Leveraging problem-independent hyper-heuristics for real-world test laboratory scheduling

Abstract

The area of project scheduling problems has seen a tremendous amount of different problem variations. Traditionally, each problem variant requires custom solution approaches in order to produce high-quality solutions. Developing and tuning these methods is an expensive process that may have to be repeated as soon as the requirements or problem structures change. On the other hand, research into hyper-heuristics has produced general heuristic problem-solving techniques that were developed to achieve good results on multiple diverse problem domains. They work with a set of comparatively simple low-level heuristics and dynamically adapt themselves to each new problem variant. In this paper, we investigate hyper-heuristic approaches for a real-world industrial test laboratory scheduling problem and develop a new problem domain for the HyFlex hyper-heuristic framework. We propose a diverse portfolio of low-level heuristics that can be dynamically selected during the search process by hyper-heuristics to solve the problem. We evaluate and compare the performance of several problem-independent hyper-heuristics on this domain and show that they are able to match, and sometimes even exceed, the performance of state-of-the-art solution techniques that were developed and tuned specifically for this problem.