{"title":"从实证研究结果看我国对医务人员能力素质的需求","authors":"M. Haberla","doi":"10.29119/1641-3466.2022.166.21","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"Purpose: The article's primary purpose is to present issues related to the demand for competence and qualification of medical personnel. The specific goal is to identify gaps in healthcare professionals' qualifications and competencies and prepare recommendations/ positions for system changes. Design/methodology/approach: The author based his considerations on Polish and foreign literature on the subject, studying scientific articles and electronic sources. The author used the following professional databases to collect scientific literature: the Library of Science and Google Scholar. The author then performed qualitative (qualitative research – individual in-depth interview) and quantitative (statistical – online survey) analysis based on extracting as much knowledge as possible from the collected quantitative data. Qualitative research is a qualitative technique for obtaining data in which an interview is conducted based on a previously prepared interview scenario. The IDI technique makes it possible to get – in direct interaction with the respondent - data of a qualitative nature, which, although it does not allow (due to lack of representativeness) to generalize it to the entire population under study, provides in-depth information within the framework of a specific research question. On the other hand, the statistical analysis made it possible to determine the extent to which a given phenomenon occurs, and then indicate the main trends observed in a specific area and environment. As part of the research, more than 1,000 CAWI interviews were conducted with owners of medical facilities (POZ), and medical and non-medical personnel. Findings: The level of competence of healthcare workers concerns all citizens. The Polish education system is mainly oriented towards professional skills training. Social competencies are acquired by medical graduates only when they begin their professional work. On the other hand, employers require documents confirming professional qualifications when looking for employees. Increasing the competencies and qualifications of the staff of medical institutions will contribute to the continuous development of POZ. It will be the foundation of the entire, efficiently operating healthcare system. Therefore, special attention should be paid to management, finance, personnel development, and the comprehensiveness of care. Social implications: The market for medical services is developing rapidly in Poland. According to a report by research firm PMR titled: „Private healthcare market in Poland 2022. Market analysis and development forecasts for 2022-2027\" (EMIS, 2022), price increases are one of the main challenges for the private healthcare sector. According to PMR, for the whole of 2022, prices for outpatient and other health-related services will increase by about 14 percent compared to 2021, which will, on the one hand, affect the nominal increase in the value of this market, but will also reduce its fundamental dynamics. On the other hand, the provision of primary healthcare services is carried out by various healthcare providers (entrepreneurs: individuals or legal entities, NGOs, SPZOZs) and professional practices (individuals and groups; doctors, nurses, or midwives). Among healthcare providers, entrepreneurs are the most numerous (83%). Providers contract with the National Health Service for a physician, nurse, and midwife care. According to the Human Capital Balance survey (PARP, 2022), medium and large enterprises continue to invest in developing their employees' competencies, despite the organizational and financial difficulties caused by the COVID-19 pandemic. Work-based learning has remained a widely used means of developing competencies, used particularly frequently in the education, healthcare and social assistance, and industry and mining sectors. Among the most critical problems in the health, the sector is the shortage of personnel, resulting from generational changes, an ineffective system of pre- and postgraduate education, changes in work styles, migration, obstruction of access to certain specialties by interest groups, and an insufficiently effective system of supporting deficit specialties (residencies). A shortage of doctors and nurses has been evident in Poland for years. According to Eurostat data, Poland has the lowest number of practicing physicians per 1,000 residents in the EU (2.4), and the number of nurses (5.1 per 1,000 residents) is also among the lowest in the EU (Figure 10). However, official national estimates are higher - between 3.4 and 4.4 doctors per 1,000 residents (Kowalska-Bobko et al., 2021). Originality/value: The author addressed the article to health policy and legislation makers on the desired qualifications and competencies in the medical services labor market. Indirect recipients are market entrepreneurs involved in identifying and forecasting qualifications and professional needs in the labor market (Primary Healthcare (PHC) medical facilities - PHC owners, medical and non-medical staff). Parallel audiences are stakeholders involved in the formation of the qualification system of the healthcare sector, including institutions responsible for defining education standards and awarding titles, administrative units running education and qualification institutions, and formal education entities (universities, schools, training institutions). The article’s value is to identify gaps in the competencies and qualifications of medical personnel to shape health policy so that these gaps are minimized. Keywords: competencies, qualifications, healthcare system, medical personnel. Category of the paper: Research paper.","PeriodicalId":184741,"journal":{"name":"Scientific Papers of Silesian University of Technology. Organization and Management Series","volume":"10 1","pages":"0"},"PeriodicalIF":0.0000,"publicationDate":"1900-01-01","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":"{\"title\":\"The demand for competence and qualification of medical personnel in the light of the results of empirical studies\",\"authors\":\"M. Haberla\",\"doi\":\"10.29119/1641-3466.2022.166.21\",\"DOIUrl\":null,\"url\":null,\"abstract\":\"Purpose: The article's primary purpose is to present issues related to the demand for competence and qualification of medical personnel. The specific goal is to identify gaps in healthcare professionals' qualifications and competencies and prepare recommendations/ positions for system changes. Design/methodology/approach: The author based his considerations on Polish and foreign literature on the subject, studying scientific articles and electronic sources. The author used the following professional databases to collect scientific literature: the Library of Science and Google Scholar. The author then performed qualitative (qualitative research – individual in-depth interview) and quantitative (statistical – online survey) analysis based on extracting as much knowledge as possible from the collected quantitative data. Qualitative research is a qualitative technique for obtaining data in which an interview is conducted based on a previously prepared interview scenario. The IDI technique makes it possible to get – in direct interaction with the respondent - data of a qualitative nature, which, although it does not allow (due to lack of representativeness) to generalize it to the entire population under study, provides in-depth information within the framework of a specific research question. On the other hand, the statistical analysis made it possible to determine the extent to which a given phenomenon occurs, and then indicate the main trends observed in a specific area and environment. As part of the research, more than 1,000 CAWI interviews were conducted with owners of medical facilities (POZ), and medical and non-medical personnel. Findings: The level of competence of healthcare workers concerns all citizens. The Polish education system is mainly oriented towards professional skills training. Social competencies are acquired by medical graduates only when they begin their professional work. On the other hand, employers require documents confirming professional qualifications when looking for employees. Increasing the competencies and qualifications of the staff of medical institutions will contribute to the continuous development of POZ. It will be the foundation of the entire, efficiently operating healthcare system. Therefore, special attention should be paid to management, finance, personnel development, and the comprehensiveness of care. Social implications: The market for medical services is developing rapidly in Poland. According to a report by research firm PMR titled: „Private healthcare market in Poland 2022. Market analysis and development forecasts for 2022-2027\\\" (EMIS, 2022), price increases are one of the main challenges for the private healthcare sector. According to PMR, for the whole of 2022, prices for outpatient and other health-related services will increase by about 14 percent compared to 2021, which will, on the one hand, affect the nominal increase in the value of this market, but will also reduce its fundamental dynamics. On the other hand, the provision of primary healthcare services is carried out by various healthcare providers (entrepreneurs: individuals or legal entities, NGOs, SPZOZs) and professional practices (individuals and groups; doctors, nurses, or midwives). Among healthcare providers, entrepreneurs are the most numerous (83%). Providers contract with the National Health Service for a physician, nurse, and midwife care. According to the Human Capital Balance survey (PARP, 2022), medium and large enterprises continue to invest in developing their employees' competencies, despite the organizational and financial difficulties caused by the COVID-19 pandemic. Work-based learning has remained a widely used means of developing competencies, used particularly frequently in the education, healthcare and social assistance, and industry and mining sectors. Among the most critical problems in the health, the sector is the shortage of personnel, resulting from generational changes, an ineffective system of pre- and postgraduate education, changes in work styles, migration, obstruction of access to certain specialties by interest groups, and an insufficiently effective system of supporting deficit specialties (residencies). A shortage of doctors and nurses has been evident in Poland for years. According to Eurostat data, Poland has the lowest number of practicing physicians per 1,000 residents in the EU (2.4), and the number of nurses (5.1 per 1,000 residents) is also among the lowest in the EU (Figure 10). However, official national estimates are higher - between 3.4 and 4.4 doctors per 1,000 residents (Kowalska-Bobko et al., 2021). Originality/value: The author addressed the article to health policy and legislation makers on the desired qualifications and competencies in the medical services labor market. Indirect recipients are market entrepreneurs involved in identifying and forecasting qualifications and professional needs in the labor market (Primary Healthcare (PHC) medical facilities - PHC owners, medical and non-medical staff). Parallel audiences are stakeholders involved in the formation of the qualification system of the healthcare sector, including institutions responsible for defining education standards and awarding titles, administrative units running education and qualification institutions, and formal education entities (universities, schools, training institutions). The article’s value is to identify gaps in the competencies and qualifications of medical personnel to shape health policy so that these gaps are minimized. Keywords: competencies, qualifications, healthcare system, medical personnel. Category of the paper: Research paper.\",\"PeriodicalId\":184741,\"journal\":{\"name\":\"Scientific Papers of Silesian University of Technology. Organization and Management Series\",\"volume\":\"10 1\",\"pages\":\"0\"},\"PeriodicalIF\":0.0000,\"publicationDate\":\"1900-01-01\",\"publicationTypes\":\"Journal Article\",\"fieldsOfStudy\":null,\"isOpenAccess\":false,\"openAccessPdf\":\"\",\"citationCount\":\"0\",\"resultStr\":null,\"platform\":\"Semanticscholar\",\"paperid\":null,\"PeriodicalName\":\"Scientific Papers of Silesian University of Technology. Organization and Management Series\",\"FirstCategoryId\":\"1085\",\"ListUrlMain\":\"https://doi.org/10.29119/1641-3466.2022.166.21\",\"RegionNum\":0,\"RegionCategory\":null,\"ArticlePicture\":[],\"TitleCN\":null,\"AbstractTextCN\":null,\"PMCID\":null,\"EPubDate\":\"\",\"PubModel\":\"\",\"JCR\":\"\",\"JCRName\":\"\",\"Score\":null,\"Total\":0}","platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Scientific Papers of Silesian University of Technology. Organization and Management Series","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.29119/1641-3466.2022.166.21","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"","JCRName":"","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
摘要
目的:本文的主要目的是提出与医务人员的能力和资格需求有关的问题。具体目标是确定医疗保健专业人员资格和能力方面的差距,并为系统变更准备建议/职位。设计/方法/方法:作者根据波兰和外国关于该主题的文献,研究科学文章和电子来源的考虑。作者收集科学文献使用的专业数据库有:Library of Science和Google Scholar。然后,作者在收集到的定量数据中尽可能多地提取知识的基础上,进行定性(定性研究-个体深度访谈)和定量(统计-在线调查)分析。定性研究是一种获取数据的定性技术,在这种技术中,根据事先准备好的采访场景进行采访。IDI技术可以与受访者直接互动,获得定性数据,尽管它不允许(由于缺乏代表性)将其推广到所研究的整个人口,但在特定研究问题的框架内提供了深入的信息。另一方面,统计分析可以确定某一现象发生的程度,然后指出在特定地区和环境中观察到的主要趋势。作为研究的一部分,对医疗设施(POZ)的所有者以及医疗和非医疗人员进行了1000多次CAWI访谈。结果:卫生保健工作者的能力水平与所有公民有关。波兰的教育体系主要面向专业技能培训。医学毕业生只有在开始他们的专业工作时才能获得社会能力。另一方面,雇主在招聘员工时需要证明专业资格的文件。提高医疗机构工作人员的能力和资格将有助于POZ的持续发展。它将是整个有效运作的医疗保健系统的基础。因此,在管理、财务、人才发展等方面要特别重视,要做到全面性关怀。社会影响:波兰的医疗服务市场正在迅速发展。根据研究公司PMR的一份题为“2022年波兰私人医疗保健市场”的报告。“2022-2027年市场分析和发展预测”(EMIS, 2022),价格上涨是私营医疗保健部门面临的主要挑战之一。根据PMR,整个2022年,门诊和其他健康相关服务的价格将比2021年增加约14%,这一方面会影响该市场价值的名义增长,但也会降低其基本动力。另一方面,初级保健服务的提供是由各种保健提供者(企业家:个人或法人实体、非政府组织、spzoz)和专业实践(个人和团体;医生、护士或助产士)。在医疗保健提供者中,企业家人数最多(83%)。提供者与国家卫生服务机构签订合同,提供医生、护士和助产士服务。根据人力资本平衡调查(PARP, 2022),尽管COVID-19大流行造成了组织和财务困难,但中型和大型企业仍在继续投资于培养员工的能力。以工作为基础的学习仍然是一种广泛使用的培养能力的手段,尤其经常用于教育、保健和社会援助以及工业和采矿部门。卫生部门最关键的问题之一是人员短缺,这是由于代际更替、学前和研究生教育制度无效、工作方式变化、移徙、利益集团阻碍进入某些专业以及支持短缺专业(住院医师)的制度不够有效造成的。多年来,医生和护士的短缺在波兰一直很明显。根据欧盟统计局的数据,波兰是欧盟每1000名居民中执业医生人数最少的国家(2.4人),护士人数(每1000名居民5.1人)也是欧盟最低的国家之一(图10)。然而,官方的国家估计数字更高——每1000名居民中有3.4至4.4名医生(Kowalska-Bobko et al., 2021)。原创性/价值:作者就医疗服务劳动力市场所需的资格和能力向卫生政策和立法制定者发表了这篇文章。
The demand for competence and qualification of medical personnel in the light of the results of empirical studies
Purpose: The article's primary purpose is to present issues related to the demand for competence and qualification of medical personnel. The specific goal is to identify gaps in healthcare professionals' qualifications and competencies and prepare recommendations/ positions for system changes. Design/methodology/approach: The author based his considerations on Polish and foreign literature on the subject, studying scientific articles and electronic sources. The author used the following professional databases to collect scientific literature: the Library of Science and Google Scholar. The author then performed qualitative (qualitative research – individual in-depth interview) and quantitative (statistical – online survey) analysis based on extracting as much knowledge as possible from the collected quantitative data. Qualitative research is a qualitative technique for obtaining data in which an interview is conducted based on a previously prepared interview scenario. The IDI technique makes it possible to get – in direct interaction with the respondent - data of a qualitative nature, which, although it does not allow (due to lack of representativeness) to generalize it to the entire population under study, provides in-depth information within the framework of a specific research question. On the other hand, the statistical analysis made it possible to determine the extent to which a given phenomenon occurs, and then indicate the main trends observed in a specific area and environment. As part of the research, more than 1,000 CAWI interviews were conducted with owners of medical facilities (POZ), and medical and non-medical personnel. Findings: The level of competence of healthcare workers concerns all citizens. The Polish education system is mainly oriented towards professional skills training. Social competencies are acquired by medical graduates only when they begin their professional work. On the other hand, employers require documents confirming professional qualifications when looking for employees. Increasing the competencies and qualifications of the staff of medical institutions will contribute to the continuous development of POZ. It will be the foundation of the entire, efficiently operating healthcare system. Therefore, special attention should be paid to management, finance, personnel development, and the comprehensiveness of care. Social implications: The market for medical services is developing rapidly in Poland. According to a report by research firm PMR titled: „Private healthcare market in Poland 2022. Market analysis and development forecasts for 2022-2027" (EMIS, 2022), price increases are one of the main challenges for the private healthcare sector. According to PMR, for the whole of 2022, prices for outpatient and other health-related services will increase by about 14 percent compared to 2021, which will, on the one hand, affect the nominal increase in the value of this market, but will also reduce its fundamental dynamics. On the other hand, the provision of primary healthcare services is carried out by various healthcare providers (entrepreneurs: individuals or legal entities, NGOs, SPZOZs) and professional practices (individuals and groups; doctors, nurses, or midwives). Among healthcare providers, entrepreneurs are the most numerous (83%). Providers contract with the National Health Service for a physician, nurse, and midwife care. According to the Human Capital Balance survey (PARP, 2022), medium and large enterprises continue to invest in developing their employees' competencies, despite the organizational and financial difficulties caused by the COVID-19 pandemic. Work-based learning has remained a widely used means of developing competencies, used particularly frequently in the education, healthcare and social assistance, and industry and mining sectors. Among the most critical problems in the health, the sector is the shortage of personnel, resulting from generational changes, an ineffective system of pre- and postgraduate education, changes in work styles, migration, obstruction of access to certain specialties by interest groups, and an insufficiently effective system of supporting deficit specialties (residencies). A shortage of doctors and nurses has been evident in Poland for years. According to Eurostat data, Poland has the lowest number of practicing physicians per 1,000 residents in the EU (2.4), and the number of nurses (5.1 per 1,000 residents) is also among the lowest in the EU (Figure 10). However, official national estimates are higher - between 3.4 and 4.4 doctors per 1,000 residents (Kowalska-Bobko et al., 2021). Originality/value: The author addressed the article to health policy and legislation makers on the desired qualifications and competencies in the medical services labor market. Indirect recipients are market entrepreneurs involved in identifying and forecasting qualifications and professional needs in the labor market (Primary Healthcare (PHC) medical facilities - PHC owners, medical and non-medical staff). Parallel audiences are stakeholders involved in the formation of the qualification system of the healthcare sector, including institutions responsible for defining education standards and awarding titles, administrative units running education and qualification institutions, and formal education entities (universities, schools, training institutions). The article’s value is to identify gaps in the competencies and qualifications of medical personnel to shape health policy so that these gaps are minimized. Keywords: competencies, qualifications, healthcare system, medical personnel. Category of the paper: Research paper.