On Mixing Eventual and Strong Consistency: Bayou Revisited

In this paper we study the properties of eventually consistent distributed systems that feature arbitrarily complex semantics and mix eventual and strong consistency. These systems execute requests in a highly-available, weakly-consistent fashion, but also enable stronger guarantees through additional inter-replica synchronization mechanisms that require the ability to solve distributed consensus. We use the seminal Bayou system as a case study, and then generalize our findings to a whole class of systems. We show dubious and unintuitive behaviour exhibited by those systems and provide a theoretical framework for reasoning about their correctness. We also state an impossibility result that formally proves the inherent limitation of such systems, namely temporary operation reordering, which admits interim disagreement between replicas on the relative order in which the client requests were executed.