How End Users Express Conditionals in Programming by Demonstration for Mobile Apps

Though conditionals are an integral component of programming, providing an easy means of creating conditionals remains a challenge for programming-by-demonstration (PBD) systems for task automation. We hypothesize that a promising method for implementing conditionals in such systems is to incorporate the use of verbal instructions. Verbal instructions supplied concurrently with demonstrations have been shown to improve the generalizability of PBD. However, the challenge of supporting conditional creation using this multi-modal approach has not been addressed. In this extended abstract, we present our study on understanding how end users describe conditionals in natural language for mobile app tasks. We conducted a formative study of 56 participants asking them to verbally describe conditionals in different settings for 9 sample tasks and to invent conditional tasks. Participant responses were analyzed using open coding and revealed that, in the context of mobile apps, end users often omit desired else statements when explaining conditionals, sometimes use ambiguous concepts in expressing conditionals, and often desire to implement complex conditionals. Based on these findings, we discuss the implications for designing a multimodal PBD interface to support the creation of conditionals.