Ifeoluwa Bodunde, Alice Karanja, S. McMullin, K. Mausch, A. Ickowitz
{"title":"Increasing fruit and vegetables consumption among children: a systematic review of animated nutrition interventions","authors":"Ifeoluwa Bodunde, Alice Karanja, S. McMullin, K. Mausch, A. Ickowitz","doi":"10.26596/wn.202213429-45","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"Background: Low consumption of fruits and vegetables among children can lead to deprivation of micronutrients necessary for growth and development and predispose them to NCDs later in life. Low consumption of these nutrient-rich foods is related to high consumption of nutrient-poor, high-energy foods, which leads to childhood overweight and obesity. Many children do not consume enough fruits and vegetables to meet recommendations. This review aims to assess the effectiveness of animated interventions in increasing children's fruit and vegetable consumption. \nMethods: Articles on animated interventions for increasing fruit and vegetable consumption among children were systematically reviewed from Web of Science, PubMed, and Google Scholar. For the literature searches, inclusion and exclusion criteria were established, and the methodology followed the PRISMA recommendations. Extracted data were synthesized to show the effectiveness of interventions. \nResults: Thirteen studies (2003-2017) of animated interventions targeting children (3-12 years) designed to increase their consumption of fruits and vegetables met the criteria for inclusion in the systematic review. Most of the studies (69.2%) were in the United States, with no studies in LMICs identified. The animation interventions used games (46.2%), characters (23.1%), adventures (23.1%), and comic books (7.7 %). 11 of the analysed studies revealed positive or neutral effects of interventions on fruit and vegetable consumption. Parental participation, goal setting, and rewards were identified as facilitators of success. Identified interventions were effective in the short term (follow-up <12months). The games and adventure interventions had the greatest effect, with multi-component interventions most effective in increasing fruit and vegetable intake. \nConclusion: There is a need for more research to determine the effectiveness of such interventions over extended periods. Multi-component interventions especially including parental involvement, goal setting, and rewards should be leveraged in designing similar interventions in LMICs since there was a conspicuous absence of such studies found in the literature.","PeriodicalId":23779,"journal":{"name":"World review of nutrition and dietetics","volume":"11 1","pages":""},"PeriodicalIF":0.0000,"publicationDate":"2022-12-31","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"World review of nutrition and dietetics","FirstCategoryId":"3","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.26596/wn.202213429-45","RegionNum":4,"RegionCategory":"医学","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"","JCRName":"","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
Abstract
Background: Low consumption of fruits and vegetables among children can lead to deprivation of micronutrients necessary for growth and development and predispose them to NCDs later in life. Low consumption of these nutrient-rich foods is related to high consumption of nutrient-poor, high-energy foods, which leads to childhood overweight and obesity. Many children do not consume enough fruits and vegetables to meet recommendations. This review aims to assess the effectiveness of animated interventions in increasing children's fruit and vegetable consumption.
Methods: Articles on animated interventions for increasing fruit and vegetable consumption among children were systematically reviewed from Web of Science, PubMed, and Google Scholar. For the literature searches, inclusion and exclusion criteria were established, and the methodology followed the PRISMA recommendations. Extracted data were synthesized to show the effectiveness of interventions.
Results: Thirteen studies (2003-2017) of animated interventions targeting children (3-12 years) designed to increase their consumption of fruits and vegetables met the criteria for inclusion in the systematic review. Most of the studies (69.2%) were in the United States, with no studies in LMICs identified. The animation interventions used games (46.2%), characters (23.1%), adventures (23.1%), and comic books (7.7 %). 11 of the analysed studies revealed positive or neutral effects of interventions on fruit and vegetable consumption. Parental participation, goal setting, and rewards were identified as facilitators of success. Identified interventions were effective in the short term (follow-up <12months). The games and adventure interventions had the greatest effect, with multi-component interventions most effective in increasing fruit and vegetable intake.
Conclusion: There is a need for more research to determine the effectiveness of such interventions over extended periods. Multi-component interventions especially including parental involvement, goal setting, and rewards should be leveraged in designing similar interventions in LMICs since there was a conspicuous absence of such studies found in the literature.
背景:儿童水果和蔬菜摄入量低可能导致缺乏生长发育所必需的微量营养素,并使他们在以后的生活中易患非传染性疾病。这些营养丰富的食物的低摄入量与营养贫乏的高能量食物的高摄入量有关,从而导致儿童超重和肥胖。许多儿童没有摄入足够的水果和蔬菜来满足建议。本综述旨在评估动画干预在增加儿童水果和蔬菜消费方面的有效性。方法:系统地回顾了Web of Science、PubMed和Google Scholar上关于增加儿童水果和蔬菜消费的动画干预的文章。对于文献检索,建立了纳入和排除标准,方法遵循PRISMA的建议。提取的数据进行综合,以显示干预措施的有效性。结果:13项(2003-2017)针对3-12岁儿童的动画干预研究(旨在增加他们的水果和蔬菜摄入量)符合纳入系统评价的标准。大多数研究(69.2%)在美国进行,没有发现针对中低收入国家的研究。动画干预使用游戏(46.2%)、角色(23.1%)、冒险(23.1%)和漫画书(7.7%)。分析的研究中有11项显示干预措施对水果和蔬菜消费的积极或中性影响。父母的参与、目标的设定和奖励被认为是成功的促进因素。确定的干预措施在短期内有效(随访<12个月)。游戏和冒险干预效果最大,多成分干预在增加水果和蔬菜摄入量方面最有效。结论:需要更多的研究来确定这种干预措施在较长时间内的有效性。多成分干预,特别是包括父母参与、目标设定和奖励,应该在中低收入国家设计类似的干预措施时加以利用,因为文献中明显缺乏此类研究。
期刊介绍:
Volumes in this series consist of exceptionally thorough reviews on topics selected as either fundamental to improved understanding of human and animal nutrition, useful in resolving present controversies, or relevant to problems of social and preventive medicine that depend for their solution on progress in nutrition. Many of the individual articles have been judged as among the most comprehensive reviews ever published on the given topic. Since the first volume appeared in 1959, the series has earned repeated praise for the quality of its scholarship and the reputation of its authors.