Automated Test Generation and Mutation Testing for Alloy

We present two novel approaches for automated testing of models written in Alloy – a well-known declarative, first-order language that is supported by a fully automatic SAT-based analysis engine. The first approach introduces automated test generation for Alloy and is embodied by three techniques that create test suites in the traditional spirit of black-box, white-box, and mutation-based testing. The second approach introduces mutation testing for Alloy and defines how to create mutants of Alloy models, compute mutation testing results, and check for equivalent mutants using SAT. The two approaches build on the theoretical foundation defined previously by our AUnit framework, which introduced the idea of unit testing for Alloy in the spirit of unit testing for imperative languages. While test generation and mutation testing are heavily studied problems with many solutions in the context of imperative languages, the key novelty of our work is to introduce and address these problems for the declarative programming paradigm, specifically for the Alloy language. Experimental results using several Alloy subjects, including those with real faults, demonstrate the efficacy of our framework.