Assay discrepancies using human coagulation factor VIII chromogenic kits: Results from a plasma-derived factor VIII collaborative study (BSP112).

Abstract

Chromogenic assay discrepancies were reported at General European Official Medicines Control Laboratories Network (GEON) meetings by laboratories testing FVIII-products. The objectives of the present investigation were to carry out a controlled collaborative study to examine these reports and to delineate the reasons for these discrepancies by assessing affected and unaffected FVIII products. The laboratories followed a strict study protocol, which included assessing their own individual observed factor X (FX) activation times, i.e. the time to reach 50% of maximal FX activation (T_1/2), for each chromogenic kit. This measurement was used, in parallel with the kit manufacturers' prescribed FX activation times, to assess the performance of the chromogenic potency assays on FVIII test products. This study confirmed a significant discrepancy between Coatest® and Coamatic® kits and between Siemens and Coamatic® kits when the kit manufacturers' prescribed T_1/2 incubation times were followed. Coamatic® kits tended to produce higher potencies than the Coatest® or Siemens kits. Furthermore, FX activation assays revealed marked differences between individual laboratories for all three chromogenic kits in the observed T_1/2 incubation times, which also did not correspond to the prescribed T_1/2 incubation times. The resulting differences in potency between kits, in some cases, were significantly reduced when using the actual observed T_1/2 incubation times instead of the prescribed T_1/2 incubation times. The study showed that FVIII potency discrepancies can occur between chromogenic kits. To compensate for this, laboratories should ideally perform FX activation curves for each new chromogenic kit in order to determine the correct observed T_1/2 incubation times, which can then be used to determine FVIII potencies in therapeutic concentrates.