{"title":"Interculturalism in Sam Najjair’s account of the battle for Tripoli: Soldier for a Summer","authors":"Marie Louvet","doi":"10.24162/EI2015-6200","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"We, here in our internment camp, greet the 1st September revolution and its leader, Colonel Mu'ammar al-Qhadafi. The voice of this leader reaches us despite the solitary confinement cells and the prison guards. [...] Long live the Arab-Irish struggle. Libyan radio Voice of the Arab Homeland, 22 December 1976 This message of support for Muammar Gaddafi's pan-Arab and quasi-socialist aspirations emanated in 1975 from republican prisoners in the Maze prison in Northern Ireland. It was read on the official Libyan radio Voice of the Arab Homeland one year later, as part of the propaganda celebrating the anti-imperialist convictions of the Libyan regime a few years after Gaddafi came into power following the 1969 coup against King Idris. (1) Simultaneously with the radio announcement, An Phoblacht, the Irish republican newspaper, was publishing extracts from Gaddafi's Green Book promoting his model of direct popular democracy, based on the participation of grassroots popular committees. (2) The striking contrast between the republicans' enthusiasm shortly after Gaddafi seized power in the 1970s and the general discredit at the moment of his fall in 2011 resulted from a reign associated with despotism, corruption and widespread oppression of the people. In Soldier for a Summer, Irish Libyan Sam Najjair gives a detailed account of his participation in the Libyan revolution against Gaddafi in 2011, while making a point of explaining his motives to the general public, in particular to Irish readers. In the narrative, he conjures up the memory of the republican commitment of his Irish grandparents to anti-imperialism. After 40 years of the Gaddafi dictatorship, the republican ideal was intact but the old Libyan ally had become an enemy to destroy. Comparisons between the Irish struggle to obtain independence from Britain and conflicts in the Arab world have been commonly deployed by militants since the end of the 1960s (Louvet 2016), but one striking feature in Sam Najjair's autobiographical work is the extent to which interculturalism pervades the narrative of the man born in Ireland to an Irish mother and a Libyan father. Interculturalism results from an interaction between different cultures and announces the possibility of the emergence of a new form of cultural expression and identity. As such, interculturalism can be observed in particular as an outcome of immigration, with the second generation of immigrants being steeped in two cultures and trying to reconcile them in the narrative of the self to build a sense of identity. In the case of second-generation immigrants, autobiographical narratives are written testimonies of the process of conciliation and reconciliation at play in \"minor literature\" in the words of Deleuze, that is to say emerging from a minority living among a majority culture and whose main three characteristics are the deterritorialization of the language, the connection of the individual and the political and collective arrangement of utterance (Deleuze and Guattari 1996: 29-33). Such characteristics are at play in Soldier for a Summer as the reader follows the narrator from Dublin to Tripoli and then back to Dublin at the end of the war. Throughout the narrative, Sam Najjair outlines an intercultural space between Ireland and Libya, opening 'an Irish angle' on the Libyan conflict, directly connected to his dual identity as the son of a Libyan immigrant living in Dublin. The Irish angle, which will be analysed in this paper, provides legitimacy to the fight in Libya while soliciting empathy and understanding from the Irish reader. It can be identified as being part of what the political sociologists Keck and Sikkink call \"framing\" the issue, that is to say shaping the narrative in such a way that it is likely to rally support for a cause, often by making use of symbolic references which are immediately identified by the target audience (Keck and Sikkink 1998: 10). …","PeriodicalId":29863,"journal":{"name":"EIGSE-A JOURNAL OF IRISH STUDIES","volume":"27 1","pages":"82-92"},"PeriodicalIF":0.0000,"publicationDate":"2016-03-15","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"EIGSE-A JOURNAL OF IRISH STUDIES","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.24162/EI2015-6200","RegionNum":4,"RegionCategory":"文学","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"","JCRName":"","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
Abstract
We, here in our internment camp, greet the 1st September revolution and its leader, Colonel Mu'ammar al-Qhadafi. The voice of this leader reaches us despite the solitary confinement cells and the prison guards. [...] Long live the Arab-Irish struggle. Libyan radio Voice of the Arab Homeland, 22 December 1976 This message of support for Muammar Gaddafi's pan-Arab and quasi-socialist aspirations emanated in 1975 from republican prisoners in the Maze prison in Northern Ireland. It was read on the official Libyan radio Voice of the Arab Homeland one year later, as part of the propaganda celebrating the anti-imperialist convictions of the Libyan regime a few years after Gaddafi came into power following the 1969 coup against King Idris. (1) Simultaneously with the radio announcement, An Phoblacht, the Irish republican newspaper, was publishing extracts from Gaddafi's Green Book promoting his model of direct popular democracy, based on the participation of grassroots popular committees. (2) The striking contrast between the republicans' enthusiasm shortly after Gaddafi seized power in the 1970s and the general discredit at the moment of his fall in 2011 resulted from a reign associated with despotism, corruption and widespread oppression of the people. In Soldier for a Summer, Irish Libyan Sam Najjair gives a detailed account of his participation in the Libyan revolution against Gaddafi in 2011, while making a point of explaining his motives to the general public, in particular to Irish readers. In the narrative, he conjures up the memory of the republican commitment of his Irish grandparents to anti-imperialism. After 40 years of the Gaddafi dictatorship, the republican ideal was intact but the old Libyan ally had become an enemy to destroy. Comparisons between the Irish struggle to obtain independence from Britain and conflicts in the Arab world have been commonly deployed by militants since the end of the 1960s (Louvet 2016), but one striking feature in Sam Najjair's autobiographical work is the extent to which interculturalism pervades the narrative of the man born in Ireland to an Irish mother and a Libyan father. Interculturalism results from an interaction between different cultures and announces the possibility of the emergence of a new form of cultural expression and identity. As such, interculturalism can be observed in particular as an outcome of immigration, with the second generation of immigrants being steeped in two cultures and trying to reconcile them in the narrative of the self to build a sense of identity. In the case of second-generation immigrants, autobiographical narratives are written testimonies of the process of conciliation and reconciliation at play in "minor literature" in the words of Deleuze, that is to say emerging from a minority living among a majority culture and whose main three characteristics are the deterritorialization of the language, the connection of the individual and the political and collective arrangement of utterance (Deleuze and Guattari 1996: 29-33). Such characteristics are at play in Soldier for a Summer as the reader follows the narrator from Dublin to Tripoli and then back to Dublin at the end of the war. Throughout the narrative, Sam Najjair outlines an intercultural space between Ireland and Libya, opening 'an Irish angle' on the Libyan conflict, directly connected to his dual identity as the son of a Libyan immigrant living in Dublin. The Irish angle, which will be analysed in this paper, provides legitimacy to the fight in Libya while soliciting empathy and understanding from the Irish reader. It can be identified as being part of what the political sociologists Keck and Sikkink call "framing" the issue, that is to say shaping the narrative in such a way that it is likely to rally support for a cause, often by making use of symbolic references which are immediately identified by the target audience (Keck and Sikkink 1998: 10). …
在我们的拘留营里,我们向9月1日的革命及其领袖穆阿迈尔·卡扎菲上校致敬。尽管有单独监禁的牢房和狱警,我们还是能听到这位领袖的声音。[…阿拉伯人和爱尔兰人的斗争万岁。1975年,支持穆阿迈尔·卡扎菲的泛阿拉伯和准社会主义愿望的信息从北爱尔兰梅兹监狱的共和派囚犯中发出。一年后,利比亚官方广播电台“阿拉伯家园之声”(Voice of the Arab Homeland)播放了这篇文章,作为庆祝利比亚政权反帝国主义信念的宣传的一部分。几年后,卡扎菲在1969年推翻伊德里斯国王的政变中掌权。与此同时,爱尔兰共和派报纸《An Phoblacht》也发表了卡扎菲《绿皮书》的节选,宣传他基于基层人民委员会参与的直接人民民主模式。20世纪70年代卡扎菲夺取政权后不久,共和党人的热情与2011年他倒台时的普遍声誉形成了鲜明对比,这是由于他的统治与专制、腐败和对人民的广泛压迫有关。爱尔兰裔利比亚人Sam Najjair在《一个夏天的战士》一书中详细描述了他在2011年参与反对卡扎菲的利比亚革命的过程,同时向公众,特别是爱尔兰读者解释了他的动机。在叙述中,他唤起了他的爱尔兰祖父母对反帝国主义的共和承诺的记忆。经过卡扎菲40年的独裁统治,共和国的理想依然完好无损,但这个利比亚的老盟友却成了一个需要摧毁的敌人。自20世纪60年代末以来,武装分子就经常将爱尔兰从英国手中争取独立的斗争与阿拉伯世界的冲突进行比较(Louvet 2016),但萨姆·纳贾尔(Sam Najjair)的自传体作品中一个引人注目的特点是,跨文化主义在这个出生在爱尔兰、母亲是爱尔兰人、父亲是利比亚人的男人的叙事中无处不在。跨文化主义是不同文化之间相互作用的结果,它预示着一种新的文化表达和认同形式出现的可能性。因此,跨文化主义可以特别观察到作为移民的结果,第二代移民沉浸在两种文化中,并试图在自我叙事中调和它们,以建立一种认同感。就第二代移民而言,自传体叙事是德勒兹所说的“小众文学”中调解与和解过程的书面见证,也就是说,从生活在多数文化中的少数民族中出现,其主要特征是语言的非领土化,个人的联系以及话语的政治和集体安排(德勒兹和瓜塔里1996:29-33)。这些特点在《一个夏天的士兵》中发挥了作用,读者跟随叙述者从都柏林到的黎波里,然后在战争结束时回到都柏林。在整个叙述中,Sam Najjair勾勒出爱尔兰和利比亚之间的跨文化空间,从“爱尔兰的角度”看待利比亚冲突,这与他作为生活在都柏林的利比亚移民之子的双重身份直接相关。爱尔兰的角度,这将在本文中进行分析,为利比亚的战斗提供合法性,同时征求爱尔兰读者的同情和理解。它可以被认为是政治社会学家Keck和Sikkink所说的“框架”问题的一部分,也就是说,通过使用目标受众立即识别的象征性参考,以这样一种方式塑造叙事,从而可能为某一事业赢得支持(Keck和Sikkink 1998: 10)。…