{"title":"从世界尽头(Les Eyzies, Dordogne,法国)到neuchatel(瑞士):旧石器时代家具艺术收藏的路线和性质(Vogt collection, latenium)","authors":"François-Xavier Chauvière, Marc-Antoine Kaeser","doi":"10.3406/bspf.2020.15105","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"EnglishThe Vogt collection of the Latenium (Neuchâtel, Switzerland) includes six pieces of engraved and/or sculpted Paleolithic portable art, either completely unpublished or only published in part. These finds come from Le Bout-du-Monde rock shelter (Les Eyzies, Dordogne, France), which was excavated between 1908 and 1910 by a certain Lucas, an assistant teacher at Les Eyzies and subsequently in 1945 by Denis Peyrony (1869-1954), who recorded the archaeo-sequence and the stratigraphy of the site. The stratigraphy was made up of four sedimentary layers, numbered from A to D from top to bottom (D- earth and scree : 0.40 m thick; C- river sands containing archaeological material: 0.30 m thick; B- Dry calcareous scree from the desquamation of the shelter walls, with fluvial sands: 0.50 cm thick; A- fluvial sands, with some calcareous scree with blunt edges. In this level, Peyrony reported the presence of a reindeer antler: 1.55 m thick) and the bedrock. While there is a possible presence of the Middle phase of the Magdalenian, the Upper and Final stages of the Magdalenian, as well as the Azilian, are, on the other hand, well documented and used by most authors to date the artefacts unearthed at Le Bout-du-Monde. The Vogt collection consists of a collection of different objects. A broken perforated baton made of reindeer antler (Rangifer tarandus) engraved with five bison heads in left profile and a stallion horse seen in right profile. A fragment of horse scapula (Equus caballus) engraved with a horse?€?s head in right profile used the spongy tissue of the bone to depict the animal's mane. A reindeer in left profile appears on a fragment of reindeer (Rangifer tarandus) right mandible. A one end of a hemi-rib from an animal larger than a reindeer is engraved and sculpted in the shape of a fish tail, perhaps from the salmon family. Moreover, there is a diaphysis portion of reindeer (Rangifer tarandus) tibia, engraved with a multitude of non-figurative drawings, made prior to the probable figuration of a feline. A limestone pebble depicts a deer with a disproportionate body (a female), next to which a fawn appears in a sitting position. Comparing these objects with the unpublished records made by Henri Breuil (1877-1961) and kept in the central library of the Museum national d'histoire naturelle of Paris (Breuil iconographic collection) shows that the engraved and sculpted artefacts have been well preserved. However, the surfaces of certain objects such as the broken perforated baton made from reindeer antler have deteriorated, as some marks seem to have disappeared over time. Finally, a schist plate engraved with the left profile of a bison is only known by a tracing by Henri Breuil. There is no information on the stratigraphic and spatial position of the archaeological material in the rock-shelter. However, it does not seem to date earlier than the Middle Magdalenian. Pending the direct dating of the organic supports, the question of a date earlier than the Upper Magdalenian (Azilian) is left open. The research conducted on the Vogt collection has traced the path of these objects from their discovery at the beginning of the 20th century to their acquisition for the Latenium. While Lucas sold Le Bout-du-Monde material immediately after their discovery to Otto Hauser (1874-1932), they were then acquired by a \"Swiss amateur\" who seems to be Emil Vogt (1906-1974), a prominent figure in 20th century European prehistory, before being finally sold by his heirs in 1991. The journey of the Palaeolithic portable art of the Vogt collection is replaced in the historical context of the constitution of the Latenium collections, and more broadly within the dynamics of the transfer of prehistoric antiquities between Switzerland and France, which started in the middle of the 19th century. This historical analysis highlights the scientific motives behind the collectors' acquisition, characterised by a widespread export of Swiss lake-dwelling materials, partly counterbalanced by the targeted import into Switzerland of archaeological remains from Palaeolithic reference sites of the Perigord, including pieces of portable art. francaisLa collection Vogt du Latenium (Neuchâtel, Suisse) comprend six pieces d'art mobilier paleolithique, gravees et/ou sculptees, totalement ou partiellement inedites. Ce materiel archeologique provient de l'abri-sous-roche du Bout-du-Monde (Les Eyzies, Dordogne, France), fouille entre 1908 et 1910 par un denomme Lucas, instituteur-adjoint aux Eyzies, puis en 1945 par Denis Peyrony (1869-1954), qui en a etabli la stratigraphie et l'archeosequence. Si la presence de la phase moyenne du Magdalenien n'est que possible, en revanche, les stades superieur et final du Magdalenien, ainsi que l'Azilien, sont bien attestes. La collection Vogt comprend un bâton perce en bois de renne, un fragment de scapula de cheval, un fragment de mandibule et une portion diaphysaire de tibia de renne, une hemi-cote faconnee du type « spatule en os », et un galet calcaire. Une gravure sur plaquette de schiste, connue uniquement par un releve d'Henri Breuil et non localisee, complete l'inventaire. Les traces paleolithiques renvoient a des images de bison, renne, cheval, poisson et felin (?). Une attribution plus ancienne que le Magdalenien moyen pour cet art mobilier non localise dans la stratigraphie du gisement n?€?est pas envisagee. La question d'une chronologie plus basse que le Magdalenien superieur (Azilien) est laissee ouverte, dans l'attente de datation directe du materiel organique. Si Lucas a vendu, des la fin de ses fouilles, le materiel du Bout-du-Monde a Otto Hauser (1874-1932), ces pieces ont ensuite ete acquises par un «amateur suisse» qui semble bien etre Emil Vogt (1906-1974), figure notable de la prehistoire europeenne du xxe siecle, avant d'etre finalement revendues en 1991 par ses heritiers et acquises pour le Latenium. Cet ensemble est representatif de la dynamique des transferts d'antiquites prehistoriques entre la Suisse et la France, depuis le milieu du xixe siecle. Caracterisees par une exportation generalisee de materiaux palafittiques suisses, les strategies d'acquisition des collectionneurs sont contrebalancees, pour l'essentiel, en Suisse, par l'importation ciblee de vestiges archeologiques issus des sites de reference paleolithiques du Perigord, notamment des pieces d'art mobilier.","PeriodicalId":375388,"journal":{"name":"Bulletin de la Société préhistorique française","volume":"9 1","pages":"0"},"PeriodicalIF":0.0000,"publicationDate":"1900-01-01","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":"{\"title\":\"Du Bout-du-Monde (Les Eyzies, Dordogne, France) jusqu’à Neuchâtel (Suisse) : itinéraire et nature d’une collection d’art mobilier paléolithique (collection Vogt, Laténium)\",\"authors\":\"François-Xavier Chauvière, Marc-Antoine Kaeser\",\"doi\":\"10.3406/bspf.2020.15105\",\"DOIUrl\":null,\"url\":null,\"abstract\":\"EnglishThe Vogt collection of the Latenium (Neuchâtel, Switzerland) includes six pieces of engraved and/or sculpted Paleolithic portable art, either completely unpublished or only published in part. These finds come from Le Bout-du-Monde rock shelter (Les Eyzies, Dordogne, France), which was excavated between 1908 and 1910 by a certain Lucas, an assistant teacher at Les Eyzies and subsequently in 1945 by Denis Peyrony (1869-1954), who recorded the archaeo-sequence and the stratigraphy of the site. The stratigraphy was made up of four sedimentary layers, numbered from A to D from top to bottom (D- earth and scree : 0.40 m thick; C- river sands containing archaeological material: 0.30 m thick; B- Dry calcareous scree from the desquamation of the shelter walls, with fluvial sands: 0.50 cm thick; A- fluvial sands, with some calcareous scree with blunt edges. In this level, Peyrony reported the presence of a reindeer antler: 1.55 m thick) and the bedrock. While there is a possible presence of the Middle phase of the Magdalenian, the Upper and Final stages of the Magdalenian, as well as the Azilian, are, on the other hand, well documented and used by most authors to date the artefacts unearthed at Le Bout-du-Monde. The Vogt collection consists of a collection of different objects. A broken perforated baton made of reindeer antler (Rangifer tarandus) engraved with five bison heads in left profile and a stallion horse seen in right profile. A fragment of horse scapula (Equus caballus) engraved with a horse?€?s head in right profile used the spongy tissue of the bone to depict the animal's mane. A reindeer in left profile appears on a fragment of reindeer (Rangifer tarandus) right mandible. A one end of a hemi-rib from an animal larger than a reindeer is engraved and sculpted in the shape of a fish tail, perhaps from the salmon family. Moreover, there is a diaphysis portion of reindeer (Rangifer tarandus) tibia, engraved with a multitude of non-figurative drawings, made prior to the probable figuration of a feline. A limestone pebble depicts a deer with a disproportionate body (a female), next to which a fawn appears in a sitting position. Comparing these objects with the unpublished records made by Henri Breuil (1877-1961) and kept in the central library of the Museum national d'histoire naturelle of Paris (Breuil iconographic collection) shows that the engraved and sculpted artefacts have been well preserved. However, the surfaces of certain objects such as the broken perforated baton made from reindeer antler have deteriorated, as some marks seem to have disappeared over time. Finally, a schist plate engraved with the left profile of a bison is only known by a tracing by Henri Breuil. There is no information on the stratigraphic and spatial position of the archaeological material in the rock-shelter. However, it does not seem to date earlier than the Middle Magdalenian. Pending the direct dating of the organic supports, the question of a date earlier than the Upper Magdalenian (Azilian) is left open. The research conducted on the Vogt collection has traced the path of these objects from their discovery at the beginning of the 20th century to their acquisition for the Latenium. While Lucas sold Le Bout-du-Monde material immediately after their discovery to Otto Hauser (1874-1932), they were then acquired by a \\\"Swiss amateur\\\" who seems to be Emil Vogt (1906-1974), a prominent figure in 20th century European prehistory, before being finally sold by his heirs in 1991. The journey of the Palaeolithic portable art of the Vogt collection is replaced in the historical context of the constitution of the Latenium collections, and more broadly within the dynamics of the transfer of prehistoric antiquities between Switzerland and France, which started in the middle of the 19th century. This historical analysis highlights the scientific motives behind the collectors' acquisition, characterised by a widespread export of Swiss lake-dwelling materials, partly counterbalanced by the targeted import into Switzerland of archaeological remains from Palaeolithic reference sites of the Perigord, including pieces of portable art. francaisLa collection Vogt du Latenium (Neuchâtel, Suisse) comprend six pieces d'art mobilier paleolithique, gravees et/ou sculptees, totalement ou partiellement inedites. Ce materiel archeologique provient de l'abri-sous-roche du Bout-du-Monde (Les Eyzies, Dordogne, France), fouille entre 1908 et 1910 par un denomme Lucas, instituteur-adjoint aux Eyzies, puis en 1945 par Denis Peyrony (1869-1954), qui en a etabli la stratigraphie et l'archeosequence. Si la presence de la phase moyenne du Magdalenien n'est que possible, en revanche, les stades superieur et final du Magdalenien, ainsi que l'Azilien, sont bien attestes. La collection Vogt comprend un bâton perce en bois de renne, un fragment de scapula de cheval, un fragment de mandibule et une portion diaphysaire de tibia de renne, une hemi-cote faconnee du type « spatule en os », et un galet calcaire. Une gravure sur plaquette de schiste, connue uniquement par un releve d'Henri Breuil et non localisee, complete l'inventaire. Les traces paleolithiques renvoient a des images de bison, renne, cheval, poisson et felin (?). Une attribution plus ancienne que le Magdalenien moyen pour cet art mobilier non localise dans la stratigraphie du gisement n?€?est pas envisagee. La question d'une chronologie plus basse que le Magdalenien superieur (Azilien) est laissee ouverte, dans l'attente de datation directe du materiel organique. Si Lucas a vendu, des la fin de ses fouilles, le materiel du Bout-du-Monde a Otto Hauser (1874-1932), ces pieces ont ensuite ete acquises par un «amateur suisse» qui semble bien etre Emil Vogt (1906-1974), figure notable de la prehistoire europeenne du xxe siecle, avant d'etre finalement revendues en 1991 par ses heritiers et acquises pour le Latenium. Cet ensemble est representatif de la dynamique des transferts d'antiquites prehistoriques entre la Suisse et la France, depuis le milieu du xixe siecle. Caracterisees par une exportation generalisee de materiaux palafittiques suisses, les strategies d'acquisition des collectionneurs sont contrebalancees, pour l'essentiel, en Suisse, par l'importation ciblee de vestiges archeologiques issus des sites de reference paleolithiques du Perigord, notamment des pieces d'art mobilier.\",\"PeriodicalId\":375388,\"journal\":{\"name\":\"Bulletin de la Société préhistorique française\",\"volume\":\"9 1\",\"pages\":\"0\"},\"PeriodicalIF\":0.0000,\"publicationDate\":\"1900-01-01\",\"publicationTypes\":\"Journal Article\",\"fieldsOfStudy\":null,\"isOpenAccess\":false,\"openAccessPdf\":\"\",\"citationCount\":\"0\",\"resultStr\":null,\"platform\":\"Semanticscholar\",\"paperid\":null,\"PeriodicalName\":\"Bulletin de la Société préhistorique française\",\"FirstCategoryId\":\"1085\",\"ListUrlMain\":\"https://doi.org/10.3406/bspf.2020.15105\",\"RegionNum\":0,\"RegionCategory\":null,\"ArticlePicture\":[],\"TitleCN\":null,\"AbstractTextCN\":null,\"PMCID\":null,\"EPubDate\":\"\",\"PubModel\":\"\",\"JCR\":\"\",\"JCRName\":\"\",\"Score\":null,\"Total\":0}","platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Bulletin de la Société préhistorique française","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.3406/bspf.2020.15105","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"","JCRName":"","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
摘要
Latenium(瑞士neuch<e:1>特尔)的Vogt藏品包括六件旧石器时代的雕刻和/或雕刻的便携式艺术品,要么完全没有出版,要么只出版了一部分。这些发现来自Le bot -du- monde岩石洞穴(法国多尔多涅的Les Eyzies),在1908年至1910年间由一个叫Lucas的人发掘,他是Les Eyzies的助理老师,随后在1945年由Denis Peyrony(1869-1954)发掘,他记录了该遗址的考古序列和地层。地层由4个沉积层组成,从上到下依次编号为A ~ D (D-土、砂层:厚0.40 m;C-含考古材料的河砂:0.30 m厚;B-从遮蔽墙脱落的干燥钙质碎石,含河流砂:0.50厘米厚;A-河流砂,有一些边缘钝的钙质碎石。在这一层,Peyrony报告了一个驯鹿角(1.55米厚)和基岩的存在。虽然有可能存在抹大拉纪的中期,但另一方面,抹大拉纪的上部和最后阶段,以及阿兹里安时期,都有很好的记录,并被大多数作者用来确定Le Bout-du-Monde出土文物的年代。Vogt集合由不同对象的集合组成。一种用驯鹿角(Rangifer tarandus)制成的破损的穿孔棒,左边侧面刻有五个野牛头,右边侧面刻有一匹公马。刻有马的肩胛骨碎片(Equus caballus) ? ?右侧面的S头用骨头的海绵组织来描绘动物的鬃毛。在驯鹿(Rangifer tarandus)的右下颌骨碎片上出现了左侧面的驯鹿。一种比驯鹿大的动物的半肋骨的一端被雕刻成鱼尾的形状,可能来自鲑鱼家族。此外,还有驯鹿(Rangifer tarandus)胫骨的骨干部分,上面刻有许多非具象的图画,可能是在猫的形象之前制作的。一块石灰岩鹅卵石描绘了一只身体不成比例的鹿(雌性),旁边是一只坐着的小鹿。将这些物品与Henri Breuil(1877-1961)未发表的记录进行比较,这些记录保存在巴黎国家自然历史博物馆的中央图书馆(Breuil图像集)中,可以发现这些雕刻和雕刻的人工制品保存得很好。然而,某些物品的表面,如用驯鹿角制成的破损穿孔棒,已经变质,因为一些痕迹似乎随着时间的推移而消失了。最后,一块刻有野牛左侧轮廓的片岩板只有在亨利·布勒伊的追踪下才为人所知。没有关于岩石掩体中考古材料的地层和空间位置的信息。然而,它的年代似乎并不早于中抹大拉纪。在对有机支撑物进行直接测年之前,是否早于上马格达莱纳纪(阿兹连)的问题仍然悬而未决。对Vogt藏品进行的研究追踪了这些物品从20世纪初被发现到被Latenium收购的过程。虽然卢卡斯在发现《世界之轮》后立即将这些材料卖给了奥托·豪泽(Otto Hauser, 1874-1932),但随后又被一位“瑞士业余爱好者”获得,此人似乎是20世纪欧洲史前史上的杰出人物埃米尔·沃格特(Emil Vogt, 1906-1974),直到1991年才最终被他的继承人出售。Vogt收藏的旧石器时代便携艺术之旅在Latenium收藏构成的历史背景下被取代,更广泛地说,在19世纪中叶开始的瑞士和法国之间史前文物转移的动态中。这一历史分析强调了收藏者收购背后的科学动机,其特点是瑞士湖边住宅材料的广泛出口,部分抵消了Perigord旧石器时代参考遗址的考古遗迹的定向进口,包括一些便携式艺术品。francaisLa的Vogt du Latenium系列(瑞士neuch<e:1> tel)包括六件艺术品,包括旧石器时代的移动艺术品、坟墓、雕塑、整体艺术品和颗粒艺术品。Ce materiel archeologique proproce de l'abri-sous-roche du Bout-du-Monde (Les Eyzies, Dordogne, France), 1908年至1910年为命名为Lucas的研究所,1908年至1910年为命名为Lucas的研究所,1945年为命名为Denis Peyrony(1869-1954)的研究所,qui en a etabli la stratigraphy et l'archeosequence。我的意思是,我的意思是我的意思是我的意思是我的意思是我的意思是我的意思是我的意思是我的意思是我的意思是我的意思是我的意思是我的意思。
Du Bout-du-Monde (Les Eyzies, Dordogne, France) jusqu’à Neuchâtel (Suisse) : itinéraire et nature d’une collection d’art mobilier paléolithique (collection Vogt, Laténium)
EnglishThe Vogt collection of the Latenium (Neuchâtel, Switzerland) includes six pieces of engraved and/or sculpted Paleolithic portable art, either completely unpublished or only published in part. These finds come from Le Bout-du-Monde rock shelter (Les Eyzies, Dordogne, France), which was excavated between 1908 and 1910 by a certain Lucas, an assistant teacher at Les Eyzies and subsequently in 1945 by Denis Peyrony (1869-1954), who recorded the archaeo-sequence and the stratigraphy of the site. The stratigraphy was made up of four sedimentary layers, numbered from A to D from top to bottom (D- earth and scree : 0.40 m thick; C- river sands containing archaeological material: 0.30 m thick; B- Dry calcareous scree from the desquamation of the shelter walls, with fluvial sands: 0.50 cm thick; A- fluvial sands, with some calcareous scree with blunt edges. In this level, Peyrony reported the presence of a reindeer antler: 1.55 m thick) and the bedrock. While there is a possible presence of the Middle phase of the Magdalenian, the Upper and Final stages of the Magdalenian, as well as the Azilian, are, on the other hand, well documented and used by most authors to date the artefacts unearthed at Le Bout-du-Monde. The Vogt collection consists of a collection of different objects. A broken perforated baton made of reindeer antler (Rangifer tarandus) engraved with five bison heads in left profile and a stallion horse seen in right profile. A fragment of horse scapula (Equus caballus) engraved with a horse?€?s head in right profile used the spongy tissue of the bone to depict the animal's mane. A reindeer in left profile appears on a fragment of reindeer (Rangifer tarandus) right mandible. A one end of a hemi-rib from an animal larger than a reindeer is engraved and sculpted in the shape of a fish tail, perhaps from the salmon family. Moreover, there is a diaphysis portion of reindeer (Rangifer tarandus) tibia, engraved with a multitude of non-figurative drawings, made prior to the probable figuration of a feline. A limestone pebble depicts a deer with a disproportionate body (a female), next to which a fawn appears in a sitting position. Comparing these objects with the unpublished records made by Henri Breuil (1877-1961) and kept in the central library of the Museum national d'histoire naturelle of Paris (Breuil iconographic collection) shows that the engraved and sculpted artefacts have been well preserved. However, the surfaces of certain objects such as the broken perforated baton made from reindeer antler have deteriorated, as some marks seem to have disappeared over time. Finally, a schist plate engraved with the left profile of a bison is only known by a tracing by Henri Breuil. There is no information on the stratigraphic and spatial position of the archaeological material in the rock-shelter. However, it does not seem to date earlier than the Middle Magdalenian. Pending the direct dating of the organic supports, the question of a date earlier than the Upper Magdalenian (Azilian) is left open. The research conducted on the Vogt collection has traced the path of these objects from their discovery at the beginning of the 20th century to their acquisition for the Latenium. While Lucas sold Le Bout-du-Monde material immediately after their discovery to Otto Hauser (1874-1932), they were then acquired by a "Swiss amateur" who seems to be Emil Vogt (1906-1974), a prominent figure in 20th century European prehistory, before being finally sold by his heirs in 1991. The journey of the Palaeolithic portable art of the Vogt collection is replaced in the historical context of the constitution of the Latenium collections, and more broadly within the dynamics of the transfer of prehistoric antiquities between Switzerland and France, which started in the middle of the 19th century. This historical analysis highlights the scientific motives behind the collectors' acquisition, characterised by a widespread export of Swiss lake-dwelling materials, partly counterbalanced by the targeted import into Switzerland of archaeological remains from Palaeolithic reference sites of the Perigord, including pieces of portable art. francaisLa collection Vogt du Latenium (Neuchâtel, Suisse) comprend six pieces d'art mobilier paleolithique, gravees et/ou sculptees, totalement ou partiellement inedites. Ce materiel archeologique provient de l'abri-sous-roche du Bout-du-Monde (Les Eyzies, Dordogne, France), fouille entre 1908 et 1910 par un denomme Lucas, instituteur-adjoint aux Eyzies, puis en 1945 par Denis Peyrony (1869-1954), qui en a etabli la stratigraphie et l'archeosequence. Si la presence de la phase moyenne du Magdalenien n'est que possible, en revanche, les stades superieur et final du Magdalenien, ainsi que l'Azilien, sont bien attestes. La collection Vogt comprend un bâton perce en bois de renne, un fragment de scapula de cheval, un fragment de mandibule et une portion diaphysaire de tibia de renne, une hemi-cote faconnee du type « spatule en os », et un galet calcaire. Une gravure sur plaquette de schiste, connue uniquement par un releve d'Henri Breuil et non localisee, complete l'inventaire. Les traces paleolithiques renvoient a des images de bison, renne, cheval, poisson et felin (?). Une attribution plus ancienne que le Magdalenien moyen pour cet art mobilier non localise dans la stratigraphie du gisement n?€?est pas envisagee. La question d'une chronologie plus basse que le Magdalenien superieur (Azilien) est laissee ouverte, dans l'attente de datation directe du materiel organique. Si Lucas a vendu, des la fin de ses fouilles, le materiel du Bout-du-Monde a Otto Hauser (1874-1932), ces pieces ont ensuite ete acquises par un «amateur suisse» qui semble bien etre Emil Vogt (1906-1974), figure notable de la prehistoire europeenne du xxe siecle, avant d'etre finalement revendues en 1991 par ses heritiers et acquises pour le Latenium. Cet ensemble est representatif de la dynamique des transferts d'antiquites prehistoriques entre la Suisse et la France, depuis le milieu du xixe siecle. Caracterisees par une exportation generalisee de materiaux palafittiques suisses, les strategies d'acquisition des collectionneurs sont contrebalancees, pour l'essentiel, en Suisse, par l'importation ciblee de vestiges archeologiques issus des sites de reference paleolithiques du Perigord, notamment des pieces d'art mobilier.