Evaluation of different training strategies to improve decision-making performance in inspection

Abstract

Various studies in inspection have demonstrated the usefulness of feedforward (FF) and feedback (FB) in improving the performance of inspectors. However, the results of these studies are not conclusive as to their effect on the sensitivity and response strategy of inspectors. Hence, this study evaluates the individual and collective effect of FF and FB on the sensitivity and response strategy of the inspectors using a computer simulation of a contact lens inspection task. Twenty-four subjects, randomly assigned to various conditions, performed an inspection task wherein the FF and FB conditions were manipulated between the subjects. In addition, the defect probability and the discriminability were manipulated within the subjects. Subsequently, the results were interpreted using signal detection theory. Although feedback improved the sensitivity, a finding consistent with earlier studies, feedforward was more effective in assisting the inspectors in setting their response strategy closer to the optimum. Moreover, providing both FF and FB resulted in improved sensitivity as well as a more optimal response strategy. © 1996 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.