THE PHILOSOPHICAL CONTENTS OF DĪWĀN LUGHĀT AL-TURK (Divanü Lûgat-it-Türk’te Felsefî İçerikler).

IF 0.1
Vefa Taşdelen
{"title":"THE PHILOSOPHICAL CONTENTS OF DĪWĀN LUGHĀT AL-TURK (Divanü Lûgat-it-Türk’te Felsefî İçerikler).","authors":"Vefa Taşdelen","doi":"10.14395/hititilahiyat.673391","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"Abstract Philosophy is a work of mind which is produced in language. The power of expression regarding being, mankind, society, morality, and value manifests the philosophical potential of a language as well. The potential of the language is the potential of philosophy and the potential of philosophy is the potential of the language. Dīwān Lughāt al-Turk is one of the oldest and the most important texts of Turkish culture. This work that is written to teach Turkish to foreigners, is not a work of dictionary in a simplistic sense, it has a quality of an “anthology” which presents the samples from the structure of the language of its own period such as poetry, proverb, and story according to the requirement of the language teaching that is embodying and exemplary. It is one of the works that has a quality of exhibiting the philosophical potential of Turkish, the possibility to conceive and articulate the being in scope of the riddle of human being, God and universe; for the first time as in the most advanced level. This article aims to deal with the philosophical content in the text. In this article words, idioms, proverbs, poems, stories, and sample sentences will be examined in terms of their philosophical contents and connotations. This accumulation, will take place in order to reflect the holistic perspective of philosophy within the frame of: (1) conception of being, (2) conception of knowledge, (3) conception of human, (4) ethical and aesthetic values. Summary Great texts are texts which are alive; they need to be re-read, re-comprehended and reproduced. Dīwān Lughāt al-Turk  is such a living text; it embodies the accumulated education, science, thought, and culture of life in its own period. Language is simultaneously experience, worldview, conception of the universe, culture of living, and the apprehension of civilization; language is a common reason with the words, conceptions and traditional verbal components (epics, proverbs, ballads, tales, myths, elegies, jokes) it embodies. Dīwān Lughāt al-Turk  is precisely such a book of common reason. It is the common accumulation and common treasure of Turkish civilization; its intention is to present a common language of culture and communication without respect to the differentiations of accent and dialect that arise from distance over space (geography) and time. Likewise, Dīwān Lughāt al-Turk  opens up the conception of Turkish into Arabic, in terms of its worldview, apprehension of life, and cultural riches; it furthermore opens up Arabic, the language of education, science, philosophy and literature, into Turkish. It does so by the means of reproducing Turkish in Arabic; it, so to speak, attunes the two languages to one another via their mutual encounter. Philosophy is a language study and emerging in the language. The power of expressing existence, people, society, morality and value constitutes the philosophical potential of a language. Languages in which great philosophies are produced are languages that allow for a detailed and inclusive consideration of existence. The \"alternating\" and \"reciprocal\" relationship between philosophy and language is reflected not only from language to thought but also from thought to language; the meaning given to the being in its broadest sense, the ability and skill in expressing the being is a contribution to the development and enrichment of the language. The potential of language determines philosophical effort; the potential of language is the potential of philosophy; the potential of philosophy is the potential of language. Dīwān Lughāt al-Turk  is one of the works in which the philosophical potential of Turkish is exhibited for the first time in the context of the concept of human beings, God and the universe. As a language has its own capacity, so too do human beings have a capacity of their own. As a language possesses its own wisdom, so too does each individual human being have a wisdom one of his or her own. At some point, language transcends being a mere “instrument” and transforms into a state of mind or consciousness that reflects in its own body the accumulation of millennia. Therein, people feel as if they were swept along in a vigorous river that comes flowing through the depths ofthe history, becoming ever greater and stronger as it flows. Philosophy, as the activity of deep thinking, emerges at the point where the capacity of humankind converges with the capacity of language, where the accumulation of language intersects with the accumulation of human beings. When the capacity of language is met by the faculties and strivings of mankind, it moves beyond mere potential and becomes an active force. Every language possesses its own mental structure and worldview. A language, which reflects a worldview, culture and the philosophy of a nation, also possesses a philosophical quality with a unique conception of being, knowledge, and values it encapsulates. This is certainly true of Dīwān Lughāt al-Turk . While the Lughāt is not a dictionary in a simplistic sense, it occupies the position of a work of art which reflects with the vocabulary it transmits; in this case, the apprehension of thought, belief and morality of the Turkish mind, as the latter exists in the frames of being, knowledge and value, and in its purest and most concise form. This rich context enables us to read it not only as a dictionary but also as a book of knowledge, culture and wisdom. Every text ought to be read and comprehended from a philosophical perspective. Such a reading enriches the text and enables it to endure. Looking at a text from a philosophical point of view does not mean to claim that the text is philosophical. Rather, such a “philosophical” reading can be defined as: (1) a reading which conceptualizes; (2) a reading which problematizes; (3) a reading which deals with an issue not in the framework of singular examples but in a holistic perspective; (4) a critical reading; (5) a reading which regards language and thought coherently; (6) a reading which intends to deal with the subject matter comprehensively and strives for integrity and consistency within that frame; (7) an interdisciplinary reading; (8) a reading which eventually seeks to ground the subject matter pursuant to ontological, epistemological, ethical and aesthetic values, to make it comprehensible; and (9) a reading which considers the historical and traditional context in its own right. In the current article, Dīwān Lughāt al-Turk will be read with the express purpose of laying forth the philosophical contents encapsulated therein; its subject will be treated within the framework of (1) being ( ontology ), (2) knowledge ( epistemology ), and (3) ethical and aesthetic values ( axiology ). This effort will also mean exploring the philosophical potential of this first source, in which the Turkish language accumulates in its purest form.","PeriodicalId":40974,"journal":{"name":"Hitit Universitesi Ilahiyat Fakultesi Dergisi-Journal of Divinity Faculty of Hitit University","volume":"69 1","pages":"151-172"},"PeriodicalIF":0.1000,"publicationDate":"2020-06-30","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"2","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Hitit Universitesi Ilahiyat Fakultesi Dergisi-Journal of Divinity Faculty of Hitit University","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.14395/hititilahiyat.673391","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"","JCRName":"","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 2

Abstract

Abstract Philosophy is a work of mind which is produced in language. The power of expression regarding being, mankind, society, morality, and value manifests the philosophical potential of a language as well. The potential of the language is the potential of philosophy and the potential of philosophy is the potential of the language. Dīwān Lughāt al-Turk is one of the oldest and the most important texts of Turkish culture. This work that is written to teach Turkish to foreigners, is not a work of dictionary in a simplistic sense, it has a quality of an “anthology” which presents the samples from the structure of the language of its own period such as poetry, proverb, and story according to the requirement of the language teaching that is embodying and exemplary. It is one of the works that has a quality of exhibiting the philosophical potential of Turkish, the possibility to conceive and articulate the being in scope of the riddle of human being, God and universe; for the first time as in the most advanced level. This article aims to deal with the philosophical content in the text. In this article words, idioms, proverbs, poems, stories, and sample sentences will be examined in terms of their philosophical contents and connotations. This accumulation, will take place in order to reflect the holistic perspective of philosophy within the frame of: (1) conception of being, (2) conception of knowledge, (3) conception of human, (4) ethical and aesthetic values. Summary Great texts are texts which are alive; they need to be re-read, re-comprehended and reproduced. Dīwān Lughāt al-Turk  is such a living text; it embodies the accumulated education, science, thought, and culture of life in its own period. Language is simultaneously experience, worldview, conception of the universe, culture of living, and the apprehension of civilization; language is a common reason with the words, conceptions and traditional verbal components (epics, proverbs, ballads, tales, myths, elegies, jokes) it embodies. Dīwān Lughāt al-Turk  is precisely such a book of common reason. It is the common accumulation and common treasure of Turkish civilization; its intention is to present a common language of culture and communication without respect to the differentiations of accent and dialect that arise from distance over space (geography) and time. Likewise, Dīwān Lughāt al-Turk  opens up the conception of Turkish into Arabic, in terms of its worldview, apprehension of life, and cultural riches; it furthermore opens up Arabic, the language of education, science, philosophy and literature, into Turkish. It does so by the means of reproducing Turkish in Arabic; it, so to speak, attunes the two languages to one another via their mutual encounter. Philosophy is a language study and emerging in the language. The power of expressing existence, people, society, morality and value constitutes the philosophical potential of a language. Languages in which great philosophies are produced are languages that allow for a detailed and inclusive consideration of existence. The "alternating" and "reciprocal" relationship between philosophy and language is reflected not only from language to thought but also from thought to language; the meaning given to the being in its broadest sense, the ability and skill in expressing the being is a contribution to the development and enrichment of the language. The potential of language determines philosophical effort; the potential of language is the potential of philosophy; the potential of philosophy is the potential of language. Dīwān Lughāt al-Turk  is one of the works in which the philosophical potential of Turkish is exhibited for the first time in the context of the concept of human beings, God and the universe. As a language has its own capacity, so too do human beings have a capacity of their own. As a language possesses its own wisdom, so too does each individual human being have a wisdom one of his or her own. At some point, language transcends being a mere “instrument” and transforms into a state of mind or consciousness that reflects in its own body the accumulation of millennia. Therein, people feel as if they were swept along in a vigorous river that comes flowing through the depths ofthe history, becoming ever greater and stronger as it flows. Philosophy, as the activity of deep thinking, emerges at the point where the capacity of humankind converges with the capacity of language, where the accumulation of language intersects with the accumulation of human beings. When the capacity of language is met by the faculties and strivings of mankind, it moves beyond mere potential and becomes an active force. Every language possesses its own mental structure and worldview. A language, which reflects a worldview, culture and the philosophy of a nation, also possesses a philosophical quality with a unique conception of being, knowledge, and values it encapsulates. This is certainly true of Dīwān Lughāt al-Turk . While the Lughāt is not a dictionary in a simplistic sense, it occupies the position of a work of art which reflects with the vocabulary it transmits; in this case, the apprehension of thought, belief and morality of the Turkish mind, as the latter exists in the frames of being, knowledge and value, and in its purest and most concise form. This rich context enables us to read it not only as a dictionary but also as a book of knowledge, culture and wisdom. Every text ought to be read and comprehended from a philosophical perspective. Such a reading enriches the text and enables it to endure. Looking at a text from a philosophical point of view does not mean to claim that the text is philosophical. Rather, such a “philosophical” reading can be defined as: (1) a reading which conceptualizes; (2) a reading which problematizes; (3) a reading which deals with an issue not in the framework of singular examples but in a holistic perspective; (4) a critical reading; (5) a reading which regards language and thought coherently; (6) a reading which intends to deal with the subject matter comprehensively and strives for integrity and consistency within that frame; (7) an interdisciplinary reading; (8) a reading which eventually seeks to ground the subject matter pursuant to ontological, epistemological, ethical and aesthetic values, to make it comprehensible; and (9) a reading which considers the historical and traditional context in its own right. In the current article, Dīwān Lughāt al-Turk will be read with the express purpose of laying forth the philosophical contents encapsulated therein; its subject will be treated within the framework of (1) being ( ontology ), (2) knowledge ( epistemology ), and (3) ethical and aesthetic values ( axiology ). This effort will also mean exploring the philosophical potential of this first source, in which the Turkish language accumulates in its purest form.
哲学是一种以语言产生的思想作品。语言对存在、对人类、对社会、对道德、对价值的表达能力,也体现了语言的哲学潜能。语言的潜能就是哲学的潜能哲学的潜能就是语言的潜能。Dīwān Lughāt al-Turk是土耳其文化最古老和最重要的文本之一。这部作品是为了向外国人教授土耳其语而写的,不是一本简单意义上的词典,它具有“选集”的性质,它根据语言教学的要求,从自己的语言结构中呈现出诗歌,谚语和故事等样本,具有体现性和示范性。这是一部具有展示土耳其语哲学潜力的作品,在人类、上帝和宇宙之谜的范围内构思和表达存在的可能性;第一次在最先进的水平。本文旨在探讨文本中的哲学内容。在这篇文章中,词汇、成语、谚语、诗歌、故事和例句将从其哲学内容和内涵的角度进行研究。这种积累是为了在以下框架内反映哲学的整体视角:(1)存在的概念,(2)知识的概念,(3)人的概念,(4)伦理和审美价值。伟大的文本是有生命的文本;它们需要被重新阅读、重新理解和复制。Dīwān Lughāt土耳其语就是这样一个活生生的文本;它凝聚了其所处时代的教育、科学、思想、文化的积淀。语言同时是经验、世界观、宇宙观、生活文化和对文明的理解;语言是一种共同的理性,它包含了词语、概念和传统的语言成分(史诗、谚语、民谣、故事、神话、挽歌、笑话)。Dīwān Lughāt al-Turk正是这样一本关于共同理性的书。是土耳其文明的共同积累和共同宝藏;它的目的是呈现一种文化和交流的共同语言,而不考虑由于空间(地理)和时间的距离而产生的口音和方言的差异。同样,Dīwān Lughāt al-Turk在世界观、对生活的理解和文化财富方面,将土耳其的概念打开为阿拉伯语;它进一步将阿拉伯语——教育、科学、哲学和文学的语言——开放为土耳其语。它通过在阿拉伯语中复制土耳其语来做到这一点;可以说,它通过两种语言的相互接触使它们彼此协调。哲学是一门语言研究和新兴的语言。语言表达存在、人、社会、道德和价值的能力构成了语言的哲学潜能。产生伟大哲学的语言是允许对存在进行详细和全面考虑的语言。哲学与语言的“交替”与“互惠”关系不仅体现在语言到思想之间,也体现在思想到语言之间;在最广泛的意义上赋予存在的意义,表达存在的能力和技巧是对语言发展和丰富的贡献。语言的潜能决定了哲学上的努力;语言的潜能就是哲学的潜能;哲学的潜力就是语言的潜力。Dīwān Lughāt al-Turk是土耳其语的哲学潜力首次在人类、上帝和宇宙概念的背景下得到展示的作品之一。语言有它自己的能力,人类也有自己的能力。正如语言拥有自己的智慧一样,每个人也都有自己的智慧。在某种程度上,语言超越了仅仅是一种“工具”,而转变为一种精神或意识状态,这种状态反映了它自身数千年的积累。在这里,人们仿佛置身于一条从历史深处奔流而来的激流之中,越流越大,越流越强。哲学作为一种深刻的思考活动,产生于人类的能力与语言的能力的交汇点,产生于语言的积累与人类的积累的交叉点。当语言的能力被人类的能力和努力所满足时,它就不仅仅是一种潜力,而成为一种积极的力量。每种语言都有自己的思维结构和世界观。语言不仅反映了一个民族的世界观、文化和哲学,而且还具有哲学性,它所蕴含的是一种独特的存在观念、知识观念和价值观。对于Dīwān Lughāt al-Turk来说确实如此。 哲学是一种以语言产生的思想作品。语言对存在、对人类、对社会、对道德、对价值的表达能力,也体现了语言的哲学潜能。语言的潜能就是哲学的潜能哲学的潜能就是语言的潜能。Dīwān Lughāt al-Turk是土耳其文化最古老和最重要的文本之一。这部作品是为了向外国人教授土耳其语而写的,不是一本简单意义上的词典,它具有“选集”的性质,它根据语言教学的要求,从自己的语言结构中呈现出诗歌,谚语和故事等样本,具有体现性和示范性。这是一部具有展示土耳其语哲学潜力的作品,在人类、上帝和宇宙之谜的范围内构思和表达存在的可能性;第一次在最先进的水平。本文旨在探讨文本中的哲学内容。在这篇文章中,词汇、成语、谚语、诗歌、故事和例句将从其哲学内容和内涵的角度进行研究。这种积累是为了在以下框架内反映哲学的整体视角:(1)存在的概念,(2)知识的概念,(3)人的概念,(4)伦理和审美价值。伟大的文本是有生命的文本;它们需要被重新阅读、重新理解和复制。Dīwān Lughāt土耳其语就是这样一个活生生的文本;它凝聚了其所处时代的教育、科学、思想、文化的积淀。语言同时是经验、世界观、宇宙观、生活文化和对文明的理解;语言是一种共同的理性,它包含了词语、概念和传统的语言成分(史诗、谚语、民谣、故事、神话、挽歌、笑话)。Dīwān Lughāt al-Turk正是这样一本关于共同理性的书。是土耳其文明的共同积累和共同宝藏;它的目的是呈现一种文化和交流的共同语言,而不考虑由于空间(地理)和时间的距离而产生的口音和方言的差异。同样,Dīwān Lughāt al-Turk在世界观、对生活的理解和文化财富方面,将土耳其的概念打开为阿拉伯语;它进一步将阿拉伯语——教育、科学、哲学和文学的语言——开放为土耳其语。它通过在阿拉伯语中复制土耳其语来做到这一点;可以说,它通过两种语言的相互接触使它们彼此协调。哲学是一门语言研究和新兴的语言。语言表达存在、人、社会、道德和价值的能力构成了语言的哲学潜能。产生伟大哲学的语言是允许对存在进行详细和全面考虑的语言。哲学与语言的“交替”与“互惠”关系不仅体现在语言到思想之间,也体现在思想到语言之间;在最广泛的意义上赋予存在的意义,表达存在的能力和技巧是对语言发展和丰富的贡献。语言的潜能决定了哲学上的努力;语言的潜能就是哲学的潜能;哲学的潜力就是语言的潜力。Dīwān Lughāt al-Turk是土耳其语的哲学潜力首次在人类、上帝和宇宙概念的背景下得到展示的作品之一。语言有它自己的能力,人类也有自己的能力。正如语言拥有自己的智慧一样,每个人也都有自己的智慧。在某种程度上,语言超越了仅仅是一种“工具”,而转变为一种精神或意识状态,这种状态反映了它自身数千年的积累。在这里,人们仿佛置身于一条从历史深处奔流而来的激流之中,越流越大,越流越强。哲学作为一种深刻的思考活动,产生于人类的能力与语言的能力的交汇点,产生于语言的积累与人类的积累的交叉点。当语言的能力被人类的能力和努力所满足时,它就不仅仅是一种潜力,而成为一种积极的力量。每种语言都有自己的思维结构和世界观。语言不仅反映了一个民族的世界观、文化和哲学,而且还具有哲学性,它所蕴含的是一种独特的存在观念、知识观念和价值观。对于Dīwān Lughāt al-Turk来说确实如此。 虽然Lughāt不是简单意义上的字典,但它占据了一件艺术作品的位置,用它所传递的词汇来反映;在这种情况下,土耳其人对思想、信仰和道德的理解,因为后者存在于存在、知识和价值的框架中,并以最纯粹和最简洁的形式存在。丰富的文脉使我们不仅可以把它当作一本字典来读,而且可以把它当作一本知识、文化和智慧之书来读。每一篇文章都应该从哲学的角度来阅读和理解。这样的阅读丰富了文本,使其经久不衰。从哲学的角度来看一篇文章,并不是说这篇文章就是哲学的。相反,这种“哲学”阅读可以定义为:(1)概念化的阅读;(2)产生问题的阅读;(3)不是在单个例子的框架中,而是在整体视角下处理问题的阅读;(4)批判性阅读;(5)连贯地看待语言和思维的阅读;(6)旨在全面处理主题并力求在该框架内保持完整性和一致性的阅读;(7)跨学科阅读;(8)一种最终寻求根据本体论、认识论、伦理和美学价值来建立主题的阅读,使其易于理解;(9)一种考虑历史和传统背景的阅读。在这篇文章中,Dīwān Lughāt al-Turk将带着阐述其中包含的哲学内容的明确目的来阅读;它的主题将在(1)存在(本体论),(2)知识(认识论)和(3)伦理和美学价值(价值论)的框架内进行处理。这一努力也将意味着探索这一最初来源的哲学潜力,土耳其语在其中以最纯粹的形式积累。 虽然Lughāt不是简单意义上的字典,但它占据了一件艺术作品的位置,用它所传递的词汇来反映;在这种情况下,土耳其人对思想、信仰和道德的理解,因为后者存在于存在、知识和价值的框架中,并以最纯粹和最简洁的形式存在。丰富的文脉使我们不仅可以把它当作一本字典来读,而且可以把它当作一本知识、文化和智慧之书来读。每一篇文章都应该从哲学的角度来阅读和理解。这样的阅读丰富了文本,使其经久不衰。从哲学的角度来看一篇文章,并不是说这篇文章就是哲学的。相反,这种“哲学”阅读可以定义为:(1)概念化的阅读;(2)产生问题的阅读;(3)不是在单个例子的框架中,而是在整体视角下处理问题的阅读;(4)批判性阅读;(5)连贯地看待语言和思维的阅读;(6)旨在全面处理主题并力求在该框架内保持完整性和一致性的阅读;(7)跨学科阅读;(8)一种最终寻求根据本体论、认识论、伦理和美学价值来建立主题的阅读,使其易于理解;(9)一种考虑历史和传统背景的阅读。在这篇文章中,Dīwān Lughāt al-Turk将带着阐述其中包含的哲学内容的明确目的来阅读;它的主题将在(1)存在(本体论),(2)知识(认识论)和(3)伦理和美学价值(价值论)的框架内进行处理。这一努力也将意味着探索这一最初来源的哲学潜力,土耳其语在其中以最纯粹的形式积累。
本文章由计算机程序翻译,如有差异,请以英文原文为准。
求助全文
约1分钟内获得全文 求助全文
来源期刊
自引率
0.00%
发文量
1
×
引用
GB/T 7714-2015
复制
MLA
复制
APA
复制
导出至
BibTeX EndNote RefMan NoteFirst NoteExpress
×
提示
您的信息不完整,为了账户安全,请先补充。
现在去补充
×
提示
您因"违规操作"
具体请查看互助需知
我知道了
×
提示
确定
请完成安全验证×
copy
已复制链接
快去分享给好友吧!
我知道了
右上角分享
点击右上角分享
0
联系我们:info@booksci.cn Book学术提供免费学术资源搜索服务,方便国内外学者检索中英文文献。致力于提供最便捷和优质的服务体验。 Copyright © 2023 布克学术 All rights reserved.
京ICP备2023020795号-1
ghs 京公网安备 11010802042870号
Book学术文献互助
Book学术文献互助群
群 号:481959085
Book学术官方微信