Fair use and fairness in copyright: A distributive justice perspective on users' rights

Abstract

Australia is once again considering how to best protect the public interest in copyright. One of the most contested current issues in Australian copyright law is the question of limits and exceptions to the rights of copyright owners. The recent Australian Law Reform Commission (‘ALRC’) review into copyright exceptions recommended broadening and simplifying the exceptions to better protect the interests of users to access and reuse copyright material for socially beneficial purposes. Despite the exhaustive consultation and report produced by the ALRC, and the support lent to it by the recent Productivity Commission Inquiry Report, there is little consensus about its recommendations. The proposal to introduce fair use is strongly contested by rightsholder groups, who are reluctant to cede further control over the use of information and cultural goods, particularly given the challenges they have faced transitioning to a digital environment.