Photovoice as a Research-Intervention Tool for Youth Neighborhood Activism in Societally Vulnerable Contexts

G. Guariso, Virginia Paloma, Samuel Arias Sánchez, Rocío Garrido Muñoz de Arenillas, M. Ramírez
{"title":"Photovoice as a Research-Intervention Tool for Youth Neighborhood Activism in Societally Vulnerable Contexts","authors":"G. Guariso, Virginia Paloma, Samuel Arias Sánchez, Rocío Garrido Muñoz de Arenillas, M. Ramírez","doi":"10.7728/0703201602","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"Teenagers who live in vulnerable neighborhoods have a higher probability of entering into a vicious circle where they suffer the consequences of an unfair structure and, at the same time, contribute to the maintenance of it. A researchintervention with photovoice was carried out with youth from a vulnerable multicultural neighborhood on the outskirts of Seville (Spain). The objective was to increase the teenagers’ neighborhood activism through an increase in their psychological sense of community, forecast of future participation, and empowerment. Young girls with different cultural roots, between the ages of 13 and 18 years old participated. After the photographs were taken by the participants, a space was opened for reflection on the strengths and challenges of the neighborhood. The photographs were worked on using artistic techniques to express the desired changes and then the group discussed how to make effective changes. Lastly, the extended community was involved through a photography exhibition. We measured the variables of interest through a prepost questionnaire given to the participant group and to a comparison group. Complementary, narratives which emerged during the meetings were analyzed. Participants increased their level of psychological sense of community and their wish to participate in the future, but continued with the same level of empowerment. Theoretical contributions and useful suggestions for researchintervention with photovoice are discussed. Although people’s daily lives today are more frequently spent in dispersed settings, neighborhoods maintain an important role as a point of reference for the construction of the inhabitants’ personal and social identities and for satisfying their need for a sense of belonging (Tartaglia, 2006). Furthermore, neighborhood conditions significantly impact the level of activism and well-being of their inhabitants. Vulnerable neighborhoods characterized by the insufficient provision of resources and services limit the wellbeing and endanger the identity construction process carried out by teenagers (Rankin & Quane, 2002). Communities with high levels of crime, drug dealing, and other indicators of low quality of life are indeed typically characterized by minimal neighborhood activism among youth (Kelly, 2009). It appears therefore necessary to find appropriate research-intervention methods to prepare teenagers with the ability to increase their neighborhood activism in order to change those elements of their environment which impede their well-being. Using the photovoice methodology, this research-intervention experience aimed to increase the level of youth neighborhood activism in a multicultural societally vulnerable neighborhood in the outskirts of Seville (Spain). This study defines neighborhood activism as the process in which teenagers work towards change in neighborhood conditions (Gilster, 2012). Photovoice is a researchintervention strategy whereby the participants take photographs that are later used as stimulus for group reflection on the strengths and challenges of their neighborhood for promoting both an individual and a social change (Nicotera, 2007). This study understands that the environment Global Journal of Community Psychology Practice Volume 7, Issue 3 September 2016 Global Journal of Community Psychology Practice, http://www.gjcpp.org/ Page 4 in which everyone lives exercises significant influence over individual behavior. At the same time, the individual can change the environment in which he/she is placed, in a relationship of reciprocal influence (Balcazar et al., 2012; Paloma & Manzano-Arrondo, 2011). From this perspective, photovoice emerges as a strategy to facilitate the youth’s awareness about the influence the neighborhood exerts on their life and to fuel youth neighborhood activism for the transformation of the environmental conditions. In what follows, we contextualize this study by showing the situation of “Su Eminencia” neighborhood in southern Spain as a vulnerable context for young people. We then expose the theoretical basis upon which this study is constructed. Later, we present the methodology carried out and the results obtained. We conclude by discussing the main theoretical contributions that emerge from this pilot study and useful suggestions for future researchintervention with photovoice. An Overview of Su Eminencia as a Vulnerable Neighborhood The neighborhood “Su Eminencia” is located in the capital of Andalusia (Seville), the southernmost region of Spain. The neighborhood originated in the 1940s, a time when a strong influx of migration was reported from diverse provinces in Andalusia and from Portugal towards the Andalusian capital. Following those changes, the urbanization of the city’s periphery grew in a rapid and disorganized manner, creating a labyrinth of narrow streets built from recycled materials, without any hydraulic, sewer, or electricity systems (Torres, 2005). Not until the 1960s, and thanks to a strong mobilization of the inhabitants, did local administration provide connections to the city’s sewer and electricity systems. In the last few years this neighborhood has received a high percentage of migrants coming mainly from Bolivia, Colombia, China, Morocco, and Romania (Torres, 2011). In fact, the neighborhood can be recognized by the diverse number of commercial activities that migrants manage in this area of the city. Eighteen percent of households in the “Su Eminencia” neighborhood are in a situation of exclusion (Ayuntamiento de Sevilla, 2012). Among the most relevant problems in the neighborhood are the lack of economic resources, unemployment, an uneducated population, widespread drug dealing, drug addiction, and crime (Torres, 2011). These conditions are associated with a psychosocial profile in which teenagers often perceive themselves as victims of uncontrollable superior forces, lack confidence and the ability to gain competence to achieve success in life (Moane, 2003). Furthermore, this experience usually produces conformist behavior, passivity, and a life based on the present moment (Martín-Baró, 1987). Thus, the experiences lived in disadvantaged neighborhoods can become naturalized and interiorized by the younger generations, undermining their membership in community organizations (Wilson, 2000). Accordingly, Putman (2000) notes that “people with lower incomes and those who feel financially strapped are much less engaged in all forms of social and community life than those who are better off” (p. 193). As a consequence, the inactive behavior of teenagers contributes to the maintenance of the neighborhood’s vulnerability, thus hindering their ability to leave this vicious cycle of oppression. These circumstances require researchintervention processes that break this vicious circle through a transformative process where teenagers become active agents of change in their environments. Given the relationship between neighborhood inequity and well-being, neighborhood activism presents an important form of participation to Global Journal of Community Psychology Practice Volume 7, Issue 3 September 2016 Global Journal of Community Psychology Practice, http://www.gjcpp.org/ Page 5 address neighborhood problems (Gilster, 2012). We propose the photovoice strategy to fuel the involvement of youth in vulnerable neighborhoods. Photovoice to Promote Youth Neighborhood Activism Photovoice is a research-intervention strategy whereby, through the use of photographs taken by the participants, group reflection on the challenges and the strengths of their community is promoted with the goal of setting in motion individual and social change (Nicotera, 2007). Wang and Burris (1997) define photovoice’s main objectives as: to allow people to understand the strengths and challenges of their community, to encourage group dialog and reflection about the challenges identified, and to favor processes of change in the community through the involvement of participants. Photovoice has been used in different contexts, involving participants from different genders, ages, nationalities, and cultural backgrounds (Baker & Wang, 2006; Killion & Wang, 2000; Oliffe & Bottorff, 2007). Photovoice allows the collection of important data on how places are experienced by people, thanks to the group reflections on the dynamics of life in these spaces. Furthermore, photovoice can increase the involvement and the collective interest in the community’s issues by inviting people to become advocates for their own and the community’s well-being (Wang & Burris, 1997). Overall, photovoice helps to find out and activate the youth’s awareness of their community and to give them the possibility of making their voice heard and to take action in their environment. For these reasons, community researchers have used the photovoice methodology as a research-intervention tool (e.g., Wang, Morrel-Samuels, Hutchison, Bell, & Pestronk, 2004; Wilson et al., 2007; Strack, Magill, & McDonagh, 2004). To our knowledge, only one other study implemented in southern Spain has used photovoice methodology among young people (Soriano & Cala, 2014). Different from that study, our work uses photovoice methodology with art therapy technique, showing how different art practices can be combined in an innovative way to achieve the goal of promoting youth neighborhood activism. Neighborhood activism is defined as the process by which teenagers work to bring change to the conditions of their neighborhood (Gilster, 2012). The importance of this process for youth goes beyond the immediate impact of their actions, as it provides them with opportunities to acquire significant civic and social skills critical to navigating and transforming their environment in adulthood as well (Kelly, 2009). Many studies have confirmed that neighborhood activism is related to the concepts of psychological sense of community, community participation, and empowerment (Garcia, Giuli","PeriodicalId":87260,"journal":{"name":"Global journal of community psychology practice","volume":"19 1","pages":""},"PeriodicalIF":0.0000,"publicationDate":"2016-09-30","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"2","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Global journal of community psychology practice","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.7728/0703201602","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"","JCRName":"","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 2

Abstract

Teenagers who live in vulnerable neighborhoods have a higher probability of entering into a vicious circle where they suffer the consequences of an unfair structure and, at the same time, contribute to the maintenance of it. A researchintervention with photovoice was carried out with youth from a vulnerable multicultural neighborhood on the outskirts of Seville (Spain). The objective was to increase the teenagers’ neighborhood activism through an increase in their psychological sense of community, forecast of future participation, and empowerment. Young girls with different cultural roots, between the ages of 13 and 18 years old participated. After the photographs were taken by the participants, a space was opened for reflection on the strengths and challenges of the neighborhood. The photographs were worked on using artistic techniques to express the desired changes and then the group discussed how to make effective changes. Lastly, the extended community was involved through a photography exhibition. We measured the variables of interest through a prepost questionnaire given to the participant group and to a comparison group. Complementary, narratives which emerged during the meetings were analyzed. Participants increased their level of psychological sense of community and their wish to participate in the future, but continued with the same level of empowerment. Theoretical contributions and useful suggestions for researchintervention with photovoice are discussed. Although people’s daily lives today are more frequently spent in dispersed settings, neighborhoods maintain an important role as a point of reference for the construction of the inhabitants’ personal and social identities and for satisfying their need for a sense of belonging (Tartaglia, 2006). Furthermore, neighborhood conditions significantly impact the level of activism and well-being of their inhabitants. Vulnerable neighborhoods characterized by the insufficient provision of resources and services limit the wellbeing and endanger the identity construction process carried out by teenagers (Rankin & Quane, 2002). Communities with high levels of crime, drug dealing, and other indicators of low quality of life are indeed typically characterized by minimal neighborhood activism among youth (Kelly, 2009). It appears therefore necessary to find appropriate research-intervention methods to prepare teenagers with the ability to increase their neighborhood activism in order to change those elements of their environment which impede their well-being. Using the photovoice methodology, this research-intervention experience aimed to increase the level of youth neighborhood activism in a multicultural societally vulnerable neighborhood in the outskirts of Seville (Spain). This study defines neighborhood activism as the process in which teenagers work towards change in neighborhood conditions (Gilster, 2012). Photovoice is a researchintervention strategy whereby the participants take photographs that are later used as stimulus for group reflection on the strengths and challenges of their neighborhood for promoting both an individual and a social change (Nicotera, 2007). This study understands that the environment Global Journal of Community Psychology Practice Volume 7, Issue 3 September 2016 Global Journal of Community Psychology Practice, http://www.gjcpp.org/ Page 4 in which everyone lives exercises significant influence over individual behavior. At the same time, the individual can change the environment in which he/she is placed, in a relationship of reciprocal influence (Balcazar et al., 2012; Paloma & Manzano-Arrondo, 2011). From this perspective, photovoice emerges as a strategy to facilitate the youth’s awareness about the influence the neighborhood exerts on their life and to fuel youth neighborhood activism for the transformation of the environmental conditions. In what follows, we contextualize this study by showing the situation of “Su Eminencia” neighborhood in southern Spain as a vulnerable context for young people. We then expose the theoretical basis upon which this study is constructed. Later, we present the methodology carried out and the results obtained. We conclude by discussing the main theoretical contributions that emerge from this pilot study and useful suggestions for future researchintervention with photovoice. An Overview of Su Eminencia as a Vulnerable Neighborhood The neighborhood “Su Eminencia” is located in the capital of Andalusia (Seville), the southernmost region of Spain. The neighborhood originated in the 1940s, a time when a strong influx of migration was reported from diverse provinces in Andalusia and from Portugal towards the Andalusian capital. Following those changes, the urbanization of the city’s periphery grew in a rapid and disorganized manner, creating a labyrinth of narrow streets built from recycled materials, without any hydraulic, sewer, or electricity systems (Torres, 2005). Not until the 1960s, and thanks to a strong mobilization of the inhabitants, did local administration provide connections to the city’s sewer and electricity systems. In the last few years this neighborhood has received a high percentage of migrants coming mainly from Bolivia, Colombia, China, Morocco, and Romania (Torres, 2011). In fact, the neighborhood can be recognized by the diverse number of commercial activities that migrants manage in this area of the city. Eighteen percent of households in the “Su Eminencia” neighborhood are in a situation of exclusion (Ayuntamiento de Sevilla, 2012). Among the most relevant problems in the neighborhood are the lack of economic resources, unemployment, an uneducated population, widespread drug dealing, drug addiction, and crime (Torres, 2011). These conditions are associated with a psychosocial profile in which teenagers often perceive themselves as victims of uncontrollable superior forces, lack confidence and the ability to gain competence to achieve success in life (Moane, 2003). Furthermore, this experience usually produces conformist behavior, passivity, and a life based on the present moment (Martín-Baró, 1987). Thus, the experiences lived in disadvantaged neighborhoods can become naturalized and interiorized by the younger generations, undermining their membership in community organizations (Wilson, 2000). Accordingly, Putman (2000) notes that “people with lower incomes and those who feel financially strapped are much less engaged in all forms of social and community life than those who are better off” (p. 193). As a consequence, the inactive behavior of teenagers contributes to the maintenance of the neighborhood’s vulnerability, thus hindering their ability to leave this vicious cycle of oppression. These circumstances require researchintervention processes that break this vicious circle through a transformative process where teenagers become active agents of change in their environments. Given the relationship between neighborhood inequity and well-being, neighborhood activism presents an important form of participation to Global Journal of Community Psychology Practice Volume 7, Issue 3 September 2016 Global Journal of Community Psychology Practice, http://www.gjcpp.org/ Page 5 address neighborhood problems (Gilster, 2012). We propose the photovoice strategy to fuel the involvement of youth in vulnerable neighborhoods. Photovoice to Promote Youth Neighborhood Activism Photovoice is a research-intervention strategy whereby, through the use of photographs taken by the participants, group reflection on the challenges and the strengths of their community is promoted with the goal of setting in motion individual and social change (Nicotera, 2007). Wang and Burris (1997) define photovoice’s main objectives as: to allow people to understand the strengths and challenges of their community, to encourage group dialog and reflection about the challenges identified, and to favor processes of change in the community through the involvement of participants. Photovoice has been used in different contexts, involving participants from different genders, ages, nationalities, and cultural backgrounds (Baker & Wang, 2006; Killion & Wang, 2000; Oliffe & Bottorff, 2007). Photovoice allows the collection of important data on how places are experienced by people, thanks to the group reflections on the dynamics of life in these spaces. Furthermore, photovoice can increase the involvement and the collective interest in the community’s issues by inviting people to become advocates for their own and the community’s well-being (Wang & Burris, 1997). Overall, photovoice helps to find out and activate the youth’s awareness of their community and to give them the possibility of making their voice heard and to take action in their environment. For these reasons, community researchers have used the photovoice methodology as a research-intervention tool (e.g., Wang, Morrel-Samuels, Hutchison, Bell, & Pestronk, 2004; Wilson et al., 2007; Strack, Magill, & McDonagh, 2004). To our knowledge, only one other study implemented in southern Spain has used photovoice methodology among young people (Soriano & Cala, 2014). Different from that study, our work uses photovoice methodology with art therapy technique, showing how different art practices can be combined in an innovative way to achieve the goal of promoting youth neighborhood activism. Neighborhood activism is defined as the process by which teenagers work to bring change to the conditions of their neighborhood (Gilster, 2012). The importance of this process for youth goes beyond the immediate impact of their actions, as it provides them with opportunities to acquire significant civic and social skills critical to navigating and transforming their environment in adulthood as well (Kelly, 2009). Many studies have confirmed that neighborhood activism is related to the concepts of psychological sense of community, community participation, and empowerment (Garcia, Giuli
光声作为社会弱势情境下青少年邻里行动的研究干预工具
生活在脆弱社区的青少年更有可能陷入恶性循环,在这种恶性循环中,他们承受着不公平结构的后果,同时也为维持这种结构做出了贡献。研究人员对来自西班牙塞维利亚郊区一个弱势多元文化社区的年轻人进行了光声干预。目的是通过增加青少年的社区心理意识、预测未来的参与和授权来增加他们的社区活动。年龄在13岁到18岁之间,有着不同文化背景的年轻女孩参加了这项活动。在参与者拍摄完照片后,开放了一个空间来反思社区的优势和挑战。这些照片是用艺术技巧来表达想要的变化,然后小组讨论如何做出有效的变化。最后,扩展社区通过摄影展参与进来。我们通过给参与者组和对照组的问卷调查来测量感兴趣的变量。对会议期间出现的补充叙述进行了分析。参与者的心理社区意识水平和参与未来的愿望有所提高,但授权水平不变。讨论了光声干预研究的理论贡献和有益建议。虽然今天人们的日常生活更频繁地在分散的环境中度过,但社区作为居民个人和社会身份的构建以及满足他们对归属感的需求的参考点,仍然发挥着重要作用(Tartaglia, 2006)。此外,社区条件显著影响居民的行动主义水平和福祉。以资源和服务供应不足为特征的弱势社区限制了青少年的福祉,并危及青少年的身份建构过程(Rankin & Quane, 2002)。犯罪率高、毒品交易和其他低生活质量指标的社区,确实典型地以年轻人的社区行动主义最小为特征(Kelly, 2009)。因此,似乎有必要找到适当的研究干预方法,使青少年有能力增加他们的邻里行动主义,以改变他们环境中阻碍他们幸福的因素。使用光声方法,本研究-干预经验旨在提高西班牙塞维利亚郊区多元文化社会弱势社区的青年社区行动主义水平。本研究将邻里行动主义定义为青少年为改变邻里环境而努力的过程(Gilster, 2012)。Photovoice是一种研究干预策略,参与者拍摄照片,随后用于刺激群体反思其社区的优势和挑战,以促进个人和社会变革(Nicotera, 2007)。本研究认为,《全球社区心理学实践杂志》2016年9月第7卷第3期《全球社区心理学实践杂志》http://www.gjcpp.org/第4页每个人生活的环境对个人行为具有重大影响。同时,个体可以改变他/她所处的环境,在一种相互影响的关系中(Balcazar et al., 2012;Paloma & Manzano-Arrondo, 2011)。从这个角度来看,光声作为一种策略出现,促进了青年对社区对他们生活的影响的认识,并推动了青年社区行动主义对环境状况的转变。在接下来的文章中,我们通过展示西班牙南部“Su Eminencia”社区作为年轻人的弱势环境的情况,将这项研究置于语境中。然后,我们揭示了构建本研究的理论基础。随后,我们介绍了所采用的方法和所获得的结果。最后,我们讨论了该初步研究的主要理论贡献以及对未来光声干预研究的有用建议。Su Eminencia社区位于西班牙最南端的安达卢西亚(塞维利亚)首府。该社区起源于20世纪40年代,据报道,当时有大量移民从安达卢西亚不同省份和葡萄牙涌入安达卢西亚首都。随着这些变化,城市外围的城市化以一种快速而无序的方式发展,创造了一个由回收材料建造的迷宫般的狭窄街道,没有任何水力、下水道或电力系统(Torres, 2005)。 直到20世纪60年代,由于居民的大力动员,当地政府才为城市的下水道和电力系统提供了连接。在过去的几年里,这个社区接收了很大比例的移民,主要来自玻利维亚、哥伦比亚、中国、摩洛哥和罗马尼亚(Torres, 2011)。事实上,这个社区可以通过移民在城市这个地区经营的各种商业活动来识别。“Su Eminencia”社区中18%的家庭处于被排斥的状态(Ayuntamiento de Sevilla, 2012)。社区中最相关的问题是缺乏经济资源、失业、未受教育的人口、广泛的毒品交易、吸毒成瘾和犯罪(Torres, 2011)。这些情况与青少年的心理社会状况有关,青少年经常认为自己是无法控制的优势力量的受害者,缺乏信心和获得能力以在生活中取得成功的能力(Moane, 2003)。此外,这种经历通常会产生顺从的行为、被动和以当下为基础的生活(Martín-Baró, 1987)。因此,生活在弱势社区的经历可能会被年轻一代归化和内化,从而削弱他们在社区组织中的成员资格(Wilson, 2000)。因此,Putman(2000)注意到“收入较低的人和那些感到经济拮据的人比那些富裕的人更少参与各种形式的社会和社区生活”(第193页)。因此,青少年不积极的行为助长了社区的脆弱性,从而阻碍了他们摆脱这种压迫的恶性循环。这些情况需要研究和干预过程,通过转变过程打破这种恶性循环,使青少年成为环境变化的积极推动者。鉴于社区不平等与福祉之间的关系,社区行动主义为全球社区心理学实践杂志第7卷第3期2016年9月全球社区心理学实践杂志http://www.gjcpp.org/第5页address neighborhood problems (Gilster, 2012)提供了重要的参与形式。我们提出了“光声”策略,以促进弱势社区青年的参与。Photovoice是一种研究干预策略,通过使用参与者拍摄的照片,促进群体对其社区的挑战和优势的反思,目标是启动个人和社会变革(Nicotera, 2007)。Wang和Burris(1997)将photovoice的主要目标定义为:让人们了解他们社区的优势和挑战,鼓励对所确定的挑战进行小组对话和反思,并通过参与者的参与来支持社区的变革过程。Photovoice已经在不同的语境中使用,涉及来自不同性别、年龄、国籍和文化背景的参与者(Baker & Wang, 2006;Killion & Wang, 2000;Oliffe & Bottorff, 2007)。Photovoice允许收集关于人们如何体验这些地方的重要数据,这要归功于对这些空间中生活动态的集体反思。此外,photovoice可以通过邀请人们成为他们自己和社区福祉的倡导者来增加对社区问题的参与和集体兴趣(Wang & Burris, 1997)。总的来说,photovoice有助于发现并激活青年对社区的意识,让他们有可能在他们的环境中发出自己的声音并采取行动。由于这些原因,社区研究人员使用光声方法作为研究干预工具(例如,Wang, Morrel-Samuels, Hutchison, Bell, & Pestronk, 2004;Wilson et al., 2007;Strack, Magill, & McDonagh, 2004)。据我们所知,只有在西班牙南部实施的另一项研究在年轻人中使用了光声方法(Soriano & Cala, 2014)。与该研究不同的是,我们的工作使用了光声方法和艺术治疗技术,展示了如何以一种创新的方式将不同的艺术实践结合起来,以实现促进青少年社区行动主义的目标。邻里行动主义被定义为青少年努力改变邻里环境的过程(Gilster, 2012)。这个过程对青年的重要性超越了他们行为的直接影响,因为它为他们提供了获得重要的公民和社会技能的机会,这些技能对于他们成年后导航和改变他们的环境至关重要(Kelly, 2009)。
本文章由计算机程序翻译,如有差异,请以英文原文为准。
求助全文
约1分钟内获得全文 求助全文
来源期刊
自引率
0.00%
发文量
0
×
引用
GB/T 7714-2015
复制
MLA
复制
APA
复制
导出至
BibTeX EndNote RefMan NoteFirst NoteExpress
×
提示
您的信息不完整,为了账户安全,请先补充。
现在去补充
×
提示
您因"违规操作"
具体请查看互助需知
我知道了
×
提示
确定
请完成安全验证×
copy
已复制链接
快去分享给好友吧!
我知道了
右上角分享
点击右上角分享
0
联系我们:info@booksci.cn Book学术提供免费学术资源搜索服务,方便国内外学者检索中英文文献。致力于提供最便捷和优质的服务体验。 Copyright © 2023 布克学术 All rights reserved.
京ICP备2023020795号-1
ghs 京公网安备 11010802042870号
Book学术文献互助
Book学术文献互助群
群 号:481959085
Book学术官方微信