{"title":"PENGARUH HUKUM ADAT TERHADAP KETENTUAN WARIS PASAL 183, 185, DAN 209 KOMPILASI HUKUM ISLAM PERSPEKTIF TEORI RECEPTIO A CONTRARIO","authors":"Devi Kasumawati","doi":"10.21093/qj.v5i2.3955","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"The presence of Kompilasi Hukum Islam (KHI) which in the beginning was anticipated as a source of Islamic civil law after releasing in Indonesia having such a pro and contra. That’s because there are some provisions that don’t fit with the classical fiqh books. Though it is said that KHI in the formulation is based on a study of the books of fiqh, especially Shafi’i. According to several parties, like Habiburrahman in his research, there are elements of customary law comes in, especially in the chapters concerning about inheritance. \nBased on the statement that KHI was influenced by customary law, this research aims (1) to study KHI subsection 183 about the division of inheritance peacefully, subsection 185 about representation of heirs, and subsection 209 about obligatory bequests for adopted children; (2) how is the influence of customary law against those three articles of KHI on perspective of Receptio a Contrario Theory. \nThis research was classified into normative research. Used data is secondary data. The process of gathering data using documentation methode according to the conceptual approach. Data was analyzed by descriptive qualitative methode. As for verifying the validity of the data using triangulation techniques. \nThe result of research showing that subsection of 183 about division of inheritance peacefully has something in common with the tradition of Indonesian society that share their inheritance deliberately. While subsection 185 about representation of heirs was reflected family system which adopted by the majority of Indonesian society, with the name bilateral system. It can be seen from the possibly of replacement the heirs for orphaned grandchildren from deceased mother, which is not accommodated in the classical Islamic inheritance system. Subsection 209 about obligatory bequests for adopted children is an alternative solution for adopted children who didn’t get a share when his/her adoptive parents died. This policy is enforced due to the practice of adoption is something usual in Indonesia. According to the Receptio a Contrario theory, the customary law can be accepted if only it’s not contradictory with Islamic law. Based on the study which researchers did, although all three subsection are influenced by customary law, but the values that contained in there already accordance with the Islamic law.","PeriodicalId":150635,"journal":{"name":"QONUN: Jurnal Hukum Islam dan Perundang-undangan","volume":null,"pages":null},"PeriodicalIF":0.0000,"publicationDate":"2021-12-29","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"QONUN: Jurnal Hukum Islam dan Perundang-undangan","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.21093/qj.v5i2.3955","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"","JCRName":"","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
摘要
Kompilasi Hukum Islam (KHI)的存在,在印度尼西亚发布后,最初被预期为伊斯兰民法的来源,具有这样的支持和反对。那是因为有一些条款不符合经典的伊斯兰教规。虽然据说配方中的KHI是基于对菲格莱书籍的研究,尤其是沙菲莱。根据一些人的观点,比如Habiburrahman在他的研究中,有一些习惯法的元素,特别是在关于继承的章节中。基于KHI受习惯法影响的说法,本研究旨在(1)研究KHI第183条关于遗产的和平分割,第185条关于继承人的代表,第209条关于收养子女的义务遗赠;(2)从接受与对立理论的角度看,习惯法对《国民法》这三篇文章的影响是怎样的?这一研究被归类为规范研究。使用的数据是辅助数据。根据概念方法使用文档方法收集数据的过程。采用描述性定性方法对资料进行分析。至于使用三角测量技术验证数据的有效性。研究结果表明,第183条关于和平分配遗产的分段与印度尼西亚社会有意分享遗产的传统有一些共同之处。关于继承人代表权的第185款反映了印度尼西亚社会大多数人采用的家庭制度,称为双边制度。这可以从可能取代已故母亲的孤儿孙辈的继承人看出,这在古典伊斯兰继承制度中是不允许的。第209条关于收养子女的义务遗赠是收养子女在养父母去世后没有获得份额的另一种解决办法。这项政策之所以得以实施,是因为在印度尼西亚,收养是一件很平常的事情。根据“接受与对立”理论,只要习惯法与伊斯兰教法不矛盾,习惯法就可以被接受。根据研究人员所做的研究,虽然这三个部分都受到习惯法的影响,但其中所包含的价值观已经符合伊斯兰教法。
PENGARUH HUKUM ADAT TERHADAP KETENTUAN WARIS PASAL 183, 185, DAN 209 KOMPILASI HUKUM ISLAM PERSPEKTIF TEORI RECEPTIO A CONTRARIO
The presence of Kompilasi Hukum Islam (KHI) which in the beginning was anticipated as a source of Islamic civil law after releasing in Indonesia having such a pro and contra. That’s because there are some provisions that don’t fit with the classical fiqh books. Though it is said that KHI in the formulation is based on a study of the books of fiqh, especially Shafi’i. According to several parties, like Habiburrahman in his research, there are elements of customary law comes in, especially in the chapters concerning about inheritance.
Based on the statement that KHI was influenced by customary law, this research aims (1) to study KHI subsection 183 about the division of inheritance peacefully, subsection 185 about representation of heirs, and subsection 209 about obligatory bequests for adopted children; (2) how is the influence of customary law against those three articles of KHI on perspective of Receptio a Contrario Theory.
This research was classified into normative research. Used data is secondary data. The process of gathering data using documentation methode according to the conceptual approach. Data was analyzed by descriptive qualitative methode. As for verifying the validity of the data using triangulation techniques.
The result of research showing that subsection of 183 about division of inheritance peacefully has something in common with the tradition of Indonesian society that share their inheritance deliberately. While subsection 185 about representation of heirs was reflected family system which adopted by the majority of Indonesian society, with the name bilateral system. It can be seen from the possibly of replacement the heirs for orphaned grandchildren from deceased mother, which is not accommodated in the classical Islamic inheritance system. Subsection 209 about obligatory bequests for adopted children is an alternative solution for adopted children who didn’t get a share when his/her adoptive parents died. This policy is enforced due to the practice of adoption is something usual in Indonesia. According to the Receptio a Contrario theory, the customary law can be accepted if only it’s not contradictory with Islamic law. Based on the study which researchers did, although all three subsection are influenced by customary law, but the values that contained in there already accordance with the Islamic law.