Volume Change of Cement Plugs: Spotlight on the Role of Boundary Conditions Using an Improved Testing Method

Abstract

Expansion additives have been used in cement plugs to mitigate the potential risk of plug failure resulting from shrinkage. These additives are effective only when their amount is tailored for downhole boundary conditions, and their role should be well understood. This work discusses using an improved testing method that enhances the dependability of the volume change measurement and exhibits the impact of test boundary conditions on the shrinking and expanding behaviors of cement plugs. Boundary conditions investigated with this method include temperature, pressure, water access to the cement from the formation, and the role of mechanical constraints. Dependability is demonstrated by verifying the repeatability and reproducibility of the method at two different laboratories. Together with the noninvasive continuous volume change, supplementary measurements, such as ultrasonic compressive strength, tensile strength, and chemical composition analysis, have provided inferences about the mechanism of volume change. The new method embodies all attributes listed in API 10 TR2 (1997), including a constant external stress state in all measurements and a constant pore pressure during total volume change measurement. The results of percentage volume change from this test method present an extremely small variance, highlighting its repeatability; additionally, the measurement was reproducible between laboratories. Expansion value increased with a decrease in confining pressure, and excessive expansion in the absence of an effective confining pressure produced weak samples. The absence of outside water caused cement containing the expansion aid to shrink more than its neat equivalent; such observations highlight the importance of fluid boundary on the action of expansion additives. These observations were possible because the test method can capture temporal and boundary condition effects more aptly. Thus, the improved method provides a dependable measurement for tailoring plug properties.