Statistical Tests for Cross-Validation of Kriging Models

Kriging or Gaussian process models are popular metamodels (surrogate models or emulators) of simulation models; these metamodels give predictors for input combinations that are not simulated. To validate these metamodels for computationally expensive simulation models, the analysts often apply computationally efficient cross-validation. In this paper, we derive new statistical tests for so-called leave-one-out cross-validation. Graphically, we present these tests as scatterplots augmented with confidence intervals that use the estimated variances of the Kriging predictors. To estimate the true variances of these predictors, we might use bootstrapping. Like other statistical tests, our tests—with or without bootstrapping—have type I and type II error probabilities; to estimate these probabilities, we use Monte Carlo experiments. We also use such experiments to investigate statistical convergence. To illustrate the application of our tests, we use (i) an example with two inputs and (ii) the popular borehole example with eight inputs. Summary of Contribution: Simulation models are very popular in operations research (OR) and are also known as computer simulations or computer experiments. A popular topic is design and analysis of computer experiments. This paper focuses on Kriging methods and cross-validation methods applied to simulation models; these methods and models are often applied in OR. More specifically, the paper provides the following; (1) the basic variant of a new statistical test for leave-one–out cross-validation; (2) a bootstrap method for the estimation of the true variance of the Kriging predictor; and (3) Monte Carlo experiments for the evaluation of the consistency of the Kriging predictor, the convergence of the Studentized prediction error to the standard normal variable, and the convergence of the expected experimentwise type I error rate to the prespecified nominal value. The new statistical test is illustrated through examples, including the popular borehole model.