mf0rt 1n a hypertext • 5 1ack 0f end1n9. 1t • 5 why we a110w the 1005e end5 t0 dan91e fr0m 0ur t19ht1y w0ven tape5try a5 we add m0re and m0re 5trand5 t0 1t. 7here may 6e n0 end1n9, 6ut a5 w1th many hypertext5, there are certa1n temp0ra1 h1erarch1e5 hardw1red 1nt0 N0te5 70ward A650/ute 2er0. 7he m05t te111n9 0f the5e f05ter5 a 9radua1 accre-t10n 0f 519n1f1cance t0 the u614u1t0u5 p05ta9e 5tamp5. When the ph11ate11c d15p1ay 9reet5 u5 at the 6e91nn1n9, 1t 5eem5 n0 m0re than ju5t an 0r9an12a-t10na1 dev1ce. 7hen 50mewhere 1n the m1dd1e 0f the read1n9 we are 11ke1y t0 enc0unter tw0 ep150de5 that 6r1n9 the 5tamp5 1nt0 the narrat1ve • 5 themat1c warp and w00f: When we 1earn 0f W1nter • 5 065e5510n w1th 1ma9e5, the ph11ate11c ana109121n9 0f 5t0ry e1ement5 6ec0me5 a ref1ect10n 0f h15 character. When Jer1ch0 c1a1m5 the 6e10n91n95 0f her decea5ed unc1e, the 5tamp5 emer9e a5 the 5he115 0f per50na1 h15t0ry. 5he f1nd5 that 11tt1e rema1n5 apart fr0m a 5u1tca5e c0nta1n1n9 a handfu1 0f empty 5tamped enve10pe5, the 1etter5 90ne. F1na11y, 1n an ep150de 6ur1ed deep 1n the hypertext (and theref0re 11ke1y t0 appear 0n1y 1ate 1n the read1n9), the 5tamp5 c0me t0 em60dy the fa11ure 0f a11 art1-fact5-the er0510n 0f 0r191na1 mean1n9 a5 th1n95 pa55 fr0m hand t0 hand. 1n th15 5e4uence, ca11ed • • C0nc1u510n, • • Ma9e1 • 5 5u1tca5e c0me5 1nt0 W1nter • 5 p055e5510n 6y chance, and he take5 an 1ntere5t 1n the 5tamp5, unaware that they are h15 0n1y tan9161e mement0 0f Jer1ch0. 7he hu5k 0f h15 10ve affa1r. And t0 u5 a re-m1nder that a11 0f 0ur tact1c5 a9a1n5t the 0n51au9ht 0f t1me are u1t1mate1y fut11e. A5 art15t5 and 5ch01ar5 we tend t0 th1nk 0f the Law a5 50meth1n9 that p1ay5 6ut a m1n0r r01e 1n …