{"title":"意大利和法国之间的Gravettien:麻糬庇护所岩石工业的新数据(Balzi Rossi,意大利)。","authors":"Fabio Santaniello, S. Grimaldi","doi":"10.3406/bspf.2019.15000","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"EnglishThe Italian Gravettian remains rarely investigated, with about twenty known archaeological sites and available data concerning its lithic industries that mainly refer to typological analyses developed during the second half of the last century. These highlight the presence of different facies with few attempts to discuss possibilities of parallel developments or colonization processes within a European scenario. The recent studies, which are few, have focused on technological and functional analyses of the Gravettian lithic industries as well as defining the mobility strategies of these human groups. In order to collect fresh technological data and to provide an explanatory framework within which to understand the dynamics of Gravettian adaptations in Italy, we analyzed the evidences from units C and D of the Riparo Mochi (Balzi Rossi, Italy). The site, located in the center of the Liguro-Provencal arc at the Italy-France border, provides one of the most complete Middle-upper Paleolithic sequences of the Mediterranean Europe and it represents a key to study the Gravettian appearance in the peninsula. This work has demanded a punctual revision of the original field documentation (diaries, pictures, drawings), allowing the correlation of collections from the 1938-1949 excavation - previously studied by other scholars - with unpublished materials coming from the 1959 excavation. During this excavation, L. Cardini used a more standardized methodology based on 10 cm spits, which led to the excavation of the Upper Paleolithic sequence during a single campaign. The Istituto Italiano di Paleontologia Umana (Anagni, Italy) houses the lithic collection including all the artifacts from both the excavation and the sieving, still preserved in their original boxes. As there seems to have been no previous selection of the material and/or there are no apparent conservation problems indicates that this collection is the most reliable for this study. The use of a techno-economic perspective has defined technological adaptations occurred during the different Gravettian frequentations; rock-supplying crops draw from a large procurement area, roughly spanning from the Rhone valley to the Italian Apennines. Furthermore, the use of statistical analysis based on both qualitative and quantitative determinations reveals the detailed interpretation of the entire Gravettian sequence spit by spit. Finally, the materials from the base and the top of the old excavations campaigns (1938-1949) have been directly studied and compared. They highlight new perspectives relating to the Gravettian of Riparo Mochi. Firstly, Noailles burins found at the base of the Gravettian sequence suggest that the Noaillian is the first Gravettian frequentation of the site. Consequently, the presence of the ancient Gravettian previously suggested by other scholars has been re-considered. Differences between raw materials and techno-typological patterns have been interpreted as different occupational phases. The latter, also highlighted by faunal and environmental studies, can be associated to changes of the site's function within the hunter-gathers mobility. Secondly, several technical and behavioral changes occurred between the middle and final Gravettian. These relate mainly to the appearance of new lithic production at the end of the Gravettian seem the sign of variations of the social organization, which can be roughly interpreted as result of the regionalization phenomenon attested during this period in the Italian peninsula. In conclusion, a survey of available data from the north Mediterranean rim (i.e. Pyrenean area, southern France and western Italy) has been carried out, in order to evaluate the implication of our results about the Italian Gravettian within the wider perspective of a European context. We have thus been able to evaluate how the Noaillian groups spread towards Italy as well as to suggest new insights into the evolution of the Italian Gravettian. francaisA ce jour, un cadre explicatif pour comprendre les dynamiques de diffusion et de developpement du Gravettien en Italie tyrrhenienne fait defaut. Les donnees disponibles se fondent sur des analyses typologiques qui soulignent la presence de differents facies sans analyser les possibilites de developpements paralleles ou de processus de colonisation par rapport au scenario europeen. Sur cette base, nous avons analyse les donnees gravettiennes de Riparo Mochi (Balzi Rossi, Italie), l'une des plus importantes sequences du Paleolithique superieur de la Mediterranee. Sa position au centre de l'arc liguro-provencal est une cle pour etudier l'apparition du Gravettien dans la peninsule. L'utilisation d'une approche techno-economique a permis de definir les territoires d'approvisionnement des matieres premieres et de reconnaitre les adaptations technologiques au fil du temps. Ces donnees mettent en evidence un nouveau scenario pour le Gravettien de Riparo Mochi : a) les burins de Noailles trouves a la base de la sequence gravettienne suggerent que le Noaillien correspond a la premiere frequentation gravettienne du site ; b) plusieurs changements techniques et comportementaux se sont produits entre le Gravettien moyen et Gravettien final. En conclusion, des comparaisons avec les donnees techno-economiques et paleo-environnementales du nord de la Mediterranee permettent de mieux comprendre comment les groupes noailliens se sont etendus vers le sud de l'Italie et de suggerer des nouvelles perspectives pour comprendre le developpement du Gravettien.","PeriodicalId":375388,"journal":{"name":"Bulletin de la Société préhistorique française","volume":"50 1","pages":"0"},"PeriodicalIF":0.0000,"publicationDate":"1900-01-01","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"3","resultStr":"{\"title\":\"Le Gravettien entre l’Italie et la France : nouvelles données sur l’industrie lithique de l’Abri Mochi (Balzi Rossi, Italie).\",\"authors\":\"Fabio Santaniello, S. Grimaldi\",\"doi\":\"10.3406/bspf.2019.15000\",\"DOIUrl\":null,\"url\":null,\"abstract\":\"EnglishThe Italian Gravettian remains rarely investigated, with about twenty known archaeological sites and available data concerning its lithic industries that mainly refer to typological analyses developed during the second half of the last century. These highlight the presence of different facies with few attempts to discuss possibilities of parallel developments or colonization processes within a European scenario. The recent studies, which are few, have focused on technological and functional analyses of the Gravettian lithic industries as well as defining the mobility strategies of these human groups. In order to collect fresh technological data and to provide an explanatory framework within which to understand the dynamics of Gravettian adaptations in Italy, we analyzed the evidences from units C and D of the Riparo Mochi (Balzi Rossi, Italy). The site, located in the center of the Liguro-Provencal arc at the Italy-France border, provides one of the most complete Middle-upper Paleolithic sequences of the Mediterranean Europe and it represents a key to study the Gravettian appearance in the peninsula. This work has demanded a punctual revision of the original field documentation (diaries, pictures, drawings), allowing the correlation of collections from the 1938-1949 excavation - previously studied by other scholars - with unpublished materials coming from the 1959 excavation. During this excavation, L. Cardini used a more standardized methodology based on 10 cm spits, which led to the excavation of the Upper Paleolithic sequence during a single campaign. The Istituto Italiano di Paleontologia Umana (Anagni, Italy) houses the lithic collection including all the artifacts from both the excavation and the sieving, still preserved in their original boxes. As there seems to have been no previous selection of the material and/or there are no apparent conservation problems indicates that this collection is the most reliable for this study. The use of a techno-economic perspective has defined technological adaptations occurred during the different Gravettian frequentations; rock-supplying crops draw from a large procurement area, roughly spanning from the Rhone valley to the Italian Apennines. Furthermore, the use of statistical analysis based on both qualitative and quantitative determinations reveals the detailed interpretation of the entire Gravettian sequence spit by spit. Finally, the materials from the base and the top of the old excavations campaigns (1938-1949) have been directly studied and compared. They highlight new perspectives relating to the Gravettian of Riparo Mochi. Firstly, Noailles burins found at the base of the Gravettian sequence suggest that the Noaillian is the first Gravettian frequentation of the site. Consequently, the presence of the ancient Gravettian previously suggested by other scholars has been re-considered. Differences between raw materials and techno-typological patterns have been interpreted as different occupational phases. The latter, also highlighted by faunal and environmental studies, can be associated to changes of the site's function within the hunter-gathers mobility. Secondly, several technical and behavioral changes occurred between the middle and final Gravettian. These relate mainly to the appearance of new lithic production at the end of the Gravettian seem the sign of variations of the social organization, which can be roughly interpreted as result of the regionalization phenomenon attested during this period in the Italian peninsula. In conclusion, a survey of available data from the north Mediterranean rim (i.e. Pyrenean area, southern France and western Italy) has been carried out, in order to evaluate the implication of our results about the Italian Gravettian within the wider perspective of a European context. We have thus been able to evaluate how the Noaillian groups spread towards Italy as well as to suggest new insights into the evolution of the Italian Gravettian. francaisA ce jour, un cadre explicatif pour comprendre les dynamiques de diffusion et de developpement du Gravettien en Italie tyrrhenienne fait defaut. Les donnees disponibles se fondent sur des analyses typologiques qui soulignent la presence de differents facies sans analyser les possibilites de developpements paralleles ou de processus de colonisation par rapport au scenario europeen. Sur cette base, nous avons analyse les donnees gravettiennes de Riparo Mochi (Balzi Rossi, Italie), l'une des plus importantes sequences du Paleolithique superieur de la Mediterranee. Sa position au centre de l'arc liguro-provencal est une cle pour etudier l'apparition du Gravettien dans la peninsule. L'utilisation d'une approche techno-economique a permis de definir les territoires d'approvisionnement des matieres premieres et de reconnaitre les adaptations technologiques au fil du temps. Ces donnees mettent en evidence un nouveau scenario pour le Gravettien de Riparo Mochi : a) les burins de Noailles trouves a la base de la sequence gravettienne suggerent que le Noaillien correspond a la premiere frequentation gravettienne du site ; b) plusieurs changements techniques et comportementaux se sont produits entre le Gravettien moyen et Gravettien final. En conclusion, des comparaisons avec les donnees techno-economiques et paleo-environnementales du nord de la Mediterranee permettent de mieux comprendre comment les groupes noailliens se sont etendus vers le sud de l'Italie et de suggerer des nouvelles perspectives pour comprendre le developpement du Gravettien.\",\"PeriodicalId\":375388,\"journal\":{\"name\":\"Bulletin de la Société préhistorique française\",\"volume\":\"50 1\",\"pages\":\"0\"},\"PeriodicalIF\":0.0000,\"publicationDate\":\"1900-01-01\",\"publicationTypes\":\"Journal Article\",\"fieldsOfStudy\":null,\"isOpenAccess\":false,\"openAccessPdf\":\"\",\"citationCount\":\"3\",\"resultStr\":null,\"platform\":\"Semanticscholar\",\"paperid\":null,\"PeriodicalName\":\"Bulletin de la Société préhistorique française\",\"FirstCategoryId\":\"1085\",\"ListUrlMain\":\"https://doi.org/10.3406/bspf.2019.15000\",\"RegionNum\":0,\"RegionCategory\":null,\"ArticlePicture\":[],\"TitleCN\":null,\"AbstractTextCN\":null,\"PMCID\":null,\"EPubDate\":\"\",\"PubModel\":\"\",\"JCR\":\"\",\"JCRName\":\"\",\"Score\":null,\"Total\":0}","platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Bulletin de la Société préhistorique française","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.3406/bspf.2019.15000","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"","JCRName":"","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 3
摘要
意大利格拉维特人很少被调查,只有大约20个已知的考古遗址和关于其石器工业的现有数据,主要参考上世纪下半叶发展起来的类型学分析。这些突出了不同相的存在,很少试图讨论在欧洲情景中平行发展或殖民化过程的可能性。最近的研究很少,主要集中在格拉维特岩石业的技术和功能分析,以及定义这些人类群体的流动性策略。为了收集新的技术数据,并提供一个解释框架,以了解意大利格拉韦特适应的动态,我们分析了来自里帕罗莫奇(意大利巴尔齐罗西)C和D单元的证据。该遗址位于意大利-法国边境的利古罗-普罗旺斯弧线的中心,提供了地中海欧洲最完整的中晚期旧石器时代序列之一,它代表了研究半岛格拉维特人外貌的关键。这项工作要求对原始的现场文件(日记、图片、图纸)进行及时的修订,以便将1938-1949年发掘的藏品(之前由其他学者研究过)与1959年发掘的未发表的材料相关联。在这次挖掘中,L. Cardini使用了一种更标准化的方法,基于10厘米的裂缝,这导致了旧石器时代晚期序列的单一挖掘活动。意大利乌马纳古生物学研究所(意大利阿纳格尼)收藏了石器收藏品,包括挖掘和筛选的所有文物,仍然保存在原来的盒子里。由于以前似乎没有选择过材料和/或没有明显的保护问题,表明该收集是本研究最可靠的。技术经济视角的使用定义了在不同的重力频率期间发生的技术适应;供应岩石的作物来自一个很大的采矿区,大致从罗纳河谷延伸到意大利亚平宁山脉。此外,利用基于定性和定量测定的统计分析,揭示了整个重力层序的详细解释。最后,对1938-1949年旧发掘运动的底部和顶部的材料进行了直接研究和比较。他们强调了与里帕罗莫奇的重力有关的新观点。首先,在格拉韦梯序列底部发现的诺埃利亚燃烧表明,诺埃利亚是该遗址的第一个格拉韦梯频繁出现的地方。因此,以前其他学者提出的古格拉维特人的存在被重新考虑。原材料和技术类型模式之间的差异被解释为不同的职业阶段。动物群和环境研究也强调,后者可能与狩猎-采集活动中场地功能的变化有关。其次,在Gravettian中期和最终阶段之间发生了一些技术和行为上的变化。这主要与格拉韦提末期新石器生产的出现有关,这似乎是社会组织变化的标志,这可以大致解释为这一时期意大利半岛出现的区域化现象的结果。总之,对地中海北部边缘地区(即比利牛斯山脉地区、法国南部和意大利西部)的现有数据进行了调查,以便在更广泛的欧洲背景下评估我们关于意大利格拉维特人的研究结果的含义。因此,我们能够评估诺埃利亚人如何向意大利传播,并对意大利格拉维特人的进化提出新的见解。在此基础上,本文阐述了意大利经济危机扩散和发展的动态过程。不确定因素、不确定因素、不确定因素、不确定因素、不确定因素、不确定因素、不确定因素、不确定因素、不确定因素、不确定因素、不确定因素、不确定因素、不确定因素、不确定因素、不确定因素、不确定因素、不确定因素。Sur cette base, nous avons分析les donnees gravettiennes de Riparo Mochi (Balzi Rossi, italy), l'une des plus重要序列du Paleolithique superieur de la Mediterranee。在省中心的一个位置上,有一个位置是在省中心的一个位置上,有一个位置是在省中心。“利用技术经济方法和许可证”定义了“领土”,“批准”了“首次开采”和“勘探”,“适应”了“油田”技术。
Le Gravettien entre l’Italie et la France : nouvelles données sur l’industrie lithique de l’Abri Mochi (Balzi Rossi, Italie).
EnglishThe Italian Gravettian remains rarely investigated, with about twenty known archaeological sites and available data concerning its lithic industries that mainly refer to typological analyses developed during the second half of the last century. These highlight the presence of different facies with few attempts to discuss possibilities of parallel developments or colonization processes within a European scenario. The recent studies, which are few, have focused on technological and functional analyses of the Gravettian lithic industries as well as defining the mobility strategies of these human groups. In order to collect fresh technological data and to provide an explanatory framework within which to understand the dynamics of Gravettian adaptations in Italy, we analyzed the evidences from units C and D of the Riparo Mochi (Balzi Rossi, Italy). The site, located in the center of the Liguro-Provencal arc at the Italy-France border, provides one of the most complete Middle-upper Paleolithic sequences of the Mediterranean Europe and it represents a key to study the Gravettian appearance in the peninsula. This work has demanded a punctual revision of the original field documentation (diaries, pictures, drawings), allowing the correlation of collections from the 1938-1949 excavation - previously studied by other scholars - with unpublished materials coming from the 1959 excavation. During this excavation, L. Cardini used a more standardized methodology based on 10 cm spits, which led to the excavation of the Upper Paleolithic sequence during a single campaign. The Istituto Italiano di Paleontologia Umana (Anagni, Italy) houses the lithic collection including all the artifacts from both the excavation and the sieving, still preserved in their original boxes. As there seems to have been no previous selection of the material and/or there are no apparent conservation problems indicates that this collection is the most reliable for this study. The use of a techno-economic perspective has defined technological adaptations occurred during the different Gravettian frequentations; rock-supplying crops draw from a large procurement area, roughly spanning from the Rhone valley to the Italian Apennines. Furthermore, the use of statistical analysis based on both qualitative and quantitative determinations reveals the detailed interpretation of the entire Gravettian sequence spit by spit. Finally, the materials from the base and the top of the old excavations campaigns (1938-1949) have been directly studied and compared. They highlight new perspectives relating to the Gravettian of Riparo Mochi. Firstly, Noailles burins found at the base of the Gravettian sequence suggest that the Noaillian is the first Gravettian frequentation of the site. Consequently, the presence of the ancient Gravettian previously suggested by other scholars has been re-considered. Differences between raw materials and techno-typological patterns have been interpreted as different occupational phases. The latter, also highlighted by faunal and environmental studies, can be associated to changes of the site's function within the hunter-gathers mobility. Secondly, several technical and behavioral changes occurred between the middle and final Gravettian. These relate mainly to the appearance of new lithic production at the end of the Gravettian seem the sign of variations of the social organization, which can be roughly interpreted as result of the regionalization phenomenon attested during this period in the Italian peninsula. In conclusion, a survey of available data from the north Mediterranean rim (i.e. Pyrenean area, southern France and western Italy) has been carried out, in order to evaluate the implication of our results about the Italian Gravettian within the wider perspective of a European context. We have thus been able to evaluate how the Noaillian groups spread towards Italy as well as to suggest new insights into the evolution of the Italian Gravettian. francaisA ce jour, un cadre explicatif pour comprendre les dynamiques de diffusion et de developpement du Gravettien en Italie tyrrhenienne fait defaut. Les donnees disponibles se fondent sur des analyses typologiques qui soulignent la presence de differents facies sans analyser les possibilites de developpements paralleles ou de processus de colonisation par rapport au scenario europeen. Sur cette base, nous avons analyse les donnees gravettiennes de Riparo Mochi (Balzi Rossi, Italie), l'une des plus importantes sequences du Paleolithique superieur de la Mediterranee. Sa position au centre de l'arc liguro-provencal est une cle pour etudier l'apparition du Gravettien dans la peninsule. L'utilisation d'une approche techno-economique a permis de definir les territoires d'approvisionnement des matieres premieres et de reconnaitre les adaptations technologiques au fil du temps. Ces donnees mettent en evidence un nouveau scenario pour le Gravettien de Riparo Mochi : a) les burins de Noailles trouves a la base de la sequence gravettienne suggerent que le Noaillien correspond a la premiere frequentation gravettienne du site ; b) plusieurs changements techniques et comportementaux se sont produits entre le Gravettien moyen et Gravettien final. En conclusion, des comparaisons avec les donnees techno-economiques et paleo-environnementales du nord de la Mediterranee permettent de mieux comprendre comment les groupes noailliens se sont etendus vers le sud de l'Italie et de suggerer des nouvelles perspectives pour comprendre le developpement du Gravettien.